You are here: Home » Companies » News
Business Standard

CCI orders antitrust probe into Roche cancer drug

Biocon and Mylan told CCI that Roche misled doctors, regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab

Reuters  |  Mumbai 

Roche
Roche tablets are seen positioned in front of a displayed Roche logo in this picture illustration (Photo: Reuters)

The antitrust regulator has ordered a probe into Swiss drugmaker for allegedly using anti-competitive practices to restrict cheaper copies of a blockbuster from reaching patients.

Trastuzumab has been a mainstay of Roche's profit for years and brought in global sales of about $6.7 billion in 2016, but it has been challenged in the last three years by biosimilars which are sold at about a 25 percent discount to the original.

and US firm Mylan, which together sell biosimilars of the drug in over a dozen countries including India, filed a complaint with the Competition Commission of India (CCI) last year alleging misled doctors and regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab.

"adheres to all applicable laws and regulations in countries where it operates," spokeswoman said in a statement. "We are fully committed to cooperating with the authorities in India."

India, with among the highest number of cancer patients in the world, is a big market for trastuzumab, which is indicated to treat certain forms of breast and gastric cancer and which sells under the brand name Herceptin.

Globally, the market for trastuzumab is getting increasingly crowded, with analysts saying late on Wednesday that U.S. biotech firm Amgen and partner Allergan are seeking approval for their form of trastuzumab later this year.

first launched the drug in India in 2002 and sells it for about Rs 75,000 ($1,170) for a 440 mg vial.

In an interim order released on Tuesday, the CCI said it found merit in and Mylan's arguments, and ordered its director general to conduct a "detailed investigation" and submit a report within 60 days.

Although the order is not final, the investigation could result in penalties, said a lawyer at the Delhi High Court, who declined to be named.

said in a statement that it welcomed the CCI's order.

Roche, which has been engaged in a legal tussle with and Mylan since 2014, has the option of filing a petition to contest the order, the lawyer added.

In their complaint, and Mylan allege wrote to doctors, hospitals, and state and federal regulators, misleading them about the safety of efficacy of the biosimilar versions.

"When seen collectively in the background of surrounding facts and circumstances, they only appear to be a part of the bigger plan/strategy of Group to eliminate competition posed by biosimilars to Roche's products in the relevant market," the CCI said in its order.

($1 = 64.0900 Indian rupees)

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

CCI orders antitrust probe into Roche cancer drug

Biocon and Mylan told CCI that Roche misled doctors, regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab

Biocon and Mylan told CCI that Roche misled doctors, regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab

The antitrust regulator has ordered a probe into Swiss drugmaker for allegedly using anti-competitive practices to restrict cheaper copies of a blockbuster from reaching patients.

Trastuzumab has been a mainstay of Roche's profit for years and brought in global sales of about $6.7 billion in 2016, but it has been challenged in the last three years by biosimilars which are sold at about a 25 percent discount to the original.

and US firm Mylan, which together sell biosimilars of the drug in over a dozen countries including India, filed a complaint with the Competition Commission of India (CCI) last year alleging misled doctors and regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab.

"adheres to all applicable laws and regulations in countries where it operates," spokeswoman said in a statement. "We are fully committed to cooperating with the authorities in India."

India, with among the highest number of cancer patients in the world, is a big market for trastuzumab, which is indicated to treat certain forms of breast and gastric cancer and which sells under the brand name Herceptin.

Globally, the market for trastuzumab is getting increasingly crowded, with analysts saying late on Wednesday that U.S. biotech firm Amgen and partner Allergan are seeking approval for their form of trastuzumab later this year.

first launched the drug in India in 2002 and sells it for about Rs 75,000 ($1,170) for a 440 mg vial.

In an interim order released on Tuesday, the CCI said it found merit in and Mylan's arguments, and ordered its director general to conduct a "detailed investigation" and submit a report within 60 days.

Although the order is not final, the investigation could result in penalties, said a lawyer at the Delhi High Court, who declined to be named.

said in a statement that it welcomed the CCI's order.

Roche, which has been engaged in a legal tussle with and Mylan since 2014, has the option of filing a petition to contest the order, the lawyer added.

In their complaint, and Mylan allege wrote to doctors, hospitals, and state and federal regulators, misleading them about the safety of efficacy of the biosimilar versions.

"When seen collectively in the background of surrounding facts and circumstances, they only appear to be a part of the bigger plan/strategy of Group to eliminate competition posed by biosimilars to Roche's products in the relevant market," the CCI said in its order.

($1 = 64.0900 Indian rupees)

image
Business Standard
177 22

CCI orders antitrust probe into Roche cancer drug

Biocon and Mylan told CCI that Roche misled doctors, regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab

The antitrust regulator has ordered a probe into Swiss drugmaker for allegedly using anti-competitive practices to restrict cheaper copies of a blockbuster from reaching patients.

Trastuzumab has been a mainstay of Roche's profit for years and brought in global sales of about $6.7 billion in 2016, but it has been challenged in the last three years by biosimilars which are sold at about a 25 percent discount to the original.

and US firm Mylan, which together sell biosimilars of the drug in over a dozen countries including India, filed a complaint with the Competition Commission of India (CCI) last year alleging misled doctors and regulators to thwart competition to Trastuzumab.

"adheres to all applicable laws and regulations in countries where it operates," spokeswoman said in a statement. "We are fully committed to cooperating with the authorities in India."

India, with among the highest number of cancer patients in the world, is a big market for trastuzumab, which is indicated to treat certain forms of breast and gastric cancer and which sells under the brand name Herceptin.

Globally, the market for trastuzumab is getting increasingly crowded, with analysts saying late on Wednesday that U.S. biotech firm Amgen and partner Allergan are seeking approval for their form of trastuzumab later this year.

first launched the drug in India in 2002 and sells it for about Rs 75,000 ($1,170) for a 440 mg vial.

In an interim order released on Tuesday, the CCI said it found merit in and Mylan's arguments, and ordered its director general to conduct a "detailed investigation" and submit a report within 60 days.

Although the order is not final, the investigation could result in penalties, said a lawyer at the Delhi High Court, who declined to be named.

said in a statement that it welcomed the CCI's order.

Roche, which has been engaged in a legal tussle with and Mylan since 2014, has the option of filing a petition to contest the order, the lawyer added.

In their complaint, and Mylan allege wrote to doctors, hospitals, and state and federal regulators, misleading them about the safety of efficacy of the biosimilar versions.

"When seen collectively in the background of surrounding facts and circumstances, they only appear to be a part of the bigger plan/strategy of Group to eliminate competition posed by biosimilars to Roche's products in the relevant market," the CCI said in its order.

($1 = 64.0900 Indian rupees)

image
Business Standard
177 22