Business Standard

'Aam Aadmi Party's performance is significant, it is not about historic politics'

Interview with Director of the Asia Research Centre and India Observatory in the London School of Economics

Vrishti Beniwal  |  New Delhi 

Ruth Kattumuri

Dr Ruth Kattumuri, a Director of the Asia Research Centre and India Observatory in the London School of Economics, says that performance of Aam Aadmi Party in the recent Delhi cannot be judged from the point of view of historic or established politics. Kattumuri, who was in Delhi to take part in the recently concluded  Delhi Economics Conclave, tells Vrishti Beniwal that UPA-II worked very hard in introducing social welfare schemes, but the people's verdict is clear.

Do you see any fiscal slippages as the government might try to offer sops to the public ahead of general elections next year, particularly after it lost out in four states in the Assembly elections?

The only point I can make without knowing the details is that UPA-II has worked very hard in introducing several social programmes and also in trying to develop institutional systems for their implementation. There is a lot more to be done. But despite that people’s verdict is what it is. So that is not going to solve the problem anymore. One of the interesting things about India is that it is becoming a mature democracy. It was evident in the last elections. The common man is beginning to say that we have a voice and we will express that voice more strongly. What has happened with the AamAadmi Party in Delhi is significant. It is not about historic or the established politics.

As far as reforms are concerned, particularly legislative reforms, do you think there will be a comma, if not a full stop, because of the general elections next year?

Institutions exist and they will continue to do their job irrespective of elections. Only in case of issues which have to go through the Parliamentary system there would be delays.

How do you look at the functioning of the Indian government in the last five years? Do you agree that India suffered from ‘policy paralysis’?

The challenge in India is that people in Parliament are not allowing it to sit. Apart from that I don’t think that there is policy paralysis. Lots of policies and reforms have been introduced in the last five years, but we need to scale up. Strengthening of institutions has happened perceptibly, but the public awareness of these is limited.

From over 9%GDP growth we have come to 5%now.

A. It’s not in India alone. It’s part of the current global scenario.

Do you think growth has bottomed out and we are recovering now

I think it has bottomed out and we are going to go up from here because there are systems now. That’s interesting about India. The public is able to voice these things openly and the change also begins to happen.

India’s food security programme has been criticised by many as it does not address problems like malnutrition and sanitation. What are your views?

What has to be addressed is the issue of malnutrition. There is a good example in Tamil Nadu with Amma’sCanteen which provides nutritious meals at a reasonable cost. Sanitation is also important  and has to be dealt with. Every individual has a fundamental right to at least one full meal in a day and there is enough grain in the world to feed all the seven billion people. There have been different schemes to help overcome these and there are sometimes challenges of implementation in India, which have to be addressed.

How do you look at the ‘Peace Clause’ floated at WTO meet? It comes with certain riders.

I do believe you have to provide facilities to address certain social, economic and developmental problems. There should not be permanent structures. At every stage there should be monitoring and evaluation and if at a certain time the need has been met we have to reform. Right now there is a need to provide subsidies to certain section of the society. We know capacity for efficient implementation is a problem and we should do things to address that.

How do you see India’s efforts in the direction of education and skill development?

Lots of good things have happened in the last few years but the demand is so much more. We have a young population and need to address the gap in opportunities between rural and urban areas. There is a lot of human capital in the urban areas and there is a need to make most of that capital, providing not just skills and education but also professional skills. At the same time you have to create jobs too.


RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

'Aam Aadmi Party's performance is significant, it is not about historic politics'

Interview with Director of the Asia Research Centre and India Observatory in the London School of Economics

Dr Ruth Kattumuri, a Director of the Asia Research Centre and India Observatory in the London School of Economics, says that performance of Aam Aadmi Party in the recent Delhi assembly elections cannot be judged from the point of view of historic or established politics. Kattumuri, who was in Delhi to take part in the recently concluded Delhi Economics Conclave, tells Vrishti Beniwal that UPA-II worked very hard in introducing social welfare schemes, but the people's verdict is clear.
Dr Ruth Kattumuri, a Director of the Asia Research Centre and India Observatory in the London School of Economics, says that performance of Aam Aadmi Party in the recent Delhi cannot be judged from the point of view of historic or established politics. Kattumuri, who was in Delhi to take part in the recently concluded  Delhi Economics Conclave, tells Vrishti Beniwal that UPA-II worked very hard in introducing social welfare schemes, but the people's verdict is clear.

Do you see any fiscal slippages as the government might try to offer sops to the public ahead of general elections next year, particularly after it lost out in four states in the Assembly elections?

The only point I can make without knowing the details is that UPA-II has worked very hard in introducing several social programmes and also in trying to develop institutional systems for their implementation. There is a lot more to be done. But despite that people’s verdict is what it is. So that is not going to solve the problem anymore. One of the interesting things about India is that it is becoming a mature democracy. It was evident in the last elections. The common man is beginning to say that we have a voice and we will express that voice more strongly. What has happened with the AamAadmi Party in Delhi is significant. It is not about historic or the established politics.

As far as reforms are concerned, particularly legislative reforms, do you think there will be a comma, if not a full stop, because of the general elections next year?

Institutions exist and they will continue to do their job irrespective of elections. Only in case of issues which have to go through the Parliamentary system there would be delays.

How do you look at the functioning of the Indian government in the last five years? Do you agree that India suffered from ‘policy paralysis’?

The challenge in India is that people in Parliament are not allowing it to sit. Apart from that I don’t think that there is policy paralysis. Lots of policies and reforms have been introduced in the last five years, but we need to scale up. Strengthening of institutions has happened perceptibly, but the public awareness of these is limited.

From over 9%GDP growth we have come to 5%now.

A. It’s not in India alone. It’s part of the current global scenario.

Do you think growth has bottomed out and we are recovering now

I think it has bottomed out and we are going to go up from here because there are systems now. That’s interesting about India. The public is able to voice these things openly and the change also begins to happen.

India’s food security programme has been criticised by many as it does not address problems like malnutrition and sanitation. What are your views?

What has to be addressed is the issue of malnutrition. There is a good example in Tamil Nadu with Amma’sCanteen which provides nutritious meals at a reasonable cost. Sanitation is also important  and has to be dealt with. Every individual has a fundamental right to at least one full meal in a day and there is enough grain in the world to feed all the seven billion people. There have been different schemes to help overcome these and there are sometimes challenges of implementation in India, which have to be addressed.

How do you look at the ‘Peace Clause’ floated at WTO meet? It comes with certain riders.

I do believe you have to provide facilities to address certain social, economic and developmental problems. There should not be permanent structures. At every stage there should be monitoring and evaluation and if at a certain time the need has been met we have to reform. Right now there is a need to provide subsidies to certain section of the society. We know capacity for efficient implementation is a problem and we should do things to address that.

How do you see India’s efforts in the direction of education and skill development?

Lots of good things have happened in the last few years but the demand is so much more. We have a young population and need to address the gap in opportunities between rural and urban areas. There is a lot of human capital in the urban areas and there is a need to make most of that capital, providing not just skills and education but also professional skills. At the same time you have to create jobs too.


image

Columnists

Widgets Magazine

More News

Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Twitter Feed

  • @ShashiTharoor

    "What we need is not to discover or rediscover our 'roots' but ourselves". @Wajahatqazi on the enigma of return: https://t.co/RQuFb8X7cN

  • @AnanthKumar_BJP

    ZP & TP Election Campaign in Madabhavi, Athani & Benadi, Nippani Taluk. #karnataka 9-2-2016 https://t.co/4qllbwDb1Z https://t.co/DNRjKj9giw

  • @rajeev_mp

    RT @IndiGo6E: @rajeev_mp We're glad we could offer assistance.

  • @thekiranbedi

    National Salute to our Siachen Heroes. Here r some pics just taken off @ibnlive screen as I was watching the channel https://t.co/yH8EP5cTzz

  • @ArvindKejriwal

    RT @DelhiTalwar: Just heard. Tomorrow BJP will be holding protest on the basis of Congress's sting. Coordinated Congress-BJP Farzi sting …

  • @SushmaSwaraj

    All party delegation called on President Bidya Bhandari. https://t.co/LwFasKzvBc

  • @ajaymaken

    RT @DrunkVinodMehta: जो ईमानदारी का ढोल पीटते है, वही सबसे ज्यादा भ्रष्टाचारी होते है ! #CorruptKejriwalGovt https://t.co/dZDueOjYU5

  • @abdullah_omar

    No one knows when the Jammu and Kashmir government will be formed – but citizens no longer care https://t.co/GzVvqCXcgH via scroll_in

  • @digvijaya_28

    वैनकैया नायडू बतायेंगे कि मिनी स्मार्ट सिटी की कोई योजना है क्या ? भारत में बड़ा फेंकू मप्र में उनसे भी बड़ा फेंकू !

  • @DVSBJP

    #Hebbal By-Election #Bengaluru public meeting today . support Sri @yanmlc1966 Sri @BSYBJP was present https://t.co/18ncjM7ySK

  • @quizderek

    RT @ndtv: Opinion: Dying to pass GST, have 25-minute speech ready! – by @quizderek https://t.co/fY3g2hbUDS https://t.co/KJbvYjroYb

  • @PMOIndia

    Scripting change across India...an interaction with PM Rural Development Fellows. https://t.co/hYp8XaEaXP

  • @MVENKAIAHNAIDU

    Held a meeting with Ministers & Secretaries to finalize the Govt Business for the ensuing Budget Session https://t.co/myBS60qxpc

  • @Swamy39

    https://t.co/WDIjTAPfU9

  • @MPNaveenJindal

    RT @shallujindal20: Had much fun with kids at#Fazlani L'Academie Global school!was truly an enjoyable ride with India-an alphabet ride😇 htt…

  • @nsitharaman

    2/2 prayers of our nation are surely with the Lance Naik for his complete & speedy recovery.

  • @narendramodi

    Going to see Lance Naik Hanumanthappa, with prayers from the entire nation.

  • @arunjaitley

    Saddened by the death of former Prime Minister of Nepal & Nepali Congress President, Sh. Sushil Koirala. May God bless the departed soul.

  • @Gen_VKSingh

    @gorabhavna we will certainly help plz also provide as many details as possible to our consulate

  • @milinddeora

    DoT's missed opportunity -- my February 1st op-ed in @EconomicTimes: https://t.co/AQs20Xuvt2 #NetNeutrality #FreeBasics

  • @SinghRPN

    Tragic & condemnable shooting of 8 year old by SP workers.Illustrates the state of law and order in UP

  • @Rao_InderjitS

    Had a rich exchange of opinions & ideas at the #BuildIndiaConclave at New Delhi. @mail_today https://t.co/pXGHbkMsgQ

  • @smritiirani

    RT @BJP4Keralam: Smt @smritiirani inaugurating the valedictory function of Stree Swabhimaan Yatra, organised by MathruSamithy at Tvm https:…

  • @varungandhi80

    [2/2] away from Delhi for a week now. @MinistryWCD @narendramodi @PMOIndia

  • @nitin_gadkari

    Saddened to hear the unfortunate demise of Sudhir Telang. My deepest condolences to his family

  • @RSSorg

    SarKaryavah Suresh(Bhaiyaji)Joshi in Republic Day celebration at MIT Medical College, Latur (Maharashtra) https://t.co/Jr3ZCbeQjm

  • @drharshvardhan

    Sharing my interview with RS TV https://t.co/kZ9VdLOWi4

  • @umasribharti

    चन्‍द्रशेखर राव को बधाई. तेलंगाना राज्‍य का मेरा संकल्‍प एवं सपना पूरा, तेलंगाना की नदियों का ध्‍यान रखेंगें.

  • @Panda_Jay

    My Twitter handle changed yesterday to @PandaJay 😊, please follow that..