Business Standard

Nilanjana S Roy: Nine from 2012: reading India

Related News

On the power of words: Indian poetry seldom wins prizes or lands on bestseller lists, and yet the strongest, most radical and most powerful of contemporary Indian writing has come from its poets.

Eunice de Souza and Melanie Silgardo’s anthology These My Words heads my personal list of the best of Indian writing in 2012. Coming after two big anthologies of Indian poetry in English, These My Words takes a broader approach. The authors, trenchant poets, mistresses of the biting, precise line themselves, have put together the definitive collection of Indian poetry, across the ages, across Indian languages. They arrange poems by theme – love and desire, bhakti and devotion, political poetry – which makes These My Words both a pleasure and an education to read. Don’t miss this.

On the family: From Tolstoy’s unhappy families to Tagore’s broken nests, the domestic sphere has held a special attraction for male writers. Jerry Pinto’s sensitive and honest account of dysfunction and love in was one of the most moving novels of 2012. Mr Pinto honed his language through the practice of poetry. Manu Joseph honed his spare and never self-indulgent prose through journalism. In his second novel, The Illicit Happiness of Other People, he writes with cruel and compelling clarity about the high cost of living with the silences and omissions of the average Indian family. Both novels, aside from the writers’ gifts of craft and technique, address potentially brutal subjects with a rare empathy.

On morality: All of Katherine Boo’s work on poverty, in the US and more recently in the slums of Mumbai, rests on a belief that clearly struck some readers in India as radical: the poor are not unlike you and me. “Nobody is representative,” she said in an interview to Guernica, “you try to let the reader have a sense of this person and soul, as a recognisable human.” Ms Boo continues to spend time with the residents of Annawadi. Behind the Beautiful Forevers, the result of her years of work, has the potential to change the way poverty is understood and thought about in India.

On being human: One of the most striking passages in Benyamin’s Goat Days is a section where the protagonist, a migrant to the Gulf in search of work and better opportunities, finds himself identifying with the goats he’s supposed to herd more than with the humans who own both the goats’ lives and his own. If there is such a thing as a great Gulf novel, Goat Days, with its compassionate understanding of the dark side of the economic migration story, is a contender; but it goes beyond, to ask what separates the animal life from the human one. The barrier, it turns out, is dangerously thin.

On another India: The myth of “village India” as a simple, sweet place has long since been exploded by writers from Rahi Masoom Raza to O V Vijayan. Gogu Shyamala, writing from rural Andhra Pradesh with sly wit and incredibly powerful lyricism, creates unique and unforgettable stories in Father May be an Elephant, And Mother Only a Small Basket, But…

On memories and absences: All of M G Vassanji’s work should be required reading for those interested in the gap between official histories and unreported histories. The Magic of Saida, his most recent novel, explores migration – contemporary, to Canada, ancient and forgotten, as in the history of east African migrants – and memory. “The past is a dangerous business … it is best to keep it buried,” says one of his characters. With tremendous control and fluent storytelling, Mr Vassanji brings up the bodies.

On invisible cities: Behind the big, popular city narratives, there are less well-known, often more disquieting stories. Janice Pariat’s Boats on Land is not a fiction writer’s travelogue into Shillong, but like any good storyteller, she brings her city alive along with her characters. Uday Prakash’s The Walls of Delhi tells three subversive stories about the underbelly of the city, focusing on Jamunapaar, far away from the protected cocoon of South Delhi.

On the past: In Between Clay and Dust, a wrestler whose powers are in decline meets a courtesan whose days of glory are in the past. Musharraf Ali Farooqi never over-embroiders his tales, letting his characters breathe and tell quiet, unforgettable stories. William Dalrymple’s Return of a King is in a completely different vein, but his history of Afghanistan, drawing on the account of a key battle and on Shah Shuja’s memoirs, makes the complex geopolitics of the country far more understandable. 

On ideas of India: For two sharp, well-considered and divergent takes on India, pick up Ramachandra Guha’s Patriots and Partisans, and Diana Eck’s India: A Sacred Geography. Mr Guha’s latest collection of essays looks at the threats to the idea of India, from a rise in religious rightwing fervour to a somewhat shaky liberal intellectualism. Ms Eck’s beautifully considered map of a pilgrim’s India gently but persuasively argues that faith as it is practised goes far beyond the aggressive simplicities of the politically religious.


nilanjanasroy@gmail.com  

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|

Nilanjana S Roy: Nine from 2012: reading India

On the power of words: Indian poetry seldom wins prizes or lands on bestseller lists, and yet the strongest, most radical and most powerful of contemporary Indian writing has come from its poets.

On the power of words: Indian poetry seldom wins prizes or lands on bestseller lists, and yet the strongest, most radical and most powerful of contemporary Indian writing has come from its poets.

Eunice de Souza and Melanie Silgardo’s anthology These My Words heads my personal list of the best of Indian writing in 2012. Coming after two big anthologies of Indian poetry in English, These My Words takes a broader approach. The authors, trenchant poets, mistresses of the biting, precise line themselves, have put together the definitive collection of Indian poetry, across the ages, across Indian languages. They arrange poems by theme – love and desire, bhakti and devotion, political poetry – which makes These My Words both a pleasure and an education to read. Don’t miss this.

On the family: From Tolstoy’s unhappy families to Tagore’s broken nests, the domestic sphere has held a special attraction for male writers. Jerry Pinto’s sensitive and honest account of dysfunction and love in Em and The Big Hoom was one of the most moving novels of 2012. Mr Pinto honed his language through the practice of poetry. Manu Joseph honed his spare and never self-indulgent prose through journalism. In his second novel, The Illicit Happiness of Other People, he writes with cruel and compelling clarity about the high cost of living with the silences and omissions of the average Indian family. Both novels, aside from the writers’ gifts of craft and technique, address potentially brutal subjects with a rare empathy.

On morality: All of Katherine Boo’s work on poverty, in the US and more recently in the slums of Mumbai, rests on a belief that clearly struck some readers in India as radical: the poor are not unlike you and me. “Nobody is representative,” she said in an interview to Guernica, “you try to let the reader have a sense of this person and soul, as a recognisable human.” Ms Boo continues to spend time with the residents of Annawadi. Behind the Beautiful Forevers, the result of her years of work, has the potential to change the way poverty is understood and thought about in India.

On being human: One of the most striking passages in Benyamin’s Goat Days is a section where the protagonist, a migrant to the Gulf in search of work and better opportunities, finds himself identifying with the goats he’s supposed to herd more than with the humans who own both the goats’ lives and his own. If there is such a thing as a great Gulf novel, Goat Days, with its compassionate understanding of the dark side of the economic migration story, is a contender; but it goes beyond, to ask what separates the animal life from the human one. The barrier, it turns out, is dangerously thin.

On another India: The myth of “village India” as a simple, sweet place has long since been exploded by writers from Rahi Masoom Raza to O V Vijayan. Gogu Shyamala, writing from rural Andhra Pradesh with sly wit and incredibly powerful lyricism, creates unique and unforgettable stories in Father May be an Elephant, And Mother Only a Small Basket, But…

On memories and absences: All of M G Vassanji’s work should be required reading for those interested in the gap between official histories and unreported histories. The Magic of Saida, his most recent novel, explores migration – contemporary, to Canada, ancient and forgotten, as in the history of east African migrants – and memory. “The past is a dangerous business … it is best to keep it buried,” says one of his characters. With tremendous control and fluent storytelling, Mr Vassanji brings up the bodies.

On invisible cities: Behind the big, popular city narratives, there are less well-known, often more disquieting stories. Janice Pariat’s Boats on Land is not a fiction writer’s travelogue into Shillong, but like any good storyteller, she brings her city alive along with her characters. Uday Prakash’s The Walls of Delhi tells three subversive stories about the underbelly of the city, focusing on Jamunapaar, far away from the protected cocoon of South Delhi.

On the past: In Between Clay and Dust, a wrestler whose powers are in decline meets a courtesan whose days of glory are in the past. Musharraf Ali Farooqi never over-embroiders his tales, letting his characters breathe and tell quiet, unforgettable stories. William Dalrymple’s Return of a King is in a completely different vein, but his history of Afghanistan, drawing on the account of a key battle and on Shah Shuja’s memoirs, makes the complex geopolitics of the country far more understandable. 

On ideas of India: For two sharp, well-considered and divergent takes on India, pick up Ramachandra Guha’s Patriots and Partisans, and Diana Eck’s India: A Sacred Geography. Mr Guha’s latest collection of essays looks at the threats to the idea of India, from a rise in religious rightwing fervour to a somewhat shaky liberal intellectualism. Ms Eck’s beautifully considered map of a pilgrim’s India gently but persuasively argues that faith as it is practised goes far beyond the aggressive simplicities of the politically religious.


nilanjanasroy@gmail.com  

image

Read More

Devangshu Datta: Expect the unexpected

The market continued to mark time as the last settlement of 2012 passed by. There was negligible change in net index levels. Most traders are ...

Recommended for you

Most Popular Columns

Mihir S Sharma

Mihir S Sharma: Forget about reform
Mihir S Sharma

The real lesson of the Budget session is that Modi has the tools and the power to conduct big-bang reform if he wants - but he doesn't want to

Ajai Shukla

Ajai Shukla: Don't divide the army, Mr Parrikar
Ajai Shukla

Internal simmering in the army has come to a boil after the govt tries to retain a discriminatory promotions policy

Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly

Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly: Beware all ye who have borrowed dollars
Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly

A US rate hike and a spike in the dollar could pose a variety of problems even if they last for a quarter

Advertisement

Columnists

Ajai Shukla

Ajai Shukla: Don't divide the army, Mr Parrikar
Ajai Shukla

Internal simmering in the army has come to a boil after the govt tries to retain a discriminatory promotions policy

Hasmukh Shah

Hasmukh Shah: The real issues behind land acquisition
Hasmukh Shah

Farmers are inextricably tied to their land. Deprived of it, they have little else to fall back on for their livelihood

Andrew Sheng & Xiao Geng

Andrew Sheng & Xiao Geng: China's trial-and-error economy
Andrew Sheng & Xiao Geng

Chinese Prime Minister Li Keqiang's work plan for 2015, revealed at this month's National People's Congress, highlighted the country's shift to ...

Back to Top