You are here: Home » Opinion » Editorial » Editorials
Business Standard

Mr Gandhi's failure

Congress leadership must be held accountable

Business Standard Editorial Comment  |  New Delhi 

The crushing defeat of their parties in the recently concluded general election has caused at least two senior politicians to offer to resign. Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, faced with dissent in his Janata Dal (United), or JD(U), is one; and the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam's (DMK's) treasurer, M K Stalin, son of the party patriarch, M Karunanidhi, is another. Messrs Kumar and Stalin were the men in charge of their parties' campaigns. The was blown away by the Narendra Modi-led Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP); it secured only two seats. The did even worse; it failed to win a single constituency. Whether or not these resignations are followed through with is another matter. For example, it is possible that Mr Kumar will be made to recognise that Bihar's development story is still fragile and requires the stability he has provided so far. But nobody can question his commitment to his party, and the fact that he has chosen to make himself properly accountable.

Sadly, that accountability is missing in some other parties. Perhaps it is too much to expect the leader of the Bahujan Samaj Party, wiped out in Uttar Pradesh, to quit. But at least can argue that her party's vote share did not decline precipitously and that the Uttar Pradesh Assembly election is her primary focus. That argument is not available to the leaders of the party, which has been reduced to a shadow of its former self at 44 seats. This is the party's worst performance. While the need not be declared dead yet - remember, in the wave election of 1984, the won just two seats in Parliament - it is certainly on life support.

And yet, the leadership has failed to truly take responsibility. In a press conference on Friday, vice-president Rahul Gandhi, who was in charge of the campaign, did not even look like he grasped the enormity of the situation - one in which his party has lost even the automatic right to name the leader of the Opposition. Only the president and the vice-president deemed it necessary to accept or explain the party's defeat. There was no sign of the many general secretaries of the party; they seemed to be missing from the scene after the debacle. The press conference stood in stark contrast to the one held by the victorious on the same day, where it fielded its entire top team. Mr Gandhi was anointed vice-president and took over the campaign even before Mr Modi was named the BJP's prime ministerial candidate. But since Mr Gandhi took over, the Congress' fortunes have only floundered. The campaign has stuttered; and there is little doubt that Mr Gandhi's own image has been compromised. It is time for him to step aside, and for a new parliamentary leader to be freely chosen from among the ranks of surviving MPs. If president does not herself want to take on that responsibility, there are many other possibilities - Jyotiraditya Scindia, perhaps, or Kamal Nath, two among those who fought off the Modi wave in north India. Or perhaps someone from the south. However, for the to argue that the main reason for the party's failure in the was the government's inability to communicate its performance and policies effectively would be disingenuous. Mr Gandhi should take the responsibility for the party's electoral debacle and a new leader should be allowed to take charge.

First Published: Sun, May 18 2014. 21:45 IST