Business Standard

T N Ninan: Make-believe solutions

The government has to deliver solutions that work, not indulge in action for the sake of demonstrating lack of paralysis

Related News

The government has been trying to get rid of the impression that it is caught in “policy paralysis”. Troubled airlines are to be rescued from their follies, and are to be assured supply of coal, while new policies have been announced for manufacturing, telecom, fertiliser… The frustrating result: solutions that look suspiciously like non-solutions, like the that has managed to do what no train does (go in reverse gear), and the opening and then quick slamming shut of doors for foreign investment in retail trade.

The latest in this list could be power projects, whose promoters faced coal linkage problems and met all the important people a few weeks ago, in a “See the Delhi Bhavans” circus. Then, in a 1970s-style solution, was asked to supply the coal, import it if needed. But Coal India is not in the import business, and its board has now decided to not do as ordered. In any case, the ports can’t handle that much imported coal, and pithead power stations cannot use imported coal because it is costlier even without the transport costs. End result: the power stations are where they were before their promoters met the prime minister.

The rescuing of airlines has been a similar story. The government has allowed the direct, duty-free import of aviation fuel, opened up the sector to investment by foreign airlines, and given loan guarantees to Air India. It may even have nudged government-owned banks to lend more to Kingfisher, but public outrage stopped the banks from throwing good money after bad (they bought shares over a year ago at about three times the current market price). And yet, both Kingfisher and Air India are in a mess; aircraft are grounded, employees have not been paid salaries and are asked to stay at home, staff unions are stirring, and travel agents are withholding bookings. Since neither airline has a survival strategy, it seems only a matter of time before one or other goes the way of East West and ModiLuft. And since Air India has a shareholder who believes in permanent life-support, the betting must be on Kingfisher justifying its name and diving into the water. Passengers will pay, as fares have started edging up. If the cost of flying goes up, there will be fewer air passengers, and the big new airports that counted on a certain level of traffic will see their calculations coming unstuck. Meanwhile, no aviation fuel has yet been imported by the airlines, and no foreign investors have come knocking.

As for the that was unveiled last summer, anyone heard of it since? Or of the new telecom policy that was unveiled shortly afterwards? And, any bets on whether the latest urea investment policy will end the decade-long famine in greenfield fertiliser investment? The highways people have tom-tommed the increase in road project clearances (6,200 km this year, up from 4,500 km last year); but a quarter of all road projects are stuck because of land acquisition problems, so some of those “cleared” projects aren’t really moving.

Too many patchwork solutions are being attempted. The bailout of the muffed share sale is but one example. There is no examination of the fundamentals (for example: why would anyone invest in bankrupt airlines?). Follow-up work is not in evidence: manufacturing cannot be given impetus unless a broad swath of measures is taken, and no single “policy” announcement can work the trick even if the industry minister claims modestly that his is the most important announcement since the industrial de-licensing of 1991. An economy that has lost momentum desperately needs solutions that work. The government has to deliver them, not indulge in action for the sake of demonstrating lack of paralysis.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

T N Ninan: Make-believe solutions

The government has to deliver solutions that work, not indulge in action for the sake of demonstrating lack of paralysis

The government has been trying to get rid of the impression that it is caught in “policy paralysis”.

The government has been trying to get rid of the impression that it is caught in “policy paralysis”. Troubled airlines are to be rescued from their follies, and power stations are to be assured supply of coal, while new policies have been announced for manufacturing, telecom, fertiliser… The frustrating result: solutions that look suspiciously like non-solutions, like the Railway Budget that has managed to do what no train does (go in reverse gear), and the opening and then quick slamming shut of doors for foreign investment in retail trade.

The latest in this list could be power projects, whose promoters faced coal linkage problems and met all the important people a few weeks ago, in a “See the Delhi Bhavans” circus. Then, in a 1970s-style solution, Coal India was asked to supply the coal, import it if needed. But Coal India is not in the import business, and its board has now decided to not do as ordered. In any case, the ports can’t handle that much imported coal, and pithead power stations cannot use imported coal because it is costlier even without the transport costs. End result: the power stations are where they were before their promoters met the prime minister.

The rescuing of airlines has been a similar story. The government has allowed the direct, duty-free import of aviation fuel, opened up the sector to investment by foreign airlines, and given loan guarantees to Air India. It may even have nudged government-owned banks to lend more to Kingfisher, but public outrage stopped the banks from throwing good money after bad (they bought Kingfisher shares over a year ago at about three times the current market price). And yet, both Kingfisher and Air India are in a mess; aircraft are grounded, employees have not been paid salaries and are asked to stay at home, staff unions are stirring, and travel agents are withholding bookings. Since neither airline has a survival strategy, it seems only a matter of time before one or other goes the way of East West and ModiLuft. And since Air India has a shareholder who believes in permanent life-support, the betting must be on Kingfisher justifying its name and diving into the water. Passengers will pay, as fares have started edging up. If the cost of flying goes up, there will be fewer air passengers, and the big new airports that counted on a certain level of traffic will see their calculations coming unstuck. Meanwhile, no aviation fuel has yet been imported by the airlines, and no foreign investors have come knocking.

As for the new manufacturing policy that was unveiled last summer, anyone heard of it since? Or of the new telecom policy that was unveiled shortly afterwards? And, any bets on whether the latest urea investment policy will end the decade-long famine in greenfield fertiliser investment? The highways people have tom-tommed the increase in road project clearances (6,200 km this year, up from 4,500 km last year); but a quarter of all road projects are stuck because of land acquisition problems, so some of those “cleared” projects aren’t really moving.

Too many patchwork solutions are being attempted. The LIC bailout of the muffed ONGC share sale is but one example. There is no examination of the fundamentals (for example: why would anyone invest in bankrupt airlines?). Follow-up work is not in evidence: manufacturing cannot be given impetus unless a broad swath of measures is taken, and no single “policy” announcement can work the trick even if the industry minister claims modestly that his is the most important announcement since the industrial de-licensing of 1991. An economy that has lost momentum desperately needs solutions that work. The government has to deliver them, not indulge in action for the sake of demonstrating lack of paralysis.

image

Read More

Sunil Sethi: Off-key and off-queue

Does bureaucracy ever give up? Not really. Do public-private partnerships take off in delivering essential services? Not if the public partner ends ...

Recommended for you

Most Popular Columns

Mihir S Sharma

Mihir S Sharma: Forget about reform
Mihir S Sharma

The real lesson of the Budget session is that Modi has the tools and the power to conduct big-bang reform if he wants - but he doesn't want to

Ajai Shukla

Ajai Shukla: Don't divide the army, Mr Parrikar
Ajai Shukla

Internal simmering in the army has come to a boil after the govt tries to retain a discriminatory promotions policy

Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly

Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly: Beware all ye who have borrowed dollars
Abheek Barua & Bidisha Ganguly

A US rate hike and a spike in the dollar could pose a variety of problems even if they last for a quarter

Advertisement

Columnists

Ashok Lahiri

Ashok K Lahiri: AAP needs to transition from politics of protest to politics of power
Ashok Lahiri

How successfully Arvind Kejriwal manages the issue of inner-party democracy will determine whether the AAP is seen as transforming politics

A K Bhattacharya

A K Bhattacharya: Diversify or perish
A K Bhattacharya

Exports in the first 11 months of 2014-15 were estimated to be $284 billion, a decline over the same period of the previous year. Failing a ...

Vanita Kohli-Khandekar

Vanita Kohli-Khandekar: Framing ideas, getting connected
Vanita Kohli-Khandekar

Ficci-Frames 2015 has started an interesting initiative to get new ideas into the entertainment industry. If only it could get its digital ...

Back to Top