Business Standard

Suit filed to recover investors' money

Petition before Delhi HC says Sebi, BSE sleeping on job of protecting small investors' interest, that suspension/delisting of firms favours promoters

N Sundaresha Subramanian  |  New Delhi 

A public interest litigation (PIL), up for hearing next week in the high court here, has alleged that nearly Rs 1.8 lakh crore of investments by small investors is locked in suspended companies and the market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), has not initiated any steps to protect these investments.

Filed by Atul Agarwal, a Delhi-based commercial pilot, it urges the court “to take action in the matter to protect the interest of over 10 million public shareholders/investors of these 1,405 suspended companies, whose enormous investment of more than Rs 1,79,560 crore in these suspended companies is at stake”.

Sebi, the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the (MCA) are respondents, in addition to the Union government. The respondents have asked for time until May 30, when the hearing resumes, to respond. The petition also seeks revocation of BSE’s recently announced relisting guidelines.



Suspended companies constitute 16.6 per cent of the total list of the BSE, the petition says. Ajay Veer Singh, partner, BS Jain &Co, who is advising Agarwal, said, “This is a conservative estimate, based on data available for 949 companies. The entire amount could be much higher.”

According to publicly available data, these 949 companies have a public shareholding of 8,978 crore shares. The petitioner assumes that each of these shares were bought by investors for at least Rs 20, (the IPO price may be anything between Rs 10 per share and Rs 500 per share or more) arriving at the sum of Rs 1.8 lakh crore.

The petition alleges the exchange has not done anything to protect the interests of the investors.

It has accused and the promoters of these companies of colluding to get listed, “then collecting money from innocent investors by making tall promises and, thereafter, getting suspended for non-compliance of the listing agreement and finally getting delisted and disappearing with public funds”.

The petition notes the MCA and maintain a portfolio, called the Investor Education and Protection Fund. The petitioner filed a petition under the and found as much as Rs 1,055 crore was unused in this fund. It accuses BSE of “rampant and continuous misuse of powers” and of a “nonchalant attitude” from Sebi.

When a question about such practices was raised in a recent conference, Sebi chairman had said, promoters and companies doing such “asset stripping” would be dealt with in an appropriate manner. BSE officials declined comment, when asked.

Singh said the entire compulsory delisting process was skewed in favour of errant promoters. “If a promoter wants to shut the company and not pay the shareholder, all he has to do is stop paying the listing fees. The exchange will suspend the company. This is exactly what they want,” he charged. The flawed system, instead of penalising the company or promoter, lets them off easily while the investor is left carrying the can, he adds.

“Instead of compelling these errant listed companies to make adequate disclosure, the exchange is providing an easy way out for these errant listed companies by suspending the trading of stock/shares... after the promoters of errant companies siphon off all public money with them and vanish altogether, no steps or actions are ever initiated to trace these companies,” the petition says.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Suit filed to recover investors' money

Petition before Delhi HC says Sebi, BSE sleeping on job of protecting small investors' interest, that suspension/delisting of firms favours promoters

A public interest litigation (PIL), up for hearing next week in the high court here, has alleged that nearly Rs 1.8 lakh crore of investments by small investors is locked in suspended companies and the market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), has not initiated any steps to protect these investments.

A public interest litigation (PIL), up for hearing next week in the high court here, has alleged that nearly Rs 1.8 lakh crore of investments by small investors is locked in suspended companies and the market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi), has not initiated any steps to protect these investments.

Filed by Atul Agarwal, a Delhi-based commercial pilot, it urges the court “to take action in the matter to protect the interest of over 10 million public shareholders/investors of these 1,405 suspended companies, whose enormous investment of more than Rs 1,79,560 crore in these suspended companies is at stake”.

Sebi, the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the (MCA) are respondents, in addition to the Union government. The respondents have asked for time until May 30, when the hearing resumes, to respond. The petition also seeks revocation of BSE’s recently announced relisting guidelines.



Suspended companies constitute 16.6 per cent of the total list of the BSE, the petition says. Ajay Veer Singh, partner, BS Jain &Co, who is advising Agarwal, said, “This is a conservative estimate, based on data available for 949 companies. The entire amount could be much higher.”

According to publicly available data, these 949 companies have a public shareholding of 8,978 crore shares. The petitioner assumes that each of these shares were bought by investors for at least Rs 20, (the IPO price may be anything between Rs 10 per share and Rs 500 per share or more) arriving at the sum of Rs 1.8 lakh crore.

The petition alleges the exchange has not done anything to protect the interests of the investors.

It has accused and the promoters of these companies of colluding to get listed, “then collecting money from innocent investors by making tall promises and, thereafter, getting suspended for non-compliance of the listing agreement and finally getting delisted and disappearing with public funds”.

The petition notes the MCA and maintain a portfolio, called the Investor Education and Protection Fund. The petitioner filed a petition under the and found as much as Rs 1,055 crore was unused in this fund. It accuses BSE of “rampant and continuous misuse of powers” and of a “nonchalant attitude” from Sebi.

When a question about such practices was raised in a recent conference, Sebi chairman had said, promoters and companies doing such “asset stripping” would be dealt with in an appropriate manner. BSE officials declined comment, when asked.

Singh said the entire compulsory delisting process was skewed in favour of errant promoters. “If a promoter wants to shut the company and not pay the shareholder, all he has to do is stop paying the listing fees. The exchange will suspend the company. This is exactly what they want,” he charged. The flawed system, instead of penalising the company or promoter, lets them off easily while the investor is left carrying the can, he adds.

“Instead of compelling these errant listed companies to make adequate disclosure, the exchange is providing an easy way out for these errant listed companies by suspending the trading of stock/shares... after the promoters of errant companies siphon off all public money with them and vanish altogether, no steps or actions are ever initiated to trace these companies,” the petition says.

image

LIVE MARKET

BSE 26392.38

161.19 (0.61 %)

NSE 8001.95

53.00 (0.67%)

Widgets Magazine

STOCK WATCH

Company Price() Chg(%)
Future Consumer 16.15 11.76
Kolte Patil Dev. 164.95 10.30
Vakrangee 118.45 9.88
PC Jeweller 384.50 9.34
Gateway Distr. 361.20 7.32
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Future Consumer 16.25 12.07
Kolte Patil Dev. 166.00 11.00
Vakrangee 118.35 9.89
L G Balakrishnan 491.15 8.78
Gateway Distr. 363.50 8.33
> More on NSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Sunrise Asian 260.70 -9.98
Symphony 2083.30 -6.39
I O B 34.95 -5.41
Indbull.RealEst. 62.55 -5.01
H D I L 59.95 -4.99
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Rasoya Proteins 0.20 -20.00
Usha Martin 15.25 -5.86
I O B 35.35 -5.73
GHCL 115.70 -5.47
Gammon India 13.90 -5.12
> More on NSE Gainers
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Derivatives

Index
Instrument Type
Expiry Date
Option Type
Strike Price