Business Standard

Sebi to take re-look at front-running norms

Move comes after Securities Appellate Tribunal said regulations only apply to market intermediaries and not individuals

Related News

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) plans to review the regulations that govern front-running, to strengthen these, after a recent ruling by the (SAT) set aside its order on individuals on this count.

The tribunal overruled Sebi’s order on the grounds that the regulations only apply to market intermediaries and not individuals.

“On this particular aspect of front-running, we will have to look at our regulations to see if it needs more improvement and strengthening,” said Chairman U K Sinha.

Front-running is an unethical practice of executing trades based on confidential information, to make profits. It is prohibited under Sebi’s Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices (FUTP) Regulations.

In 2009, Sebi had passed an interim order that barred three individuals from the securities market and imposed penalties on them for their alleged front-running. An investigation had found and had traded on information from their cousin, Dipak Patel, who was working at Passport India Investment (Mauritius), on forthcoming trades by his organisation, to make a profit of Rs 1.56 crore.

Earlier this month, the order against these individuals was set aside by SAT.

The appellate body’s ruling that the FUTP Act cannot be applied for front-running by individuals, has legal experts divided.

While some believe SAT’s judgement is ‘flawed’, as it has only looked at the section meant for intermediaries and even individuals are covered under different sections, others say the FUTP Regulations, 1995, prohibits front-running by individuals, while the FUTP Regulations, 2003, prohibits it only by intermediaries.

“Front-running as an offence is pursued to be for intermediaries. So, will somebody who is an indirect beneficiary, fall under the purview? Common sense and justice demand that they should,” said Sinha.

“Given this particular example, we will need to have a serious look at our regulation,” he added

“It makes no logical sense to restrict the securities anti-fraud rule (even if one) to apply only to intermediaries and that too, registered intermediaries. The point is to protect investors, not punish wrongdoers if they wear a particular hat,” said of Finsec Law Advisors.

According to legal experts, the regulator should appeal against the SAT’s ruling, so that it doesn’t set a precedent.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Sebi to take re-look at front-running norms

Move comes after Securities Appellate Tribunal said regulations only apply to market intermediaries and not individuals

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) plans to review the regulations that govern front-running, to strengthen these, after a recent ruling by the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) set aside its order on individuals on this count.

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) plans to review the regulations that govern front-running, to strengthen these, after a recent ruling by the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) set aside its order on individuals on this count.

The tribunal overruled Sebi’s order on the grounds that the regulations only apply to market intermediaries and not individuals.

“On this particular aspect of front-running, we will have to look at our regulations to see if it needs more improvement and strengthening,” said Sebi Chairman U K Sinha.

Front-running is an unethical practice of executing trades based on confidential information, to make profits. It is prohibited under Sebi’s Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices (FUTP) Regulations.

In 2009, Sebi had passed an interim order that barred three individuals from the securities market and imposed penalties on them for their alleged front-running. An investigation had found Kanaiyalal Patel and Anandkumar Patel had traded on information from their cousin, Dipak Patel, who was working at Passport India Investment (Mauritius), on forthcoming trades by his organisation, to make a profit of Rs 1.56 crore.

Earlier this month, the order against these individuals was set aside by SAT.

The appellate body’s ruling that the FUTP Act cannot be applied for front-running by individuals, has legal experts divided.

While some believe SAT’s judgement is ‘flawed’, as it has only looked at the section meant for intermediaries and even individuals are covered under different sections, others say the FUTP Regulations, 1995, prohibits front-running by individuals, while the FUTP Regulations, 2003, prohibits it only by intermediaries.

“Front-running as an offence is pursued to be for intermediaries. So, will somebody who is an indirect beneficiary, fall under the purview? Common sense and justice demand that they should,” said Sinha.

“Given this particular example, we will need to have a serious look at our regulation,” he added

“It makes no logical sense to restrict the securities anti-fraud rule (even if one) to apply only to intermediaries and that too, registered intermediaries. The point is to protect investors, not punish wrongdoers if they wear a particular hat,” said Sandeep Parekh of Finsec Law Advisors.

According to legal experts, the regulator should appeal against the SAT’s ruling, so that it doesn’t set a precedent.

image

Read More

BSE launches carbon index

Premier bourse BSE, in collaboration with the UK government, today launched BSE Carbonex, the first-of-its-kind index in India or any emerging market ...

Recommended for you

Advertisements

Quick Links

Market News

Govt hikes import tariff on gold, silver

During the last fortnight of March, the tariff value on imported gold was $375 per 10 grams and on silver at $512 per kg

Banks, rate-sensitives drive markets ahead of RBI policy

The Sensex surges 302 points; logs first weekly gain in three weeks. The Nifty rises 95 points

Delivery-based volumes hit one-year high in March

Earlier, in March 2014, more than half, or 51%, of the total traded shares got converted into delivery before the general elections

Gold shipments into Gujarat register highest rise in last four years: GSECL

The official added that rise in import of gold is a sign that the economy is recovering slowly

FY16 begins on a firm note; Sensex ends 300 points higher

The 30-share Sensex gained 303 points to end at 28,260 and the 50-share Nifty soared 95 points to close at 8,586

 

Back to Top