You are here: Home » PTI Stories » National » News
Business Standard

India alone may not bring about change in Pakistan: Expert

Press Trust of India  |  Washington 

Observing that tends to regard itself as "indispensable", an eminent South Asian expert has said that unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to "play games" with New Delhi.

"alone may not able to bring about change in Pakistan's behaviour. tends to think of itself as indispensable to the world: too important for the rest of the world to ignore.



"Thus unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to play games with India, assured by the prospect of lining up others behind it in its games," said Aparna Pande, director, Initiative on the Future of and South Asia, Hudson Institute, a think-tank.

As other experts at a panel discussion here urged to come up with policies to address Pakistan's concerns, Pande emphatically argued that in Pakistan, the psychological need for imaginary threats from will not go away as a result ofIndia's policies.

"needs to threaten and feel threatened by it to maintain its national identity. That makes normal policy responses ineffective," she said.

The military'sinstitutional interests requirethat continue to attract international attention through terrorism and nuclear weapons, she added.

"Nothing short offear oftheunraveling of or the prospect of global isolation will make the military rethink its fundamental worldview. has to remain the enemy, Kashmir must continue to be the casus belli. Nuclear arms must be brandished both to mobilise Pakistani nationalism and to keep at bay," Pande said.

"The world must be persuaded to remain engaged with on Pakistan's terms, without changing Pakistani behaviour. Promises must be made to be broken because no one can do anything about it any way," she said.

Pande warned that the reluctance to understand the military's mindset and worldview as the core issue in India-non-relations leads to ideas that look good on paper but will only lead to frustration down the road.

Pande was participating in a panel discussion on the launch of a book titled "Not War, Not Peace: Motivating to Prevent Cross-Border Terrorism," by George Perkovich and Toby Dalton of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Former Assistan Secretary of State for South Robin Raphel also spoke on the occasion.

Responding to the argument in the book that "the condition of 'no war' is unsustainable if 'no peace' is the core of either state's policy",Pande said one must look for ananswer to the question who gains by a 'no war, no peace' status.

"ItisPakistan's security establishment," she stressed.
Since there is no war the Pakistani militarydoes not need

to fightbut thepermanent stateof conflict- 'no peace' - keeps the military pre-eminent, she noted.

"Perhaps we need to come to terms with that reality and wait for the internal dynamics of to play themselves out. Instead of complex interaction, needs to just patiently wait for to feel the pain of its slowly growing isolation or collapse under the weight of its own policies," Pande said.

"Until and its military reinvent themselves, India's better option is to deal with like South Korea deals with North Korea, notwithstanding the many easily identifiable differences between North Korea and Pakistan," she said.

Noting that changing Pakistan's behaviour involves changing the fundamental nature of the Pakistani state, Pande said expecting to do that alone may be a bridge too far.

The analysis presented in book show that there are no clear solutions that can unilaterally pursue to end the threat of violence from Pakistan. Some are more or less likely to be effective at greater or lesser risk and cost to India.

"Only a combination of Indian coercive and nonviolent policies and capabilities, paired with a willingness to bargain, can motivate to remove the threat of violence.

And just as threat of force alone will not work for India, neither will support or tolerance of anti-terrorism enable to get what it wants from India," authors of the book argue.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

India alone may not bring about change in Pakistan: Expert

Observing that Pakistan tends to regard itself as "indispensable", an eminent South Asian expert has said that unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, Islamabad will only continue to "play games" with New Delhi. "India alone may not able to bring about change in Pakistan's behaviour. Pakistan tends to think of itself as indispensable to the world: too important for the rest of the world to ignore. "Thus unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, Pakistan will only continue to play games with India, assured by the prospect of lining up others behind it in its games," said Aparna Pande, director, Initiative on the Future of India and South Asia, Hudson Institute, a think-tank. As other experts at a panel discussion here urged India to come up with policies to address Pakistan's concerns, Pande emphatically argued that in Pakistan, the psychological need for imaginary threats from New Delhi will not go away as a result ofIndia's policies. "Pakistan needs to Observing that tends to regard itself as "indispensable", an eminent South Asian expert has said that unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to "play games" with New Delhi.

"alone may not able to bring about change in Pakistan's behaviour. tends to think of itself as indispensable to the world: too important for the rest of the world to ignore.

"Thus unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to play games with India, assured by the prospect of lining up others behind it in its games," said Aparna Pande, director, Initiative on the Future of and South Asia, Hudson Institute, a think-tank.

As other experts at a panel discussion here urged to come up with policies to address Pakistan's concerns, Pande emphatically argued that in Pakistan, the psychological need for imaginary threats from will not go away as a result ofIndia's policies.

"needs to threaten and feel threatened by it to maintain its national identity. That makes normal policy responses ineffective," she said.

The military'sinstitutional interests requirethat continue to attract international attention through terrorism and nuclear weapons, she added.

"Nothing short offear oftheunraveling of or the prospect of global isolation will make the military rethink its fundamental worldview. has to remain the enemy, Kashmir must continue to be the casus belli. Nuclear arms must be brandished both to mobilise Pakistani nationalism and to keep at bay," Pande said.

"The world must be persuaded to remain engaged with on Pakistan's terms, without changing Pakistani behaviour. Promises must be made to be broken because no one can do anything about it any way," she said.

Pande warned that the reluctance to understand the military's mindset and worldview as the core issue in India-non-relations leads to ideas that look good on paper but will only lead to frustration down the road.

Pande was participating in a panel discussion on the launch of a book titled "Not War, Not Peace: Motivating to Prevent Cross-Border Terrorism," by George Perkovich and Toby Dalton of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Former Assistan Secretary of State for South Robin Raphel also spoke on the occasion.

Responding to the argument in the book that "the condition of 'no war' is unsustainable if 'no peace' is the core of either state's policy",Pande said one must look for ananswer to the question who gains by a 'no war, no peace' status.

"ItisPakistan's security establishment," she stressed.
Since there is no war the Pakistani militarydoes not need

to fightbut thepermanent stateof conflict- 'no peace' - keeps the military pre-eminent, she noted.

"Perhaps we need to come to terms with that reality and wait for the internal dynamics of to play themselves out. Instead of complex interaction, needs to just patiently wait for to feel the pain of its slowly growing isolation or collapse under the weight of its own policies," Pande said.

"Until and its military reinvent themselves, India's better option is to deal with like South Korea deals with North Korea, notwithstanding the many easily identifiable differences between North Korea and Pakistan," she said.

Noting that changing Pakistan's behaviour involves changing the fundamental nature of the Pakistani state, Pande said expecting to do that alone may be a bridge too far.

The analysis presented in book show that there are no clear solutions that can unilaterally pursue to end the threat of violence from Pakistan. Some are more or less likely to be effective at greater or lesser risk and cost to India.

"Only a combination of Indian coercive and nonviolent policies and capabilities, paired with a willingness to bargain, can motivate to remove the threat of violence.

And just as threat of force alone will not work for India, neither will support or tolerance of anti-terrorism enable to get what it wants from India," authors of the book argue.
image
Business Standard
177 22

India alone may not bring about change in Pakistan: Expert

Observing that tends to regard itself as "indispensable", an eminent South Asian expert has said that unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to "play games" with New Delhi.

"alone may not able to bring about change in Pakistan's behaviour. tends to think of itself as indispensable to the world: too important for the rest of the world to ignore.

"Thus unless the rest of the world is willing to join India, will only continue to play games with India, assured by the prospect of lining up others behind it in its games," said Aparna Pande, director, Initiative on the Future of and South Asia, Hudson Institute, a think-tank.

As other experts at a panel discussion here urged to come up with policies to address Pakistan's concerns, Pande emphatically argued that in Pakistan, the psychological need for imaginary threats from will not go away as a result ofIndia's policies.

"needs to threaten and feel threatened by it to maintain its national identity. That makes normal policy responses ineffective," she said.

The military'sinstitutional interests requirethat continue to attract international attention through terrorism and nuclear weapons, she added.

"Nothing short offear oftheunraveling of or the prospect of global isolation will make the military rethink its fundamental worldview. has to remain the enemy, Kashmir must continue to be the casus belli. Nuclear arms must be brandished both to mobilise Pakistani nationalism and to keep at bay," Pande said.

"The world must be persuaded to remain engaged with on Pakistan's terms, without changing Pakistani behaviour. Promises must be made to be broken because no one can do anything about it any way," she said.

Pande warned that the reluctance to understand the military's mindset and worldview as the core issue in India-non-relations leads to ideas that look good on paper but will only lead to frustration down the road.

Pande was participating in a panel discussion on the launch of a book titled "Not War, Not Peace: Motivating to Prevent Cross-Border Terrorism," by George Perkovich and Toby Dalton of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Former Assistan Secretary of State for South Robin Raphel also spoke on the occasion.

Responding to the argument in the book that "the condition of 'no war' is unsustainable if 'no peace' is the core of either state's policy",Pande said one must look for ananswer to the question who gains by a 'no war, no peace' status.

"ItisPakistan's security establishment," she stressed.
Since there is no war the Pakistani militarydoes not need

to fightbut thepermanent stateof conflict- 'no peace' - keeps the military pre-eminent, she noted.

"Perhaps we need to come to terms with that reality and wait for the internal dynamics of to play themselves out. Instead of complex interaction, needs to just patiently wait for to feel the pain of its slowly growing isolation or collapse under the weight of its own policies," Pande said.

"Until and its military reinvent themselves, India's better option is to deal with like South Korea deals with North Korea, notwithstanding the many easily identifiable differences between North Korea and Pakistan," she said.

Noting that changing Pakistan's behaviour involves changing the fundamental nature of the Pakistani state, Pande said expecting to do that alone may be a bridge too far.

The analysis presented in book show that there are no clear solutions that can unilaterally pursue to end the threat of violence from Pakistan. Some are more or less likely to be effective at greater or lesser risk and cost to India.

"Only a combination of Indian coercive and nonviolent policies and capabilities, paired with a willingness to bargain, can motivate to remove the threat of violence.

And just as threat of force alone will not work for India, neither will support or tolerance of anti-terrorism enable to get what it wants from India," authors of the book argue.

image
Business Standard
177 22

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard