Business Standard

Sebi questions USE on trade concentration

Ashish Rukhaiyar & Palak Shah  |  Mumbai 

Allegations on alone accounting for bulk of turnover, something not permitted under the rules.

The (USE) has come under the regulatory scanner for alleged concentration of trades by a single member. The regulator has questioned the effectiveness of the exchange’s surveillance and risk mechanism measures that allowed such an occurrence.

According to reports, only a few brokers account for a majority of the volume registered on USE. More important, Gurgaon-based Jaypee Capital, also a shareholder in USE, accounts for nearly 80 per cent of the turnover. USE currently operates in the currency derivatives space and offers currency futures in all the four currency pairs permitted by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi). It is also one of the only two stock exchanges in the country to offer in the dollar-rupee pair.
 

REGULATOR TALK
  • says such practices are against the spirit of law
  • Surveillance, risk mechanisms should throw such alerts, the regulator asserts 
  • Jaypee Capital accounted for nearly 80% volume on USE
  • Jaypee is a shareholder in USE; public sector stakeholder banks account for only a marginal share in volumes

“This puts a big question mark on the surveillance mechanism, as there should have been alerts thrown up by the system and the exchange should have taken note of it," said an official familiar with the development. "Questions have been raised as this is something the regulator is not comfortable with. It is against the spirit of the law."

Sebi has clearly said on numerous occasions that concentration of positions with a single member will not be entertained and exchanges should have robust surveillance and risk mechanism measures to monitor such developments.

The regulator has also directed exchanges to put in place systems to monitor "position concentration, open interest across trading members... alerts on large traded quantity." Further, "exchanges were also advised to suitably warn their members against self trades," in a surveillance meet held in December 2008.

Jaypee Capital is a direct shareholder in USE. Gaurav Arora, managing director and founder of the brokerage entity, and his son, Saurav Arora, hold another one per cent each. USE chief executive officer and managing director, T S Nayaranaswami, could not be reached for comments, despite repeated attempts.

"Concentration of positions with one single entity is a clear breach of FUTP (Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices)," says Ameet Naik of Naik, Naik & Co. "One cannot have brokers with trading rights, as that was the whole idea behind pushing for demutualisation. Then, there are also codes and ethics followed by brokers, violation of which could have serious impact," says Naik, who specialises in securities regulations.

Data shows that while Jaypee Capital accounted for nearly 80 per cent of the turnover, some of the banks (Andhra Bank, Union Bank of India, Indian Bank, Bank of India and Bank of Baroda) were responsible for a marginal share in the volume. USE’s stakeholders include the Bombay Stock Exchange, which owns 15 per cent, along with 28 banks and three corporate houses.

Last Friday, the volume on USE dropped significantly to Rs 6,514 crore after clocking a little over Rs 12,000 crore the previous day. Interestingly, MCX Stock Exchange (MCX-SX) and the National Stock Exchange registered volumes of Rs 29,992 crore and Rs 35,393 crore, respectively. On Monday, USE registered a turnover of Rs 8,038 crore, while and clocked volumes of Rs 26,616 crore and Rs 19,067 crore. USE’s first-day turnover had surpassed the combined currency segment of NSE and MCX-SX. The exchange had made a big-bang debut last year, cornering a near 52 per cent market share in the currency derivatives segment. Jaypee and Union Bank, incidentally, conducted the first trade on the exchange.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Sebi questions USE on trade concentration

Allegations on Jaypee Capital alone accounting for bulk of turnover, something not permitted under the rules.

Allegations on alone accounting for bulk of turnover, something not permitted under the rules.

The (USE) has come under the regulatory scanner for alleged concentration of trades by a single member. The regulator has questioned the effectiveness of the exchange’s surveillance and risk mechanism measures that allowed such an occurrence.

According to reports, only a few brokers account for a majority of the volume registered on USE. More important, Gurgaon-based Jaypee Capital, also a shareholder in USE, accounts for nearly 80 per cent of the turnover. USE currently operates in the currency derivatives space and offers currency futures in all the four currency pairs permitted by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi). It is also one of the only two stock exchanges in the country to offer in the dollar-rupee pair.
 

REGULATOR TALK
  • says such practices are against the spirit of law
  • Surveillance, risk mechanisms should throw such alerts, the regulator asserts 
  • Jaypee Capital accounted for nearly 80% volume on USE
  • Jaypee is a shareholder in USE; public sector stakeholder banks account for only a marginal share in volumes

“This puts a big question mark on the surveillance mechanism, as there should have been alerts thrown up by the system and the exchange should have taken note of it," said an official familiar with the development. "Questions have been raised as this is something the regulator is not comfortable with. It is against the spirit of the law."

Sebi has clearly said on numerous occasions that concentration of positions with a single member will not be entertained and exchanges should have robust surveillance and risk mechanism measures to monitor such developments.

The regulator has also directed exchanges to put in place systems to monitor "position concentration, open interest across trading members... alerts on large traded quantity." Further, "exchanges were also advised to suitably warn their members against self trades," in a surveillance meet held in December 2008.

Jaypee Capital is a direct shareholder in USE. Gaurav Arora, managing director and founder of the brokerage entity, and his son, Saurav Arora, hold another one per cent each. USE chief executive officer and managing director, T S Nayaranaswami, could not be reached for comments, despite repeated attempts.

"Concentration of positions with one single entity is a clear breach of FUTP (Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices)," says Ameet Naik of Naik, Naik & Co. "One cannot have brokers with trading rights, as that was the whole idea behind pushing for demutualisation. Then, there are also codes and ethics followed by brokers, violation of which could have serious impact," says Naik, who specialises in securities regulations.

Data shows that while Jaypee Capital accounted for nearly 80 per cent of the turnover, some of the banks (Andhra Bank, Union Bank of India, Indian Bank, Bank of India and Bank of Baroda) were responsible for a marginal share in the volume. USE’s stakeholders include the Bombay Stock Exchange, which owns 15 per cent, along with 28 banks and three corporate houses.

Last Friday, the volume on USE dropped significantly to Rs 6,514 crore after clocking a little over Rs 12,000 crore the previous day. Interestingly, MCX Stock Exchange (MCX-SX) and the National Stock Exchange registered volumes of Rs 29,992 crore and Rs 35,393 crore, respectively. On Monday, USE registered a turnover of Rs 8,038 crore, while and clocked volumes of Rs 26,616 crore and Rs 19,067 crore. USE’s first-day turnover had surpassed the combined currency segment of NSE and MCX-SX. The exchange had made a big-bang debut last year, cornering a near 52 per cent market share in the currency derivatives segment. Jaypee and Union Bank, incidentally, conducted the first trade on the exchange.

image

LIVE MARKET

BSE 25818.93

54.15 (0.21 %)

NSE 7823.00

106.00 (1.37%)

Widgets Magazine

STOCK WATCH

No Record Found.
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Rasoya Proteins 0.25 25.00
Kitex Garments 780.65 15.25
Unichem Labs. 303.05 12.85
DLF 120.60 9.94
J B Chem & Pharm 286.00 9.62
> More on NSE Gainers
No Record Found.
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Amtek Auto 31.50 -34.98
Kaveri Seed Co. 446.85 -5.89
Castex Tech 52.10 -4.93
Container Corpn. 1396.30 -4.45
Oracle Fin.Serv. 3917.60 -3.68
> More on NSE Gainers
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Derivatives

Index
Instrument Type
Expiry Date
Option Type
Strike Price