Parl panel moots wider slabs for personal income tax
Suggests far more generous provisions than proposed in Direct Taxes Code
Gyan Varma / New Delhi Feb 10, 2012, 00:27 IST
A parliamentary panel is set to recommend sweeping changes in personal income tax slabs proposed in the Direct Taxes Code (DTC) Bill. A draft report prepared by Parliament’s standing committee on finance suggests increasing the income tax exemption limit to Rs 3 lakh a year against Rs 2 lakh proposed in the Bill.
The committee, chaired by Bharatiya Janata Party leader and former Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha, wants a 10 per cent rate to kick in for annual income of Rs 3-10 lakh, according to those in the know. The Bill proposes this rate to be imposed in a slab of Rs 2-5 lakh. The draft report also recommends 20 per cent income tax rate be paid by those earning income of Rs 10-20 lakh a year. This slab was proposed to be Rs 5-8 lakh in the Bill.
Finally, the report wants the government to impose a peak rate of 30 per cent on annual income above Rs 20 lakh, as against above Rs 10 lakh as sought in the Bill. The report is not final and minor tweaking of these suggestions could be incorporated after a meeting tomorrow, according to the persons cited earlier. Tax slabs needed to be progressive, they said, adding, “Most of the assesses would fall in the category of Rs 3-10 lakh a year, which should get a lower income tax rate of 10 per cent.”
The finance ministry expects the standing committee to give its report in the Budget session of Parliament, so that DTC could be introduced from April 1, 2013.
The committee will finalise the report tomorrow and give it to the government. “It is up to the government to table the report in the Budget session or not,” they said.
In fact, the suggestions in the draft report of the committee are much closer to the original discussion paper put out by the finance ministry on DTC.
That paper had suggested a 10 per cent tax rate for Rs 1.6-10 lakh a year, 20 per cent for Rs 10-25 lakh and 30 per cent for income above Rs 25 lakh a year.
But, the paper had also proposed to do away with a host of exemptions. After certain quarters protested, the ministry proposed in the Bill to give some of those exemptions but also narrowed the income tax slabs.
Currently, income of Rs 1.80-5 lakh attracts 10 per cent income tax, Rs 5-8 lakh 20 per cent and above Rs 8 lakh 30 per cent.
The standing committee’s draft report wants the government to cautiously implement the General Anti-Avoidance Rules. These provisions, contained in the Bill, are aimed at authorising the tax department to demand tax in situations where the main motive of a transaction is to have a tax advantage.
These provisions have assumed importance after the government lost the Vodafone case in the Supreme Court. Many believe the Budget may incorporate the proposal, even before the introduction of DTC.
We must give relief to lower-income earners and reduce the work of the IT department by not taxing the huge number of people earning upto 3L. However for heavens sake dont create black money and criminals out of tax payers by going back to the old regime of higher tax rates for higher-income earners. 30% tax for nothing is a huge amount considering that most goes into politicians and bureaucrats pockets.
Well, DTC was the best opportunity to make structural changes to the personal income tax and design a transparent mechanism to link tax slabs to the inflation (like the USA tax code)
Instead our political class (UPA as well as NDA) continue to unnecessarily hold on to discretionary powers so that they can tinker with IT rates/slabs as an election year dole to middle class.
Apropos of the statement that a draft report prepared by Parliament's standing committee on finance suggests increasing the income tax exemption limit to Rs 3 lakh a year against Rs 2 lakh proposed in the Bill, it may be recalled that the exemption limit was Rs.3k, fifty years ago.
Posted by: Anon
February 13 , 2012, 12:45 IST
and 50 years ago you were in diapers,so stop comparing what was there 50 years ago. I hate this type of reasoning. Everything should mirror reality not past or future. Currently Indians have one of the lowest standard of living (working lower middle class, won't even mention the poor) and on top of that tax slabs are too low.
Content Guide
A parliamentary panel is set to recommend sweeping changes in personal income tax slabs proposed in the Direct Taxes Code (DTC) Bill. A draft report prepared by Parliament’s standing committee on finance suggests increasing the income tax exemption limit to Rs 3 lakh a year against Rs 2 lakh proposed in the Bill.
