You are here: Home » Companies » Opinion
Business Standard

8 sectors double shareholders' wealth in 4 yrs

Vishal Chhabria & Deepak B Korgaonkar  |  Mumbai 

Robust growth in sales and profits has helped them grow the combined market cap by 92 per cent to Rs 17 lakh crore during FY08-12

Last four years have been the worst of times for most countries across the world since the depression of the 1930s. India, too, has suffered, but on a relative basis — it has done better, recording the second-best growth rate after China.

But, despite these tough times, select sectors have done remarkably well, helping Indian markets shine. Automobiles, auto ancillaries, banks, fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG), pharmaceuticals, tobacco producers, tyre makers and are the eight sectors that clearly stand out. They have reported a compounded annual growth rate (CAGR) of 22.1 per cent and 19.5 per cent in sales and adjusted net profit during FY08-12.

A lot of their success is consequent to healthy demand in the domestic market. Their aggregate adjusted net profit had grown from Rs 29,991 crore in 2003-04 to Rs 57,694 crore in 2007-08. Those were the times when Indian and global economies were doing well. However, even during the tough times that followed the global crisis of 2008, their aggregate profits continued to rise and stood at Rs 1.19 lakh crore for the year ended March 2012 (FY12). The markets have been quick to reward them. While their market capitalisation increased 148 per cent to Rs 8.84 lakh crore during FY04-08, compared to the Sensex’s 194 per cent, it has nearly doubled to Rs 17 lakh crore between FY08 and FY12 against the Sensex’s 6.3 per cent.

In contrast, the negative outliers are the core sectors like capital goods, power, metals, construction, textiles and refiners, which have fared poorly during the last four years, thanks to issues pertaining to economic slowdown, high debt, hurdles in environment clearance and input availability among others. New entrants, in terms of those which didn’t have a significant presence like realty (high debt, subdued demand) and telecom (stiff competition, regulatory woes) have also lagged. While their combined profits are up by just Rs 838 crore during FY08-12 (to Rs 99,574 crore in FY12), sales have grown at a of 15.5 per cent to Rs 22.96 lakh crore. Not surprisingly, their combined market cap is down 20 per cent.

The outperformers
The auto sector has been a star performer, with its net profits clocking a of 34 per cent, fastest among the eight sectors. New vehicle launches, cut in excise duties and low helped the industry. However, with excise duties returning to normalised levels and ruling high, growth rates have again slowed in recent months, which experts believe is a temporary phase–they expect growth to revive in the long run. Among responsible for the sector’s stellar show during FY08-12 are Tata Motors, and Mahindra and Mahindra. The auto sector’s performance also had its influence on the auto ancillary sector, wherein Bosch Exide, Amara Raja and Fag Bearings did well both in terms of profits and shareholders’ wealth creation. Tyre also did well, but not as well as auto

In Rs crore 2011-12

Mar 31,’12

Compounded Annual Growth Rate (%)
Net sales Adjusted PAT Market Cap


FY08-12 FY04-08 FY08-12 FY04-08 FY08-12
Tobacco products  28878 6,548 182,962 19.2 15.8 18.3 18.2 31.9 26.5
FMCG  73213 7,273 234,637 11.3 18.1 8.5 17.6 20.1 24.3
Tyres  32401 1,182 12,388 19.8 23.3 35.2 14.1 28.3 21.4
Automobile  310527 22,293 226,470 22.5 31.4 26.1 34.0 14.1 20.6
Pharmaceuticals  101901 11,957 275,389 19.5 15.0 23.2 8.6 18.1 19.6
Auto ancillaries  62142 3,605 67,553 22.2 21.7 21.9 14.0 29.5 16.6
Banks  511243 62,747 663,858 20.5 21.6 15.2 19.3 33.5 12.6
Fertilisers  63360 3,492 37,178 14.3 12.7 42.9 28.7 20.0 10.7
Realty  10035 798 16,994 41.3 -8.7 - -31.3 205.1 -32.3
Construction  31405 239 9,820 33.8 21.0 54.3 -26.9 121.2 -21.7
Mining & mineral 
26144 10,582 88,828 39.9 19.1 65.6 18.7 124.2 -11.4
Power generation & 
54112 3,169 59,624 13.5 22.0 15.2 -4.6 28.7 -10.8
Capital goods - 
electrical equipment
96818 9,145 129,174 34.6 16.1 43.6 15.7 64.0 -10.6
Telecomm - service  81645 -289 139,008 24.6 21.9 40.7 - 41.9 -8.6
Steel  319,949 14,461 189,545 40.6 5.8 37.3 -9.5 56.0 -7.4
Refineries  1,257,343 33,031 358,533 20.5 18.9 13.2 3.3 24.5 -5.0
Non-ferrous metals  143,855 15,406 157,591 49.2 9.3 46.7 4.5 46.5 -2.8
Sugar  25,001 469 6,858 22.3 22.7 29.3 2.5 53.0 -2.4
Textiles  132,399 4,782 61,812 22.5 15.0 - 4.7 33.3 -2.4
developers & operators
73,986 5,425 91,674 27.4 21.4 38.5 18.2 128.1 -2.2
Capital goods - Non 
electrical equipment 
43,467 2,356 44,459 26.0 11.6 40.4 -2.6 54.4 -0.9
Note: Only common sample has been taken into account, for instance, not listed in 2004 are not considered
Source: CapitalinePlus; Data complied by BS Research

With farm incomes rising, it has led to rising aspirations among Indians based in smaller towns and villages, which have helped deliver fast growth. Their aggregate adjusted net profits has grown at a of 17.6 per cent, more than double the 8.5 per cent reported during FY04-08. In fact, auto and are the only ones to have reported higher growth rates (both in sales and net profit) during FY08-12, compared to FY04-08. Not surprisingly, the gains for their shareholders have also been fantastic. it is the same case with tobacco companies, which include ITC, VST Inds and Godfrey Phillips.

Among the top scorers, the sector has also done well, but it could have been higher on the toppers chart. Subdued by Ranbaxy (due to US Food and Drug Administration-related issues) and Glenmark pulled down the performance. However, both are expected to see a visible improvement in their performance –Ranbaxy’s FDA issues are being sorted and Glenmark is seeing expansion in its niche product portfolio.

The positive outliers are Lupin, Cadila Healthcare, Torrent Pharma, Ipca, Dr Reddy’s Lab and Sun Pharma, which have grown at a fast clip, as well as rewarded their shareholders well. Lupin, which saw fast growth in its US and Japan operations, tops the chart wherein sales and profit grew at 26-28 per cent, while the market cap widened 58 per cent during FY08-12. Among mid-caps, Cadila and Ipca did well by growing at a fast pace in the domestic market—Cadila also did equally well in the US. On the other hand, Dr Reddy’s, while growing strongly in the US, also reported robust sales in Russia and other emerging markets. Sun has delivered a decent show. Its performance could have been better, had it not faced problems with its acquisition of Israel-based Taro.

Surprisingly, despite volatile times, India’s banking sector clocked over 19 per cent in aggregate adjusted profits during FY08-12 and that, too, when the top two banks (State Bank of India and ICICI Bank) saw profit growth of 11-15 per cent. Other banks saw profits growing between 20-80 per cent. This performance is commendable, given the trend in rising non-performing assets and restructured loans and the recent slowdown in growth rates, which has restricted their performance on the bourses.

The underperformers
The big surprise is the refinery space. Here, while Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) and Indian Oil Corp (IOC) have seen a rising trend in profits, RIL’s dismal performance on the bourses (25 per cent fall in market cap) has pulled down the sector, which can be attributed to worries over fall in margins, excess cash lowering return ratios and declining gas output. What’s surprising is that even as oil marketing (Hindustan Petroleum Corp, Bharat Petroleum Corp) saw a decline in profit (in FY12 over FY08), their market value rose.

Steel Authority of India’s market value and profits have tanked by half, which is largely responsible for the sector’s dismal show on the bourses. Tata Steel, which has also seen its profits fall by over 50 per cent, has lost just 10 per cent in market value. However, its performance would have been worse had the company not raised funds from promoters to lower its debt-equity ratio. The positive outlier is Jindal Steel and Power. Its profits rose 80 per cent in four years, leading to a 60 per cent rise in market capitalisation. So, has Bhushan Steel.

In capital goods, Havells, Siemens, Engineers India and Larsen and Toubro (L&T) have seen an improvement in profits. However, barring L&T (market cap down about 10 per cent), the other three have seen a surge in their market values. On the other hand, Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd (Bhel) (down 37 per cent in market value) and ABB (down 28 per cent) pulled down the sector’s performance on the bourses. Bhel, despite having reported rising profits, is down due to concerns over order inflow led by slowdown in the power sector.

The deterioration in the profitability and concerns over growth in the core sectors are key reasons for the decline in shareholders’ wealth. In fact, these were the sectors that did exceptionally well during FY04-08.

But don’t write them off so fast. Experts say when the Indian economic growth looks up (to above 8 per cent levels) on a sustainable basis, these sectors will rebound.

First Published: Mon, August 06 2012. 00:45 IST