You are here: Home » Opinion » Letters
Business Standard

A question of disorder

There are no interventions designed in our system between appointment and impeachment

Business Standard 

With reference to Somasekhar Sundaresan’s column, “A chance to score a judicial point” (May 25), the Justice saga appears to be more a disorder within the than a judge’s accountability to or the public at large. Before invoking constitutional provisions of checks and balances, we need to ponder over the following.  

First, a judge once appointed can only be impeached. There are no interventions designed in our system between appointment and impeachment. We need to recognise that judges, like any human being, can behave irrationally when it is about their dignity. The needs to devise a human resources policy having less severe interventions than impeachment.

has a provision to expel a member from the house for misbehaviour. Similarly, under the executive arm of the state can be suspended from duty so that they can’t use official powers to their advantage. Why can’t there be an in-house mechanism in the to prevent a judge from passing orders over his fellow judges and the judges of the  

We need to differentiate between institutional checks and balances, and individuals erring within an institution. should intervene only when a malaise is affecting the as an institution.

Amit Kumar Upadhyay   New Delhi

can be mailed, faxed or e-mailed to: 
The Editor, Business Standard
Nehru House, 4 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg 
New Delhi 110 002 
Fax: (011) 23720201  •  E-mail:
All must have a postal address and telephone number