Business Standard
Saturday, Nov 21, 2009
 
drived banner
drived banner
  Advanced Search
Feedback | RSS
Content Guide
Follow us on  
||||||||Tech World| 
 Section Home | News Now | Features & Analysis | IT/ITES | Telecom | Hardware | Columnists | Gadgets & Gizmos
Home > ICE World Live Markets | Smart Portfolios II
  Search:

It's Apple vs Nokia
Priyanka Joshi / Mumbai June 29, 2009, 0:16 IST

The Nokia N97, the Finnish company’s much-hyped crown jewel, has finally made its way into Indian stores.

 
 
Related Stories
News Now
-A must-have upgrade

Since the timing of Nokia N97’s launch in India has coincided with the launch of Apple iPhone 3GS and the fact that there's a software upgrade available for the older iPhone 3G (and iPod Touch), it is inevitable that we end up comparing both (we don’t have the iPhone 3GS in India yet). The Nokia N97 is also the first device to ship with the Ovi Store, best described as an online appstore for applications such as games, videos, podcasts, productivity tools, web and location-based services. Similar to Apple’s AppStore, Ovi Store, too, has paid for free content from content providers and developers that offer applications for Facebook, Hi5, Twitter, city maps and documents.

Hardware
The N97 is powered by a 434 MHz processor and 128MB RAM compared to the rumoured 600 MHz processor and 256MB RAM on the iPhone 3GS. If this configuration of the iPhone 3GS stands confirmed, then it clearly sets the N97 a step back. Add to that, the Symbian, the new S60 (5th edition) operating system on N97, looks achingly old-fashioned and sluggish when compared with the older iPhone 3G.Too bad that Nokia decided to go with the resistive touch screen instead of the capacitive one on the iPhone that makes its touch operation unmatched. Though the N97 has some touch gestures and the accelerometer, we have to admit that touch features on the iPhone remain iconic despite all efforts by Nokia and Windows Mobile.

Noticeably, the huge 1,500 mAh Li-Ion battery gives the N97 an advantage over iPhone 3G. Also the built-in 32GB internal memory and the microSD card slot are big positives when compared with iPhone 3G, which has 16GB internal memory.

Design
A slide-out 3.5 inch touch display along with a Qwerty keyboard and a fully customisable home screen makes the Nokia N97 look really elegant. The slide-out keyboard on the phone begins to feel very useful after you have written some emails and text messages on it. It’s not perfect, but it gets your work done faster.

But for average users, Nokia N97 is better positioned as a touch screen N-series device that happens to have a D-pad for gaming and a miniature Qwerty keyboard for ad hoc use .

Multimedia & Other Features
We liked the active home screen on the Nokia N97 as well as the phone’s ability to organise the widgets on it. Not to forget, Nokia widgets are really amazing, making the home screen the most usable page.

The N97 obviously takes a lead with its 5 megapixel camera whereas iPhone 3G sports only a 2 megapixel lens. The two stereo speakers, located along the left edge of N97, are the best set of speakers we have heard on a phone. They clearly put iPhone speakers to shame. Bundled features such as handwriting recognition, Bluetooth file transfers, FM radio and video recording on the N97 clearly put the message out loud and clear — it’s a great multimedia device.

Though scrolling through webpages isn’t as smooth and fluid on the N97 as on the iPhone (which has the Safari browser), yet the pages render quickly.

And...
The Nokia N97 is expected to retail for around Rs 36,119 in India (official prices not yet announced) while the iPhone 3G is sold for about Rs 29,000 (the 8GB model)

PROs

  • Battery life of up to 7 hours  
  • Hi-end camera and video features  
  • Fantastic home screen widgets and variety of apps from Ovi Store

    CONs

  • QWERTY keypad; navigational buttons need time to get used to  
  • The multi-touch feature seems sluggish  
  • Relatively lower RAM causes slowing down while running with multiple applications   

     

  • Arrow Other Stories     
    - Sensex makes remarkable recovery, regains 17K
    - Bharati to go by Sebi norms on Great Offshore offer
    - Galleon exits Edelweiss; sells 7% stake for Rs 255.54 cr
    - Suzlon Energy's three promoters pledge 2.8 cr shares
    - Draw export strategy of $300 bn: Assocham to govt
    More  
      Read Business news in 
      Get financial advisory and solutions for your projects
      Holidays starting at a delightful EMI of Rs 3481
      Switch on and say hello to Monday morning !
      Your dream home can now be a reality.
      Visit Fortis for a preventive health check-up & get a 20% discount.
      Follow the ups and downs of your investments. Try our new Portfolio Tracker
      Kolkata Dock \ Freight contract for the British Gurkhas Nepal
      Find how Midsize Businesses use ERP to gain competitive advantage
      Trading in Forex is now as easy as 1-2-3
      Discover an economical and cost effective way to market your products and services
      Giftwithlove.com: Same day delivery of Flowers and Cakes to India
      Download the E-book on the Future of Business Intelligence
      Learn Best Practices for improving customer satisfaction
      Know your customers better... download the free e-book on CRM
       Discussion Board / User Comments    
    Display Name  Email-Id  
    Post your comment
    Ramnath
    Apple I phone is beautiful but walled garden, u cannot access any thing outside that and cant access any thing inside with out paying for it..
    Reply
    ak
    Informative article, thanks.
    Reply
    SAN
    Priyanka... This does seem a pointless comparison...iPhone ought to hv been compared with a HTC Touch HD or similar...
    Reply
      Reply by priyanka:
    why it OUGHT to be compared with HTC Touch (a slightly older release) we have just compared the most touted touchscreen devices. HTC, in past, we have compared with iphone (sometime last year). Please check our archives
    VJ
    any day i would prefer Iphone. I have seen the home screen of N97 and does not look great as it has a scroll bar on the side... not very professional. the touch screen is ok but not as good as an Iphone.. which uses a totally different techonology... of electomastatics and n97 user pressure sensors. games like termimnaor and assasins creed make the iphone worth buying and many more to come...
    Reply
    kumar
    The point being Ravi, Nokia does not have an answer to Apple iTunes store. Hundreds of thousands of applications with 1Bn+ downloads!!!! It's hard to match up. All in all, go iPhone :)
    Reply
    muk
    You still havent compared the fact that iphone comes with a heavy contract. A contract that will completely offset the initial expenditure and pressure us more on the long run when nokia will surely turn out to be the cheaper option.
    Reply
    Srinath
    This is one of the most sluggish reviews i have ever seen ... QWERTY keypad is listed in cons, I am not sure if they know what Qwerty key pad means. QWERTY keypad is considered as one feature which is unique and N97 stands ahead of Iphone.. for its Qwerty keypad. I would appreciate if you can read few reviews from the net and then post the same on your website.
    Reply
    ravi
    I wish magazines could find someone who better understands the gadget spec sheets than just compare numbers. I hope they have some knowledge about ram usage and that symbian os stands 40% efficient than the apples one. Also that megapixels doesnt matter unless you are going to take a wall size printout and stare it at a cm distance. What matters is how the device handles autofocus, its shutterspeed and does it has a better flash. So please stop publishing amateurish reviews
    Reply
      Reply by Dev:
    no one is comparing specs here ravi. this is a review for average consumer to see how the Nokia N97 matches up to iphone 3G. autofocus and shutter speed (by the way) are not what average cosnumer asks at shops. he asks if the picture will look good! stop being a cynic
      Reply by aditya:
    both the phones are very costly in comparision of others likr htc.
    Most Popular
    Read
    E-Mailed
    Commented
       
    - Bharti Airtel slashes roaming rates by 60%
    - Govt may allow private sector investment in education
    - Suzlon Energy's three promoters pledge 2.8 cr shares
    - Patni may host all IT services on 'cloud'
    - We are not trying for a monopoly: HAL chairman
     
     More  
    BS Poll
    Cast Your Vote
     
       
     
    Should rich charitable trusts be brought under the tax net?
      Yes  No
    Submit

      Hot Searches  
     
    Amitabh Bachchan | N Chandrasekaran | Swine Flu | Mukesh Ambani | Anil Ambani | TCS | Infosys |  Air India |  Duronto |  Pranab Mukherjee | Sonia Gandhi | Congress | Rahul Gandhi |  Bigg Boss |  New Pension Scheme |  Service tax |  Excise duty |  Sebi | Tech Mahindra |  Ramalinga Raju |  Satyam |  Reliance  |  RBI |  GDP |  Gold |  Ratan Tata |  ICICI |  |  B-School | DLF  Sensex |  Tax calculator | Home Loan  | Bollywood | Personal Finance |  inflation | oil prices |  World Bank | Reliance Infratel |  HDFC |  Barack Obama  
     
      Member Area Write to the Editor RSS Archives Advanced Search
      Subscribe to BS print product BS e-paper Newsletter Portfolio Tracker
      BS Products BS Hindi BS Motoring
    FOR HOT PRODUCTS
    BS Bazaar.com
    Home | Markets & Investing | Companies & Industry | Banking & Finance | Economy & Policy | Opinion
    Life & Leisure | Management & Marketing | Tech World
    About Us | Partner With Us | Code of Conduct | Careers | Advertise with us| Terms & Conditions | Disclaimer | Site Map | Contact Us | Feedback