Business Standard

Shahabuddin opposes plea for shifting him from Siwan jail to Tihar

IANS  |  New Delhi 

RJD strongman Mohammed on Wednesday opposed the plea seeking his shifting from Siwan district jail to Tihar Jail in and the transfer of trials in 45 cases he faces, saying that plea for his transfer was against the law.

Opposing the plea, told the bench of Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Amitava Roy that such a transfer from Siwan district jail to Tihar was unwarranted and unjustified as same was contrary to the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950.

Telling the court that it could not issue a mandamus that was contrary to the law, senior counsel Shekhar Naphade said: "The plea for mandamus is contrary to law. What is illegal can't be a mandamus."

He said no order can be passed that is contrary to Section 3 of the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950 as prisons and the prisoners are in the exclusive domain of the State governments.

As bench observed that the plea was seeking the transfer of from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail invoking top court's powers under Article 142, Naphade said: "You can't exercise powers under Article 142 of the constitution which may infringe my fundamental rights."

Article 142 says "the Supreme Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India..."

The top court was told this as it is hearing the plea by Chandrakeshwar Prasad and Asha Ranjan, widow of a journalist allegedly killed on Shahabuddin's orders, seeking his transfer from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail in and holding of his trial through video-conferencing.

Chandrakeshwar Prasad's three sons were killed allegedly by Shahabuddin's henchmen.

Reversing the Patna High Court's September 7 order granting him bail, the top court had on September 30 had ordered back to jail in the Rajiv Roshan murder case as it pointed to the need for balancing the consideration of individual liberty of the accused with that of societal interest.

As Naphade's arguments had not concluded, the hearing will continue on Thursday.

--IANS

pk/pgh/vm

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Shahabuddin opposes plea for shifting him from Siwan jail to Tihar

RJD strongman Mohammed Shahabuddin on Wednesday opposed the plea seeking his shifting from Siwan district jail to Tihar Jail in Delhi and the transfer of trials in 45 cases he faces, saying that plea for his transfer was against the law.

RJD strongman Mohammed on Wednesday opposed the plea seeking his shifting from Siwan district jail to Tihar Jail in and the transfer of trials in 45 cases he faces, saying that plea for his transfer was against the law.

Opposing the plea, told the bench of Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Amitava Roy that such a transfer from Siwan district jail to Tihar was unwarranted and unjustified as same was contrary to the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950.

Telling the court that it could not issue a mandamus that was contrary to the law, senior counsel Shekhar Naphade said: "The plea for mandamus is contrary to law. What is illegal can't be a mandamus."

He said no order can be passed that is contrary to Section 3 of the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950 as prisons and the prisoners are in the exclusive domain of the State governments.

As bench observed that the plea was seeking the transfer of from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail invoking top court's powers under Article 142, Naphade said: "You can't exercise powers under Article 142 of the constitution which may infringe my fundamental rights."

Article 142 says "the Supreme Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India..."

The top court was told this as it is hearing the plea by Chandrakeshwar Prasad and Asha Ranjan, widow of a journalist allegedly killed on Shahabuddin's orders, seeking his transfer from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail in and holding of his trial through video-conferencing.

Chandrakeshwar Prasad's three sons were killed allegedly by Shahabuddin's henchmen.

Reversing the Patna High Court's September 7 order granting him bail, the top court had on September 30 had ordered back to jail in the Rajiv Roshan murder case as it pointed to the need for balancing the consideration of individual liberty of the accused with that of societal interest.

As Naphade's arguments had not concluded, the hearing will continue on Thursday.

--IANS

pk/pgh/vm

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

image
Business Standard
177 22

Shahabuddin opposes plea for shifting him from Siwan jail to Tihar

RJD strongman Mohammed on Wednesday opposed the plea seeking his shifting from Siwan district jail to Tihar Jail in and the transfer of trials in 45 cases he faces, saying that plea for his transfer was against the law.

Opposing the plea, told the bench of Justice Dipak Misra and Justice Amitava Roy that such a transfer from Siwan district jail to Tihar was unwarranted and unjustified as same was contrary to the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950.

Telling the court that it could not issue a mandamus that was contrary to the law, senior counsel Shekhar Naphade said: "The plea for mandamus is contrary to law. What is illegal can't be a mandamus."

He said no order can be passed that is contrary to Section 3 of the Transfer of Prisoners Act, 1950 as prisons and the prisoners are in the exclusive domain of the State governments.

As bench observed that the plea was seeking the transfer of from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail invoking top court's powers under Article 142, Naphade said: "You can't exercise powers under Article 142 of the constitution which may infringe my fundamental rights."

Article 142 says "the Supreme Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction may pass such decree or make such order as is necessary for doing complete justice in any cause or matter pending before it, and any decree so passed or order so made shall be enforceable throughout the territory of India..."

The top court was told this as it is hearing the plea by Chandrakeshwar Prasad and Asha Ranjan, widow of a journalist allegedly killed on Shahabuddin's orders, seeking his transfer from Siwan jail to Tihar Jail in and holding of his trial through video-conferencing.

Chandrakeshwar Prasad's three sons were killed allegedly by Shahabuddin's henchmen.

Reversing the Patna High Court's September 7 order granting him bail, the top court had on September 30 had ordered back to jail in the Rajiv Roshan murder case as it pointed to the need for balancing the consideration of individual liberty of the accused with that of societal interest.

As Naphade's arguments had not concluded, the hearing will continue on Thursday.

--IANS

pk/pgh/vm

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

image
Business Standard
177 22

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard