Court order vindicates our stand on PC: Govt

Government today hailed the verdict of Delhi court dismissing a plea to make Home Minister an accused in the 2G case, saying it vindicates its stand and also of the Congress party.

A number of senior Ministers including Pranab Mukherjee, Kapil Sibal, and said the government is clear that Chidambaram had no role in the matter and allegations against him were political.

"We always know that our colleague (Chidambaram) in Parliament and in Government is absolutely not culpable for anything against...That were put forward by Subramaniam Swamy...I know the evidence and shifted through the evidence and there is absolutely no responsibility that can be foisted on my colleague," Telecom Minister Kapil Sibal said.

Terming it a "good judgement", Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee told reporters in Kolkata, "it is a relief because somebody was unnecessarily being prosecuted. Even in the judgement of the in the main cases it was clearly mentioned that advice of the Finance Ministry was not listened to. I welcome the judgement."

Sibal also said the apex court's verdict on the 2G issue also made it clear that Chidambaram was not culpable for anything.

He also attacked the opposition leaders saying that they were seeking to take political advantage and trying to influence the court.

The Telecom Minister alleged that some Opposition leaders in Parliament were making "very ugly" statements that are not expected of responsible members.

Stating that the Opposition leaders should reflect on the "irresponsible" manner in which they were making "scathing allegations" against his colleague, Sibal stressed Chidambaram was infact one colleague who had told Raja that he should have got a market discovery done on spectrum.

Sibal added "the court verdict has vindicated the stand of the Congress party and the government."

Expressing happiness over the judgement, Law Minister Salman Khurshid said it was a "relief" for the government. "...It is a relief, especially when it is a judgement coming from a court," he told reporters here.

Khurshid said he was "happy" for Chidambaram as well as the "system" after the judgement. The Law Minister termed his Cabinet colleague as an "important" and "significant" member of the UPA government.

Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni alleged that Swamy did all this to keep himself in focus.

"We all know Swamy for years. It is not for the first time that his petition has been dismissed. Earlier also he has moved many petitions and all his pleas were dismissed. He did it to keep himself in focus in the public domain," she said.

When asked that Swamy is planning to move higher court, Sibal retorted back saying, "he will go to High Court and Supreme Court...He will appeal to God."

The Telecom Minister also took a dig at the media on the issue.

"I think the system has gone wrong. The way the TV channels have debates one day before the hearing as if they will tend to influence the hearing and direct in which the judiciary should go. This is something that has to be deprecated.

"Therefore all those institutions which are responsible for disseminating information should also reflect on the role they should play in the context of very serious cases before the court," he said.

image
Business Standard
177 22
Business Standard

Court order vindicates our stand on PC: Govt

Press Trust of India  |  New Delhi 

Government today hailed the verdict of Delhi court dismissing a plea to make Home Minister an accused in the 2G case, saying it vindicates its stand and also of the Congress party.

A number of senior Ministers including Pranab Mukherjee, Kapil Sibal, and said the government is clear that Chidambaram had no role in the matter and allegations against him were political.

"We always know that our colleague (Chidambaram) in Parliament and in Government is absolutely not culpable for anything against...That were put forward by Subramaniam Swamy...I know the evidence and shifted through the evidence and there is absolutely no responsibility that can be foisted on my colleague," Telecom Minister Kapil Sibal said.

Terming it a "good judgement", Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee told reporters in Kolkata, "it is a relief because somebody was unnecessarily being prosecuted. Even in the judgement of the in the main cases it was clearly mentioned that advice of the Finance Ministry was not listened to. I welcome the judgement."

Sibal also said the apex court's verdict on the 2G issue also made it clear that Chidambaram was not culpable for anything.

He also attacked the opposition leaders saying that they were seeking to take political advantage and trying to influence the court.

The Telecom Minister alleged that some Opposition leaders in Parliament were making "very ugly" statements that are not expected of responsible members.

Stating that the Opposition leaders should reflect on the "irresponsible" manner in which they were making "scathing allegations" against his colleague, Sibal stressed Chidambaram was infact one colleague who had told Raja that he should have got a market discovery done on spectrum.

Sibal added "the court verdict has vindicated the stand of the Congress party and the government."

Expressing happiness over the judgement, Law Minister Salman Khurshid said it was a "relief" for the government. "...It is a relief, especially when it is a judgement coming from a court," he told reporters here.

Khurshid said he was "happy" for Chidambaram as well as the "system" after the judgement. The Law Minister termed his Cabinet colleague as an "important" and "significant" member of the UPA government.

Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni alleged that Swamy did all this to keep himself in focus.

"We all know Swamy for years. It is not for the first time that his petition has been dismissed. Earlier also he has moved many petitions and all his pleas were dismissed. He did it to keep himself in focus in the public domain," she said.

When asked that Swamy is planning to move higher court, Sibal retorted back saying, "he will go to High Court and Supreme Court...He will appeal to God."

The Telecom Minister also took a dig at the media on the issue.

"I think the system has gone wrong. The way the TV channels have debates one day before the hearing as if they will tend to influence the hearing and direct in which the judiciary should go. This is something that has to be deprecated.

"Therefore all those institutions which are responsible for disseminating information should also reflect on the role they should play in the context of very serious cases before the court," he said.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Court order vindicates our stand on PC: Govt

Government today hailed the verdict of Delhi court dismissing a plea to make Home Minister P Chidambaram an accused in the 2G case, saying it vindicates its stand and also of the Congress party.

Government today hailed the verdict of Delhi court dismissing a plea to make Home Minister an accused in the 2G case, saying it vindicates its stand and also of the Congress party.

A number of senior Ministers including Pranab Mukherjee, Kapil Sibal, and said the government is clear that Chidambaram had no role in the matter and allegations against him were political.

"We always know that our colleague (Chidambaram) in Parliament and in Government is absolutely not culpable for anything against...That were put forward by Subramaniam Swamy...I know the evidence and shifted through the evidence and there is absolutely no responsibility that can be foisted on my colleague," Telecom Minister Kapil Sibal said.

Terming it a "good judgement", Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee told reporters in Kolkata, "it is a relief because somebody was unnecessarily being prosecuted. Even in the judgement of the in the main cases it was clearly mentioned that advice of the Finance Ministry was not listened to. I welcome the judgement."

Sibal also said the apex court's verdict on the 2G issue also made it clear that Chidambaram was not culpable for anything.

He also attacked the opposition leaders saying that they were seeking to take political advantage and trying to influence the court.

The Telecom Minister alleged that some Opposition leaders in Parliament were making "very ugly" statements that are not expected of responsible members.

Stating that the Opposition leaders should reflect on the "irresponsible" manner in which they were making "scathing allegations" against his colleague, Sibal stressed Chidambaram was infact one colleague who had told Raja that he should have got a market discovery done on spectrum.

Sibal added "the court verdict has vindicated the stand of the Congress party and the government."

Expressing happiness over the judgement, Law Minister Salman Khurshid said it was a "relief" for the government. "...It is a relief, especially when it is a judgement coming from a court," he told reporters here.

Khurshid said he was "happy" for Chidambaram as well as the "system" after the judgement. The Law Minister termed his Cabinet colleague as an "important" and "significant" member of the UPA government.

Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni alleged that Swamy did all this to keep himself in focus.

"We all know Swamy for years. It is not for the first time that his petition has been dismissed. Earlier also he has moved many petitions and all his pleas were dismissed. He did it to keep himself in focus in the public domain," she said.

When asked that Swamy is planning to move higher court, Sibal retorted back saying, "he will go to High Court and Supreme Court...He will appeal to God."

The Telecom Minister also took a dig at the media on the issue.

"I think the system has gone wrong. The way the TV channels have debates one day before the hearing as if they will tend to influence the hearing and direct in which the judiciary should go. This is something that has to be deprecated.

"Therefore all those institutions which are responsible for disseminating information should also reflect on the role they should play in the context of very serious cases before the court," he said.

image
Business Standard
177 22

More News

  • Signs of realty revival ahead of festive season Signs of realty revival ahead of festive season
  • Amit Chandra Bain Capital's Amit Chandra joins Tata Sons board

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard