We not only have an oversupply of MBAs already, but have MBAs whose academic and experience profile actually makes them another "brick in the wall"
Arvind Singhal / New Delhi May 06, 2010, 00:36 IST
For the last few years, every MBA placement season sees a flurry of releases from various business schools on the highest and average salaries offered to their newly minted MBA graduates. Each year, the numbers show a rising trend, and if these numbers are to be taken at face value, India must be facing an incredible crunch of entry-level managerial talent since such compensation levels are aspirational even for mid-career professionals in other functions, such as manufacturing, or professional service providers, such as doctors and chartered accountants. Sometime later in the year, it would be the “ranking” season when leading business magazines come out with cover stories carrying their rankings of leading business schools in India, adding further glamour to the MBA degree.
Largely unstated are the less-than-stellar overall placement records for most MBA institutes in India, including some that have made it to even the top-10 rankings. While it may be true that finally most MBAs from the top-10 or even the top-25 ranked institutes find some job and hence they are technically “placed”, it is also true that increasingly, many of them are forced to take up jobs that could be easily managed by someone with a basic graduation degree itself. The plight of those who do not come from the top-25 institutions is probably worse. Indeed, if the glamour and the clamour for an MBA degree continue to grow as it has in the last few years, and with both public and private institutions creating capacity at the same pace as they have been doing recently, it may be an exaggeration, but just barely, that we will see legions of MBAs in the field sales force of pharmaceutical or FMCG companies, on the shop floor of retail outlets, and in different types of BPOs and KPOs.
Hard data supports the onset of this glut of MBAs. In 2000, there were about 600 colleges in India offering about 70,000 MBA seats. By the end of 2009, the number had increased to 1,400 colleges offering about 120,000 MBA seats! The intake of the top-20 institutes alone has increased from 1,500 in 2000 to over 5,000 in 2009, and is poised to increase further in the next five years as more IIMs come into operation while the current top-ranked ones (IIMs and others) further expand capacity or add new campuses and programmes. By comparison, the US (whose economy is over 10 times bigger than that of India) has about 1,000 colleges offering about 150,000 MBA seats to both US citizens and to a growing pool of international applicants. In the entire European Union (EU), whose economy is also over 10 times that of India and which has much more diversity in terms of number of countries and businesses, there are just about 550 colleges offering about 100,000 MBA seats. Major EU economies such as Germany, France and the UK individually offer between 8,600 and 27,000 MBA seats despite each being significantly larger and more global than India is at this time.
Making it worse is the highly flawed selection criterion of almost all Indian MBA colleges, including the IIMs. The 2010 incoming batch, for instance, has just 6 per cent women, about 94 per cent are engineers with just an isolated representative from arts stream, 33 per cent have no work experience at all and 41 per cent have less than two years of experience. There is very high probability that even this experience profile will largely have applicants who have worked in the IT sector post-engineering and wish to make a transition out of the IT sector itself. Harvard’s class of 2010 has 38 per cent women, just 32 per cent are engineers, and over 84 per cent have experience of more than two years. ESADE (Barcelona, Spain) has 48 nationalities represented in its class of 180 students with an average work experience of seven years.
Hence, we not only have an oversupply of MBAs already, but have MBAs whose academic and experience profile actually makes them another “brick in the wall”. There are no easy solutions except that MBA colleges have to reinvent themselves and their programmes immediately before they add more capacity, and all new aspirants for an MBA programme should keep in mind that an MBA degree from even a high-ranking institute may not translate into a dream job in the near future!
When the undergrad system in a country forces 90% of the best students to opt for engineering (leave apart the medicos !!), with hardly a few good students left in art, science and commerce streams, isn't it okay when the best institutes of the likes of IIMs A, B and C have more than 90% of their students as engineers. Or would you rather opt for a B school which has 33% each of engineers, arts and commerce grads just for the sake of the ultra hyped word "DIVERSITY" while sacrificing talent and intellect.
As regards, lack of work experience, that is indeed a concern. I agree with that.
While the observations made may all be true and all the data presented makes sense; it would be pertinent here to understand that in the context of the Indian System at least neither one's educational qualification nor work experience is a very good proxy to gauge the managerial potential one holds. So while I agree with what has been said, I would just like to point out that the probable reason Indian MBA's have been getting good jobs (well the one's that did get placed) is more to do with what potential they hold rather than what they have or have not done in the past.
And everything said and done I don't think that's a very bad criterion for any recruiter assuming you have the kind of infrastructure which help capable individuals grow into roles! This should be taken into consideration before we straight away start comparing and straight jacketing the exact credentials that any MBA aspirant should have!!
analysing the profile of MBA student's background does not matter....As long as MBAs get good salaries, it will attract all sorts of students....MBA institutes are simply launch pads to be used for getting campus placements because finding a job in open market is often tough....how many MBAs stick to their campus placements for more than a year or two...???
I am a student of one of the top three IIMs and seriously consider the excess of engineering students in the institutes as a significant drawback...But at the same time we need to consider the harsh reality of undergraduate education in India...Most of the non engineering undergraduate colleges except for the elite ones are grossly inadequate of providing the basic education...At the same time oppurtunities in humanitiesa and other similar background are either sorely lacking or insignificant for a student to take a plunge even if interested...IF usee in the top engineering colleges in India u will find scores of students genuinely interseted in social sciences, humanities etc but pursuing engineering for teh additional career security it offers...until this imbalance is sorted out at the undergraduate level we cannot hope to see the batch profile of a top notch business school resembling that of its ivy cousins abroad...
Of 1,400 institutes offering MBA program, it would be interesting to determine the % of the institutes with requisite faculty? Reality is that the quality of MBA graduates is so pathetic that one can get a MBA graduate from one of the MBA institutes for about Rs. 5,000.00/Rs 6,000.00 a month to work.
Content Guide
