You are here: Home » PTI Stories » National » News
Business Standard

US church shooter to represent self at trial

AFP  |  Charleston (US) 

A US federal judge has granted self-described white supremacist Dylann Roof's request to represent himself at trial on charges of gunning down nine African-American churchgoers last year in South Carolina.

US Richard Gergel's ruling means that Roof, 22, could cross-examine survivors and family members of those he mowed down in June 2015 during a Bible study class at the historic "Mother Emmanuel" black church in Charleston.



"I do find defendant has the personal capacity to self-representation," Gergel said.

"I continue to believe it is strategically unwise, but it is a decision you have the right to make."

Federal prosecutors are seeking to put Roof to death, and have refused to accept his offer to plead guilty to the 33 federal charges against him -- including hate crime violations that could carry the death penalty -- in exchange for a life sentence.

Roof is also facing state charges in South Carolina and faces the death penalty for his allegedly racially-motivated attack.

The case got under way earlier this month, but had to be postponed while the court determined whether Roof was mentally competent to stand trial.

Roof was granted the chance to represent himself shortly before jury selection began for the case. The ruling follows Gergel's ruling on Friday finding Roof was mentally competent to stand trial following a recent mental health evaluation.

Court proceedings are now focused on impaneling a 12-member jury and alternates, a process expected to take at least three weeks.

Legal experts say mistakes made by a defendant acting as his or her own lawyer -- without legal training -- can be especially damaging in a case involving capital punishment.

"I don't see any circumstance where it won't be self-destructive," said James Coleman of Duke Law School.

In the 1980s, Coleman represented the late serial killer Ted Bundy, unsuccessfully trying to appeal the death sentence handed down to Bundy after the killer served as his own defense lawyer and was convicted.

Juries tend to react negatively to a defendant acting as his own counsel, possibly interpreting the maneuver as making a mockery of the court and the defendant's alleged crimes.

Roof will be disadvantaged in not knowing court rules and the ins and outs of legal strategy, but that may not matter to the accused killer, Coleman suggested.

"He'll be a loose cannon and basically can severely disrupt the trial," said Coleman.

"He may not care. He may be using this as his last hurrah.

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

US church shooter to represent self at trial

A US federal judge has granted self-described white supremacist Dylann Roof's request to represent himself at trial on charges of gunning down nine African-American churchgoers last year in South Carolina. US District Judge Richard Gergel's ruling means that Roof, 22, could cross-examine survivors and family members of those he mowed down in June 2015 during a Bible study class at the historic "Mother Emmanuel" black church in Charleston. "I do find defendant has the personal capacity to self-representation," Gergel said. "I continue to believe it is strategically unwise, but it is a decision you have the right to make." Federal prosecutors are seeking to put Roof to death, and have refused to accept his offer to plead guilty to the 33 federal charges against him -- including hate crime violations that could carry the death penalty -- in exchange for a life sentence. Roof is also facing state murder charges in South Carolina and faces the death penalty for his allegedly ... A US federal judge has granted self-described white supremacist Dylann Roof's request to represent himself at trial on charges of gunning down nine African-American churchgoers last year in South Carolina.

US Richard Gergel's ruling means that Roof, 22, could cross-examine survivors and family members of those he mowed down in June 2015 during a Bible study class at the historic "Mother Emmanuel" black church in Charleston.

"I do find defendant has the personal capacity to self-representation," Gergel said.

"I continue to believe it is strategically unwise, but it is a decision you have the right to make."

Federal prosecutors are seeking to put Roof to death, and have refused to accept his offer to plead guilty to the 33 federal charges against him -- including hate crime violations that could carry the death penalty -- in exchange for a life sentence.

Roof is also facing state charges in South Carolina and faces the death penalty for his allegedly racially-motivated attack.

The case got under way earlier this month, but had to be postponed while the court determined whether Roof was mentally competent to stand trial.

Roof was granted the chance to represent himself shortly before jury selection began for the case. The ruling follows Gergel's ruling on Friday finding Roof was mentally competent to stand trial following a recent mental health evaluation.

Court proceedings are now focused on impaneling a 12-member jury and alternates, a process expected to take at least three weeks.

Legal experts say mistakes made by a defendant acting as his or her own lawyer -- without legal training -- can be especially damaging in a case involving capital punishment.

"I don't see any circumstance where it won't be self-destructive," said James Coleman of Duke Law School.

In the 1980s, Coleman represented the late serial killer Ted Bundy, unsuccessfully trying to appeal the death sentence handed down to Bundy after the killer served as his own defense lawyer and was convicted.

Juries tend to react negatively to a defendant acting as his own counsel, possibly interpreting the maneuver as making a mockery of the court and the defendant's alleged crimes.

Roof will be disadvantaged in not knowing court rules and the ins and outs of legal strategy, but that may not matter to the accused killer, Coleman suggested.

"He'll be a loose cannon and basically can severely disrupt the trial," said Coleman.

"He may not care. He may be using this as his last hurrah.

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

image
Business Standard
177 22

US church shooter to represent self at trial

A US federal judge has granted self-described white supremacist Dylann Roof's request to represent himself at trial on charges of gunning down nine African-American churchgoers last year in South Carolina.

US Richard Gergel's ruling means that Roof, 22, could cross-examine survivors and family members of those he mowed down in June 2015 during a Bible study class at the historic "Mother Emmanuel" black church in Charleston.

"I do find defendant has the personal capacity to self-representation," Gergel said.

"I continue to believe it is strategically unwise, but it is a decision you have the right to make."

Federal prosecutors are seeking to put Roof to death, and have refused to accept his offer to plead guilty to the 33 federal charges against him -- including hate crime violations that could carry the death penalty -- in exchange for a life sentence.

Roof is also facing state charges in South Carolina and faces the death penalty for his allegedly racially-motivated attack.

The case got under way earlier this month, but had to be postponed while the court determined whether Roof was mentally competent to stand trial.

Roof was granted the chance to represent himself shortly before jury selection began for the case. The ruling follows Gergel's ruling on Friday finding Roof was mentally competent to stand trial following a recent mental health evaluation.

Court proceedings are now focused on impaneling a 12-member jury and alternates, a process expected to take at least three weeks.

Legal experts say mistakes made by a defendant acting as his or her own lawyer -- without legal training -- can be especially damaging in a case involving capital punishment.

"I don't see any circumstance where it won't be self-destructive," said James Coleman of Duke Law School.

In the 1980s, Coleman represented the late serial killer Ted Bundy, unsuccessfully trying to appeal the death sentence handed down to Bundy after the killer served as his own defense lawyer and was convicted.

Juries tend to react negatively to a defendant acting as his own counsel, possibly interpreting the maneuver as making a mockery of the court and the defendant's alleged crimes.

Roof will be disadvantaged in not knowing court rules and the ins and outs of legal strategy, but that may not matter to the accused killer, Coleman suggested.

"He'll be a loose cannon and basically can severely disrupt the trial," said Coleman.

"He may not care. He may be using this as his last hurrah.

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

image
Business Standard
177 22

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard