Tax audit report may be made mandatory for e-filing of returns
Anindita Dey / Mumbai Jun 12, 2009, 00:59 IST
The government is considering a proposal to make tax audit reports mandatory for e-filing of income tax returns.
This follows a recommendation by the Income Tax (I-T) department after the Satyam accounting fraud issue broke in January following founder Ramalinga Raju's confession. I-T officials said since the returns were e-filed, there was no provision to check whether or not the tax audit reports were certified by the chartered accountant.
Current norms require all companies to conduct audits under section 44 AB, which is otherwise known as “tax audit”. The section covers almost all listed or unlisted companies whose total sales or turnover exceeded Rs 40 lakh. In the case of individuals, gross professional receipts should be over Rs 10 lakh.
These companies are mandatorily required to file their returns electronically. While a tax audit report is certified by a chartered accountant, there is no provision for this in an e-filing system. Therefore, it is difficult to ascertain whether the tax audit has been done properly.
The actual audit report can only be accessed if the case goes for a scrutiny assessment, said officials. Therefore, a mandatory directive is required under which the chartered account would have to certify the audit and send a copy of the report to the income tax department under the permanent account number (PAN) of the client. This will help the department see the audit report along with the returns.
Officials explained that these measures might not rule out fraud but could at least throw up some indicators about the company.
I-T departments across India have also made a recommendation for rolling back the time bar for assessment of cases to March from December. Before 2007, the time limit for assessment of cases was March 31, 2009, which coincided with the closure of the financial year and transfers of personnel.
However, in 2007, the time limit was reduced to December 31 so that officers could also be involved in the recovery of taxes following the assessment. This deadline, however, left very little time for proper scrutiny and investigation of cases, said officials.
think online return will be one step of transperacy in the bussiness houses.To prevent satyam type fraud, we should give authority to Cost Accountant for conducting Tax Audit & also Financial Audit like our neighbouring countries i.e. Bangladesh,Pakistan,Sri Lanka & in Canada. Regards manjunatha.T.R B.COM,ICWA
I think online return will be one step of transperacy in the bussiness houses.To prevent satyam type fraud, we should give authority to Cost Accountant for conducting Tax Audit & also Financial Audit like our neighbouring countries i.e. Bangladesh,Pakistan,Sri Lanka & in Canada.
Regards
CMA Rajiv Kumar Pandey
LLB.AICWAI.CMA(USA)
I think IT Department make it mandatory to attach Tax Audit Report with E filing document, because earlier practise may call for fraud in terms of simply giving the auditor name and his PAN No in the e filing without knowing concern chartered accountant. Otherwise E filing provision itself gets change to incorporate scanned attachments to verify the authenticity of the tax audit done by Chartered Accountant. Then only it will prevent ITP peoples fraud intention.
The limit of Rs.40 lakhs (Revenue) and Rs.10 lakhs (Receipts) for mandatory tax audit was fixed decades back. Since then one can imagine the increase in cost of living index. Therefore, it is desirable that this limit be increased keeping in view the inflationary index. Secondly, it is not in public interest to monopolise the conduct of tax audit under CA. It shall also be open to another statutory premier accounting institute, ICWAI established under Cost & Works Accountants Act,1959 by Parliament. This will offer public wider choice for availing of tax audit services.
At present Public has not any choice for selection of accountants. Tax audit u/s 44AB should be open for Cost Accountants (member of ICWAI) immediately. the scope of Tax Audit limit for should be increased to 5 crs for corporate and others. In case of Individual assessee, this limit should be fixed 60 Lacs.
Content Guide
