You are here: Home » Economy & Policy » News
Business Standard

Trai rings in telecom M&A game-changer

BS Reporters  |  New Delhi 

Operators with 35% combined market or revenue share can merge, case-wise approval possible if joint share up to 60%; new ground rules on spectrum.

Mergers of with a combined market share or adjusted gross revenue of less than 35 per cent in a circle should be permitted, according to new recommendations by sector regulator If the combined market share is 35-60 per cent, the government could consider allowing a merger on a case-by-case basis.

In no circumstances should mergers be allowed if the combined market share would exceed 60 per cent, according to (the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India).

The move is expected to encourage much-needed consolidation in the telecom industry, where there are already more than 10-12 players in each circle. Many such operators in financial difficulties could then get a way out.

Some of the half a dozen-odd new operators given licences in 2008 would get a window of opportunity to exit their loss-making businesses. Telcos such as STel, Videocon, (MTS), (Uninor), Loop and Etisalat DB account for only 6.38 per cent of the telecom market. Some of them have asked the government for an exit policy, the norms for which would be determined by


* Telcos with combined market share up to 35% in a circle can merge

* For 35-60% share, mergers can be considered case by case

* Entities with 60%-plus share can’t merge in any case

* Incumbent operators must pay for excess spectrum beyond 6.2 MHz at current price

* Stiff riders for spectrum-sharing; delinking spectrum from service usage mooted

Under the new recommendations, in the Delhi circle it would theoretically be possible for Airtel to merge with Aircel or Idea Cellular, and be considered for a merger with Vodafone. Airtel has 20.51 per cent market share based on data of August 2011, Aircel has 5.40 per cent, Idea Cellular 10.4 per cent and Vodafone 19.7 per cent.

Earlier recommendations, which the department of telecommunications asked it to reconsider, said mergers of entities with a combined share of up to 30 per cent should be allowed. That would have meant a hypothetical Airtel-Idea Cellular or a Airtel-Vodafone merger would not be permitted in Delhi. Currently, mergers are permitted provided the joint market share is not more than 40 per cent and there is a three-year lock-in period.

The new recommendations would also significantly liberalise the amount of spectrum the merged entity can retain: up to 25 per cent of the total spectrum available with all the operators in the circle. Earlier, the merged entity could retain only 14.4 MHz and had to return the rest to the government. In the new plan, the merged operator can retain 16-17 MHz, according to officials’ calculations of spectrum availability in various circles.

Ernst & Young telecom industry leader said, “This will put consolidation on a fast track, after which three-five players will have enough competition. That the combined entity can retain 25 per cent of the total spectrum is also a step forward in this direction.” The GSM industry lobby, Cellular Operators’ Association of India director general, Rajan Mathews, said, “The new merger norms will give enough flexibility to operators. It will be very effective, practical and conducive for the operators in this scenario.”

has also recommended the government explore the freeing of spectrum usage linked to a specified service. officials say, for instance, users of 1,800 MHz, who currently have to use it to provide only 2G services, can also use it for 3G services. However, the process would entail substantial re-pricing of spectrum to ensure a level playing field for operators. The regulator will release a consultation paper to deal with this issue.

It has reiterated the stand that operators with excess spectrum beyond 6.2 MHz must pay for it based on current prices, determined by a committee.

The stand has been criticised by existing players such as Bharti Airtel, Vodafone Essar and Idea Cellular, among others, who will have to fork out nearly Rs 17,000 crore to hold spectrum beyond 6.2 MHz if the recommendation is implemented. The COAI has opposed the move.

has suggested permitting spectrum sharing, but with stiff riders. Sharing would be permitted only between two spectrum holders, so an operator with a UASL licence without spectrum cannot share with a licensee who has spectrum. Sharing would be for five years and could be renewed. The total spectrum shared should not exceed the limit prescribed for mergers. In a clear move to steer clear of the 3G controversy around operators offering services through roaming pacts, has clarified that spectrum obtained through auction can be shared only if the auction conditions provide for it.

First Published: Fri, November 04 2011. 00:02 IST