Business Standard
Thursday, Feb 16, 2012
Sponsored by  
drived banner
drived banner
  Advanced Search
RSS
Content Guide
Follow us on  
|||||Opinion|||| 
 Section Home | Editorials | Compass | BS People | Columnists | Lunch with BS
Home > Opinion & Analysis Live Markets | Commodities
 
From trade pooper to heroic leader
/ Business Standard September 23,2003

From trade pooper to heroic leader
Raisina Hill
A K Bhattacharya / New Delhi Sep 23, 2003, 00:00 IST

Murasoli Maran and Prabir Sengupta have worked together on two controversial issues. In 1997, Maran was the industry minister in the United Front government at the Centre. Sengupta was secretary in the department of heavy industries.

 Click here for Cloud Computing
 
A problem arose over who should control the management of Maruti Udyog Limited, a joint venture of the Indian government and Suzuki Motor Company of Japan. Maran felt that Suzuki should not dispute the Indian government’s control over the company’s management. Sengupta was his key official as he was also the government-nominated chairman of the board of Maruti Udyog.

It did appear that in his fight with the Japanese automobile giant, he was banking less on the principles of the agreement between the two parties and more on nationalistic fervour. Suzuki also did not want to give up the fight easily even though it knew that it was taking on the Government of India.

The dispute was even referred to the International Council of Arbitration. It would have been a long-drawn affair. But the United Front government fell before its normal tenure and the BJP-led coalition that came to power after the general elections had a different perspective on this issue. It was less jingoistic and a new industry minister, Sikandar Bakht, presided over the resolution of the dispute. The rest is history.

Maran and Sengupta met again in 2000. This time, Maran was the industries and commerce minister (the two ministries had been merged into one entity by then) and Sengupta was commerce secretary. Once again, the duo combined well to put up a brave fight at the fourth ministerial meeting of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) at Doha in 2001.

At Doha, Maran and Sengupta were all alone in their fight against the developed world. They were opposed to the inclusion of the Singapore issues (investment, competition, transparency in government procurement and trade facilitation) in the negotiations for the new round of trade talks. Maran’s argument was that before starting negotiations on new issues, the developed world must focus on the implementation of the unfinished agenda of the Uruguay Round.

Nobody could find fault with his argument, but few gave him a chance to succeed in this battle. Maran was hopeful of many developing countries backing him up at the meeting. But everybody told him that these developing countries would be won over one by one by the US and the European Union (EU), leaving him alone carrying the cross — and paying the price for defiance.

Such fears came true. Many developing countries that promised support to Maran in the early stages of the talks gave in to pressure from the US and the EU. Maran was left alone and knew that he was fighting a losing battle. But he did not give in so easily. He agreed to the new agenda for including the Singapore issues for the new Doha round, but only after an “explicit consensus” was obtained from all member countries.

That “victory” of his at Doha went virtually unnoticed. Maran’s performance at Doha was known more for the manner in which he “wrecked” the developed world’s agenda for free trade.

It is, therefore, ironic that the man who was accused of having spoilt the party at Doha is now being hailed as the developing countries’ saviour at Cancun. And the recognition comes from none other than Commerce Minister Arun Jaitley, who led the Indian delegation at the recently concluded fifth ministerial meeting of the WTO at Cancun.

Indeed, if Maran had not forced the inclusion of the condition of an “explicit consensus” for starting the negotiations on Singapore issues, life at Cancun for developing countries could have been more difficult.

All this marks a change in the way our policy makers have begun perceiving the role India should play in the global community. Maran’s stand on the Maruti Udyog issue may have had few takers then. But the belated endorsement of his line at Doha by his successor shows that the government has recognised India’s growing strength at such international forums.

Maran anticipated this change and made the first move. Jaitley has built on this initiative. He has built a strong alliance of developing countries, which has stayed intact so far. He has also got the Indian industry’s support. Both before and during the Cancun meeting, the government took industry into confidence while evolving its approach. Not surprisingly, industry associations have now held meetings to support the government’s stand at Cancun.

Jaitley has tried even to get the non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and media on the government’s side. He himself took the unusual step of addressing an NGO meeting at Cancun. The Indian official delegation shared information with the Indian media without any reservations.

In fact, media briefings for Indian journalists at Cancun were often held in Hindi so that journalists representing news organisations from the US and EU were unable to understand what was really going on inside the developing countries’ camp.

According to a member of the Indian delegation at Cancun, Indian journalists present there made no secret of their enthusiasm over the Indian government’s tough stand. “Their enthusiasm was reminiscent of the reaction of the Indian journalists covering the Kargil war,” a member said.

Cancun was no Kargil. But Maran and Jaitley have ensured that Cancun marked a new phase in the way the government engages the people, the press and industry while fighting for its due in global trade battles.

New Ipad Application :Business Standard's all new IPad App
Click here to download for free
Arrow Other Stories     
- Markets end lower on profit booking
- Par Panel to discuss DTC, may suggest hiking IT exemption limit
- Govt hopes to achieve road projects target for FY12
- India, China and Brazil ahead of US in R&D rate of growth
- Social media has made us a different generation: Anand Pillai
  Read Business news in 
- Now property search gets more exciting than ever before!
- IndianOil Citibank Card at Zero annual card fee
- We live for our family. have you secured them?
- Earn fuel worth Rs.2400 with Citi
- India's No. 1 Property Site. Click here to know more..
- Diseases earlier, Saving Costs, Extending Lives. Know More..
- Win a Business Class Ticket to Europe..Know more..
- Enjoy the journey as much as the destination. click to know more..
- Exim Bank Conclave on India - Africa Project Partnership. Know more..
- Medium-sized businesses are the engines of a smarter planet.
- Be part of it The World's Largest Aircraft.
- Creating Wealth made simple the SIP way. Know more..
- Only Developer to give a guarantee on time space & rate.
- Office 365 for professionals and small businesses.
- Buy Your Property with Our Triple Guarantee in India.
- Improve Patient Care & Experience. Click here to know more
-  Introduce a New Automotive Luxury Car.. know more
- Health is Wealth..... Insurance + Savings... Know More...
Sorry, comments to this story are closed
Latest Messages
SmartInvestor+ E-zine
  Pay Rs.747/- for 3 years and
  get a branded watch FREE

  Subscribe Now
Most Popular
Read
E-Mailed
Commented
   
- Leela parts ways with Kempinski
- Kanika Datta: The importance of being SRK
- Nestle: Food for thought
- Tailor-made but not good enough
- Tata Motors soars to record level as JLR propels profit
 
 More  
BUSINESS STANDARD INDIA 2012
  Now available at Special price
  Rs.395/- Only
  Buy Now
  Now available on the Kindle Store...
  BS Specials  
    Full coverage of elections in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Uttarakhand, Manipur and Goa
  Hot Searches  
 
IRFC bond |  Antrix-Devas |  Rafale fighter |  Junglee |  IPL 5 |  Dhanlaxmi Bank |  Thomas Cook |  TCS |  Sarfaesi Act |  Vodafone |  Aakash tablet |  Sodexo |  Rupee |  Samsung Galaxy Note |  Kingfisher Airlines |  Silver |  Provident Fund |  income tax refund |  Anna Hazare |  iPhone |  Reliance Industries |  SEBI |  BSNL |  BSE |  NSE |  Mukesh Ambani |  Anil Ambani |  Infosys |  Pranab Mukherjee |  Sonia Gandhi |  Rahul Gandhi |  New Pension Scheme |  Reliance |  RBI |  GDP |  Gold |  Ratan Tata |  ICICI |  B-School |  Sensex |  Tax calculator |  Home Loan |  Personal Finance |  inflation |  oil prices |  Barack Obama |   
 
  Member Area Write to the Editor RSS Archives Advanced Search
  Subscribe to BS print product BS e-paper Newsletter Portfolio Tracker
  BS Products BS Hindi BS Motoring BS Books
FOR HOT PRODUCTS
BS Bazaar.com
Home | Markets & Investing | Companies & Industry | Banking & Finance | Economy & Policy | Opinion
Life & Leisure | Management & Marketing | Tech World
About Us | Partner With Us | Code of Conduct | Careers | Advertise with us| Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Contact Us