Business Standard
Thursday, Feb 16, 2012
Sponsored by  
drived banner
drived banner
  Advanced Search
RSS
Content Guide
Follow us on  
|||||Opinion|||| 
 Section Home | Editorials | Compass | BS People | Columnists | Lunch with BS
Home > Opinion & Analysis Live Markets | Commodities
 
Abheek Barua: One year of the sub-prime crisis
Abheek Barua / New Delhi July 07, 2008, 0:18 IST

As the crisis originated in the asset markets, its resolution too will lie in the asset markets.

A popular example of the complexity of "chaos" theory involves a butterfly flapping its wings somewhere in Latin America and through an intricate chain of linkages setting off a powerful tornado thousands of miles across the globe. The current financial crisis is perhaps an equally poignant illustration. What started as a sell-off in the market for American mortgage-backed bonds sometime in July 2007 has now manifested in a sharp rise in inflation rates in Asian economies.

One of the errors in judgement, in my opinion, that economists made at the early stages of the crisis was in making the following assumption — that the transmission of the US crisis would work essentially through macro-economic linkages. The key elements of this hypothesis were the following. Falling house prices would erode household wealth and destroy consumer demand. Hurt by a rising share bad loans on their books, banks would cut back on credit. This would choke both consumer and investment demand further. As the US slumped, the rest of the world would also slow down since trade and investment flows with the US are really what kept the rest of the world ticking. This seemed like a fairly neat hypothesis except for one problem. The corollary of this sequence of events would be a sharp decline in all commodity prices as global demand contracted. Thus the fact that oil sells for close to $150 a barrel today and steel prices are soaring suggests a fundamental flaw.

Where specifically did this hypothesis go wrong? Has the US showed more resilience to the problems in its mortgage market than expected? Not quite. There is enough evidence that the US has slowed down substantially over the past six months although it is technically perhaps still not in recession. Consumer spending has dissipated and corporate sales are sluggish. The housing market is in free fall. The US may be in deep trouble but has its problems impinged on the rest of the world? This is where the macro-transmission hypothesis begins to falter. The rest of the world does not seem to have been affected as much or as quickly as many had anticipated. Europe, for one, is still holding up though there are growing signs of moderation. Asia certainly has not collapsed.

Does this mean that other economies have entirely decoupled from the US growth engine? The jury is still out on this. It is possible that it is just a question of leads and lags. Other economies will respond to the US with a longer lag than anticipated by the end of this year, the global economic system would have slowed considerably. However, at least for me, this is a somewhat peripheral issue or question.

What seems more important is the fact that the initial shock (that emerged from the US mortgage markets) has transmitted to the rest of the world not through visible macroeconomic linkages but rather through dramatic shifts in risk appetite and asset preferences. Thus, the first signs of an end to the crisis have to be found in asset market movements, rather than in hard macroeconomic data.

Let me explain. By the beginning of the year (that is, roughly six months into the US mortgage crisis), most analysts had recognised that risk aversion had risen sharply and the search for a safe haven would determine the way investors would allocate their assets in 2008. Emerging markets, touted as a hedge against the US for a while last year, soon fell out of favour. Analysts predicted that global investments would find their way into the time-tested "safest of the safe" havens, US treasury bills and bonds. Thus, despite the underlying problems in the US, the flight to safety would support the dollar.

This, however, was not to be. Two alternative assets classes emerged as a viable hedge against the dollar. Investors seeking insulation from the heat of the US economic meltdown started to hold commodities (particularly oil) and short-term European government debt instruments. As the flow of bad news from the US accelerated, investors dumped dollar assets and bought heavily into these asset classes. Both the euro and commodity prices gained as a result. There were other quick intermediate effects — rising oil prices fed the expectations of an accelerated shift of cultivable land away from food into bio-fuels. Food prices rose in response.

The net result was the emergence of a global macroeconomic crisis that involves a peculiar conjunction of two trends that currently run parallel but are usually in conflict with each other. The prospect of a global slowdown that going by conventional wisdom should breed deflation goes hand in hand with rising inflation. This makes it so difficult to handle. Central bankers find it difficult to figure out which of the two evils is lesser. Do they pare interest rates to thwart a slowdown or raise them to fight inflation?

My sense is that the beginning of the end of the crisis will be seen when this dilemma is resolved. Just as the transmission of the crisis worked through asset markets, the resolution will also lie in the asset markets. Renewed preference for dollar assets will lead to moderation in commodity prices and will go hand in hand with euro depreciation. As this happens, inflationary pressures will wane. Central banks will then have a more defined remit — to get growth back on track. How soon can this happen? As soon as investors get the first whiff that the US business cycle is close to a bottom, risk preference could change dramatically. That is certainly possible in the next few months.

The author is chief economist, HDFC Bank. The views here are personal

New Ipad Application :Business Standard's all new IPad App
Click here to download for free
Arrow Other Stories     
- Markets end lower on profit booking
- Govt goes ahead to allow direct import of jet fuel by airlines
- Sahara-BCCI stalemate ends, Pune Warriors to play in IPL
- GM reports weaker-than-expected profit
- Israel steps up security for its diplomats
  Read Business news in 
- Now property search gets more exciting than ever before!
- IndianOil Citibank Card at Zero annual card fee
- We live for our family. have you secured them?
- Earn fuel worth Rs.2400 with Citi
- India's No. 1 Property Site. Click here to know more..
- Diseases earlier, Saving Costs, Extending Lives. Know More..
- Win a Business Class Ticket to Europe..Know more..
- Enjoy the journey as much as the destination. click to know more..
- Exim Bank Conclave on India - Africa Project Partnership. Know more..
- Medium-sized businesses are the engines of a smarter planet.
- Be part of it The World's Largest Aircraft.
- Creating Wealth made simple the SIP way. Know more..
- Only Developer to give a guarantee on time space & rate.
- Office 365 for professionals and small businesses.
- Buy Your Property with Our Triple Guarantee in India.
- Improve Patient Care & Experience. Click here to know more
-  Introduce a New Automotive Luxury Car.. know more
- Health is Wealth..... Insurance + Savings... Know More...
Sorry, comments to this story are closed
Latest Messages
Posted by: v.b.sastry
The primary errors that caused the disaster appear to be:(a) Lending based on current market values without considering the levels of income and the repayment capability of the loan beneficiaries, and (b) rating these loans as prime ones in securitising them and offloading them on innocent and well-meaning financial institutions. What action has been taken against the concerned lenders, their auditors and the rating companie that allowed the rating of those loans as prime credit?
Posted by: chandru541969
How soon can this happen? As soon as investors get the first whiff that the US business cycle is close to a bottom, risk preference could change dramatically. That is certainly possible in the next few months. With 750 billion trade deficit per annum and 350 billion budget deficit of USA (set aside pentagon`s unexposed budgets)the last four lines are nothing but pure day dreaming. USA has only one of the two options either enter economic depression or face hyperinflation.
SmartInvestor+ E-zine
  Pay Rs.747/- for 3 years and
  get a branded watch FREE

  Subscribe Now
Most Popular
Read
E-Mailed
Commented
   
- Leela parts ways with Kempinski
- Kanika Datta: The importance of being SRK
- Nestle: Food for thought
- Tailor-made but not good enough
- Star-studded jury honours corporate excellence
 
 More  
BUSINESS STANDARD INDIA 2012
  Now available at Special price
  Rs.395/- Only
  Buy Now
  Now available on the Kindle Store...
  BS Specials  
    Full coverage of elections in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Uttarakhand, Manipur and Goa
  Hot Searches  
 
IRFC bond |  Antrix-Devas |  Rafale fighter |  Junglee |  IPL 5 |  Dhanlaxmi Bank |  Thomas Cook |  TCS |  Sarfaesi Act |  Vodafone |  Aakash tablet |  Sodexo |  Rupee |  Samsung Galaxy Note |  Kingfisher Airlines |  Silver |  Provident Fund |  income tax refund |  Anna Hazare |  iPhone |  Reliance Industries |  SEBI |  BSNL |  BSE |  NSE |  Mukesh Ambani |  Anil Ambani |  Infosys |  Pranab Mukherjee |  Sonia Gandhi |  Rahul Gandhi |  New Pension Scheme |  Reliance |  RBI |  GDP |  Gold |  Ratan Tata |  ICICI |  B-School |  Sensex |  Tax calculator |  Home Loan |  Personal Finance |  inflation |  oil prices |  Barack Obama |   
 
  Member Area Write to the Editor RSS Archives Advanced Search
  Subscribe to BS print product BS e-paper Newsletter Portfolio Tracker
  BS Products BS Hindi BS Motoring BS Books
FOR HOT PRODUCTS
BS Bazaar.com
Home | Markets & Investing | Companies & Industry | Banking & Finance | Economy & Policy | Opinion
Life & Leisure | Management & Marketing | Tech World
About Us | Partner With Us | Code of Conduct | Careers | Advertise with us| Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Contact Us