You are here: Home » PTI Stories » National » News

AAP govt moves HC agnst LG scrapping DERC chief's appointment

The AAP government today moved High seeking direction to Lieutenant Governor (LG) to reconsider his decision scrapping appointment of Krishna Saini as the Chairperson of Delhi's power regulator DERC.

The application was moved before a bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice Jayant Nath who were hearing two pleas challenging the appointment process of the government.

Citing Transaction of Business Rules (TBR), the government said the should be directed to "reconsider his decision on the request of Council of Ministers of GNCTD".

The has listed the application on November 25.

Najeeb Jung had on September 21 set aside Saini's appointment in March to the top post of Electricity Regulatory Commission (DERC), as it was done without taking his approval as mandated under the rules and procedure.

The government has said that "the order of the has only found fault with the process that was followed leading upto/culminating in the selection of the DERC Chief and has not otherwise found him unfit for the post".

The application said the high court, in its August 4 judgement interpreting the inter-relationship between the and the Council of Ministers, had said that if the does not agree with a decision taken by Council of Ministers, he was required to refer the matter to the President of India.

It further said the "Cabinet of the government is proposing to request the to consider the matter once again and grant ex-post facto approval, which would be in the interest of the seamless and unhindered supply of electricity to the citizens of the national capital of and hence undeniably in public interest".
The government had appointed Saini in March after the

high gave conditional permission during hearing of the pleas.

The first petition against the appointment was filed by Raman Suri, challenging government's December 2015 notification seeking applications for the post of DERC chairperson and one member.

Suri has argued that the chairperson of the commission should be a former high judge, since the adjudication of disputes between generating companies or transmission licensees was a "judicial function".

His PIL also challenged Section 84 of the Electricity Act 2003, arguing that the provision that a judge "may" be appointed should be read as mandatory.

The second petition was filed by lawyer A Mishra seeking scrapping of the appointment by the AAP government as it was made without LG's approval.

Mishra had alleged that Saini's appointment violated a February 20, 2004 notification issued by the ministry of home affairs under Article 239 of the Constitution, read with provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003.

The and AAP government have been at loggerheads over a range of issues, including appointments, and fighting it out in court.

The High had last month held that is the administrative head of which was a union territory, following which the AAP government had challenged the verdict in the Supreme Court.

image
Business Standard
177 22
Business Standard

AAP govt moves HC agnst LG scrapping DERC chief's appointment

Press Trust of India  |  New Delhi 

The AAP government today moved High seeking direction to Lieutenant Governor (LG) to reconsider his decision scrapping appointment of Krishna Saini as the Chairperson of Delhi's power regulator DERC.

The application was moved before a bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice Jayant Nath who were hearing two pleas challenging the appointment process of the government.



Citing Transaction of Business Rules (TBR), the government said the should be directed to "reconsider his decision on the request of Council of Ministers of GNCTD".

The has listed the application on November 25.

Najeeb Jung had on September 21 set aside Saini's appointment in March to the top post of Electricity Regulatory Commission (DERC), as it was done without taking his approval as mandated under the rules and procedure.

The government has said that "the order of the has only found fault with the process that was followed leading upto/culminating in the selection of the DERC Chief and has not otherwise found him unfit for the post".

The application said the high court, in its August 4 judgement interpreting the inter-relationship between the and the Council of Ministers, had said that if the does not agree with a decision taken by Council of Ministers, he was required to refer the matter to the President of India.

It further said the "Cabinet of the government is proposing to request the to consider the matter once again and grant ex-post facto approval, which would be in the interest of the seamless and unhindered supply of electricity to the citizens of the national capital of and hence undeniably in public interest".
The government had appointed Saini in March after the

high gave conditional permission during hearing of the pleas.

The first petition against the appointment was filed by Raman Suri, challenging government's December 2015 notification seeking applications for the post of DERC chairperson and one member.

Suri has argued that the chairperson of the commission should be a former high judge, since the adjudication of disputes between generating companies or transmission licensees was a "judicial function".

His PIL also challenged Section 84 of the Electricity Act 2003, arguing that the provision that a judge "may" be appointed should be read as mandatory.

The second petition was filed by lawyer A Mishra seeking scrapping of the appointment by the AAP government as it was made without LG's approval.

Mishra had alleged that Saini's appointment violated a February 20, 2004 notification issued by the ministry of home affairs under Article 239 of the Constitution, read with provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003.

The and AAP government have been at loggerheads over a range of issues, including appointments, and fighting it out in court.

The High had last month held that is the administrative head of which was a union territory, following which the AAP government had challenged the verdict in the Supreme Court.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

AAP govt moves HC agnst LG scrapping DERC chief's appointment

The AAP government today moved Delhi High Court seeking direction to Lieutenant Governor (LG) to reconsider his decision scrapping appointment of Krishna Saini as the Chairperson of Delhi's power regulator DERC. The application was moved before a bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice Jayant Nath who were hearing two pleas challenging the appointment process of the Delhi government. Citing Transaction of Business Rules (TBR), the Delhi government said the LG should be directed to "reconsider his decision on the request of Council of Ministers of GNCTD". The court has listed the application on November 25. LG Najeeb Jung had on September 21 set aside Saini's appointment in March to the top post of Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission (DERC), as it was done without taking his approval as mandated under the rules and procedure. The Delhi government has said that "the order of the LG has only found fault with the process that was followed leading upto/culminating in the ... The AAP government today moved High seeking direction to Lieutenant Governor (LG) to reconsider his decision scrapping appointment of Krishna Saini as the Chairperson of Delhi's power regulator DERC.

The application was moved before a bench of Chief Justice G Rohini and Justice Jayant Nath who were hearing two pleas challenging the appointment process of the government.

Citing Transaction of Business Rules (TBR), the government said the should be directed to "reconsider his decision on the request of Council of Ministers of GNCTD".

The has listed the application on November 25.

Najeeb Jung had on September 21 set aside Saini's appointment in March to the top post of Electricity Regulatory Commission (DERC), as it was done without taking his approval as mandated under the rules and procedure.

The government has said that "the order of the has only found fault with the process that was followed leading upto/culminating in the selection of the DERC Chief and has not otherwise found him unfit for the post".

The application said the high court, in its August 4 judgement interpreting the inter-relationship between the and the Council of Ministers, had said that if the does not agree with a decision taken by Council of Ministers, he was required to refer the matter to the President of India.

It further said the "Cabinet of the government is proposing to request the to consider the matter once again and grant ex-post facto approval, which would be in the interest of the seamless and unhindered supply of electricity to the citizens of the national capital of and hence undeniably in public interest".
The government had appointed Saini in March after the

high gave conditional permission during hearing of the pleas.

The first petition against the appointment was filed by Raman Suri, challenging government's December 2015 notification seeking applications for the post of DERC chairperson and one member.

Suri has argued that the chairperson of the commission should be a former high judge, since the adjudication of disputes between generating companies or transmission licensees was a "judicial function".

His PIL also challenged Section 84 of the Electricity Act 2003, arguing that the provision that a judge "may" be appointed should be read as mandatory.

The second petition was filed by lawyer A Mishra seeking scrapping of the appointment by the AAP government as it was made without LG's approval.

Mishra had alleged that Saini's appointment violated a February 20, 2004 notification issued by the ministry of home affairs under Article 239 of the Constitution, read with provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003.

The and AAP government have been at loggerheads over a range of issues, including appointments, and fighting it out in court.

The High had last month held that is the administrative head of which was a union territory, following which the AAP government had challenged the verdict in the Supreme Court.
image
Business Standard
177 22

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard