You are here: Home » PTI Stories » National » News
Business Standard

Parl Standing Comm not to be briefed on surgical strikes; Cong

Press Trust of India  |  New Delhi 

A controversy has broken out over the last minute dropping of a planned briefing on surgical strikes at the meeting of the Parliamentary Standing Committee for Defence tomorrow with two senior members dubbing it "highly unacceptable" and pitching for bringing back the original agenda.

"The decision not to brief the committee over surgical strikes under the garb of secrecy only amounts to 'lack of confidence' in the Members of Parliament, who are in the committee and who are bound by the oath of secrecy. This position is absolutely unacceptable to us," party General Secretaries and Madhusudan Mistry said in a joint statement.



leader Subramanian Swamy, who is also a member of the Standing Committee, however, differed saying the decision should be left to the army.

Mistry said they have written to Committee's Chairman telling him the move is "highly unacceptable".

"We are deeply disappointed over the last minute change of agenda," they said, adding "We demand that the original agenda of the forthcoming Committee meeting should be maintained and also defence officials inform the Committee about the number of surgical strikes carried out since 2004."

"It is our firm belief that the officials should brief the standing committee members as they briefed the leaders of the opposition parties on the above said issues."

They insisted it's high time the attitude of the defence officials towards the standing committee members "change for the better" and committee is informed of the "shortcomings" the forces are facing in combating adversaries on borders.

"We believe that the agenda must have been fixed after consultation with top officials of defence ministry. We see no reason why this has been changed and that too at the last minute," they said.

They said this is not the first such instance and the agenda of such meetings has been changed earlier too.

They complained that it's unfortunate that they come to know of the shortage of arms and ammunition to the Special Forces, who carried out surgical strikes through newspaper, but the army officials are not ready to discuss or answer queries to be raised in the meeting of Standing Committee Members.
Speaking separately of the two leaders, BJP's MP

Swamy said, "If the Army feels that something has to be kept secret for sometime, there is no way we in the committee can challenge it. The Committee chairman is consulted by the Army chief and the chairman also interacts with the government."

However, Soni and Mistry blamed the Defence Ministry for not presenting their policies and preparedness to meet emergency situations, despite repeated mentions at the meetings.

Besides, they said the ministry has not come out with valid reasons for delay in acquisition of Defence equipment including arms and ammunition.

"The Make in India initiative also seems to be a complete failure in the Defence sector," they opined.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

Parl Standing Comm not to be briefed on surgical strikes; Cong

A controversy has broken out over the last minute dropping of a planned briefing on surgical strikes at the meeting of the Parliamentary Standing Committee for Defence tomorrow with two senior Congress members dubbing it "highly unacceptable" and pitching for bringing back the original agenda. "The decision not to brief the committee over surgical strikes under the garb of secrecy only amounts to 'lack of confidence' in the Members of Parliament, who are in the committee and who are bound by the oath of secrecy. This position is absolutely unacceptable to us," party General Secretaries Ambika Soni and Madhusudan Mistry said in a joint statement. BJP leader Subramanian Swamy, who is also a member of the Standing Committee, however, differed saying the decision should be left to the army. Mistry said they have written to Committee's Chairman B C Khanduri telling him the move is "highly unacceptable". "We are deeply disappointed over the last minute change of agenda," they said, ... A controversy has broken out over the last minute dropping of a planned briefing on surgical strikes at the meeting of the Parliamentary Standing Committee for Defence tomorrow with two senior members dubbing it "highly unacceptable" and pitching for bringing back the original agenda.

"The decision not to brief the committee over surgical strikes under the garb of secrecy only amounts to 'lack of confidence' in the Members of Parliament, who are in the committee and who are bound by the oath of secrecy. This position is absolutely unacceptable to us," party General Secretaries and Madhusudan Mistry said in a joint statement.

leader Subramanian Swamy, who is also a member of the Standing Committee, however, differed saying the decision should be left to the army.

Mistry said they have written to Committee's Chairman telling him the move is "highly unacceptable".

"We are deeply disappointed over the last minute change of agenda," they said, adding "We demand that the original agenda of the forthcoming Committee meeting should be maintained and also defence officials inform the Committee about the number of surgical strikes carried out since 2004."

"It is our firm belief that the officials should brief the standing committee members as they briefed the leaders of the opposition parties on the above said issues."

They insisted it's high time the attitude of the defence officials towards the standing committee members "change for the better" and committee is informed of the "shortcomings" the forces are facing in combating adversaries on borders.

"We believe that the agenda must have been fixed after consultation with top officials of defence ministry. We see no reason why this has been changed and that too at the last minute," they said.

They said this is not the first such instance and the agenda of such meetings has been changed earlier too.

They complained that it's unfortunate that they come to know of the shortage of arms and ammunition to the Special Forces, who carried out surgical strikes through newspaper, but the army officials are not ready to discuss or answer queries to be raised in the meeting of Standing Committee Members.
Speaking separately of the two leaders, BJP's MP

Swamy said, "If the Army feels that something has to be kept secret for sometime, there is no way we in the committee can challenge it. The Committee chairman is consulted by the Army chief and the chairman also interacts with the government."

However, Soni and Mistry blamed the Defence Ministry for not presenting their policies and preparedness to meet emergency situations, despite repeated mentions at the meetings.

Besides, they said the ministry has not come out with valid reasons for delay in acquisition of Defence equipment including arms and ammunition.

"The Make in India initiative also seems to be a complete failure in the Defence sector," they opined.
image
Business Standard
177 22

Parl Standing Comm not to be briefed on surgical strikes; Cong

A controversy has broken out over the last minute dropping of a planned briefing on surgical strikes at the meeting of the Parliamentary Standing Committee for Defence tomorrow with two senior members dubbing it "highly unacceptable" and pitching for bringing back the original agenda.

"The decision not to brief the committee over surgical strikes under the garb of secrecy only amounts to 'lack of confidence' in the Members of Parliament, who are in the committee and who are bound by the oath of secrecy. This position is absolutely unacceptable to us," party General Secretaries and Madhusudan Mistry said in a joint statement.

leader Subramanian Swamy, who is also a member of the Standing Committee, however, differed saying the decision should be left to the army.

Mistry said they have written to Committee's Chairman telling him the move is "highly unacceptable".

"We are deeply disappointed over the last minute change of agenda," they said, adding "We demand that the original agenda of the forthcoming Committee meeting should be maintained and also defence officials inform the Committee about the number of surgical strikes carried out since 2004."

"It is our firm belief that the officials should brief the standing committee members as they briefed the leaders of the opposition parties on the above said issues."

They insisted it's high time the attitude of the defence officials towards the standing committee members "change for the better" and committee is informed of the "shortcomings" the forces are facing in combating adversaries on borders.

"We believe that the agenda must have been fixed after consultation with top officials of defence ministry. We see no reason why this has been changed and that too at the last minute," they said.

They said this is not the first such instance and the agenda of such meetings has been changed earlier too.

They complained that it's unfortunate that they come to know of the shortage of arms and ammunition to the Special Forces, who carried out surgical strikes through newspaper, but the army officials are not ready to discuss or answer queries to be raised in the meeting of Standing Committee Members.
Speaking separately of the two leaders, BJP's MP

Swamy said, "If the Army feels that something has to be kept secret for sometime, there is no way we in the committee can challenge it. The Committee chairman is consulted by the Army chief and the chairman also interacts with the government."

However, Soni and Mistry blamed the Defence Ministry for not presenting their policies and preparedness to meet emergency situations, despite repeated mentions at the meetings.

Besides, they said the ministry has not come out with valid reasons for delay in acquisition of Defence equipment including arms and ammunition.

"The Make in India initiative also seems to be a complete failure in the Defence sector," they opined.

image
Business Standard
177 22

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard