[RETAIL TROUBLE]

C O N T E N T S

EDITORIAL

Down but not out
The poor offtake of retail loans has pulled down credit growth

Red alert
After a sharp reduction in the last three years, NPAs are creeping back into banks’ balance sheets

A vote for the future
A distinguished Jury picks State Bank of India Chairman O P Bhatt as the Business Standard Banker of the year

Making the elephant dance
Interview with SBI Chairman O P Bhatt on his efforts at re-energising the bank

Round Table
Seven top bankers discuss “2009: Are banks in India ready for it?”

Overcoming obstacles
RBI has softened its stand on co-operative banks, but the guidelines are still strict

Database
All the data you wanted on banks

Banking Annual (HOME)

Banking Annual 2006
Banking Annual 2005
HOME

 

[Page 2]

Other changes are also happening. Till a couple of months back, 25-year old Sanjeev (name changed), working at the call-centre of a Mumbai-based recovery agency, used to argue with a borrower when he was told that the payment would be made when he has the necessary liquidity. Now, he has to quietly end this conversation. Then, visiting consumers after a deadline of seven in the evening was a common occurrence earlier. Now, it is a strict no-no.

ADITYA PURI

The banks are moving towards a more organised format with guidelines like an official intimation through a letter, informing defaulters that they have a month’s time to clear dues. Says Aditya Puri, managing director and chief executive officer, HDFC Bank, “We have, in consultation with the Banking Codes and Standards Board of India (BCSBI), decided to send a letter to a defaulter giving him/her enough time to clear the dues. If the customer reverts to us, we would give the individual necessary credit counselling. However, if the customer does not show up within the specified time frame, we would hand over the case to the recovery agent as informed to the customer.”

Of course, this stifling of recovery methods has resulted in lower recoveries of bad loans. The collection data for the last two months has shown a marked 10-15 per cent dip.

“We have decided to send a letter to the defaulter giving them enough time to clear the dues”

ADITYA PURI
MD, HDFC BANK

“The attention on recovery has acted as a dampener for normal on-field recovery efforts. If earlier the efficiency in recovery was 95 per cent, in the last few months it is at 88-90 per cent,” says the retail head of a private sector bank.

There are also a lot reluctant bank officials and recovery agents who were earlier sent to repossess cars or two-wheelers on default. “Sixty days before repossessing a vehicle, banks do send an intimation letter to the local police station informing them about the default case details and the time when the bank will repossess the vehicle. However, the police have so many other things to do that these intimation letters are usually thrown in the dustbin,” says Manish Desai, senior partner, Paras Kuhad & Associates, a law firm.

Also, with borrowers filing police complaints against the bank officials and recovery agents alleging use of abusive methods for repossessing vehicles, banks are wary. “The entire process of repossession of vehicle has become difficult and tedious after the recent incidents of abuse by recovery agents. But we have not stopped the process. If we stop, we will have to shut the business,” says a senior HDFC Bank official.

Many banks have been forced to review their loan policies to pre-empt further escalation of the problem. The first measure they are taking is exiting the subprime business where borrowers belong to economically weaker sections with a monthly income of around Rs 5,000 and pay interest rate as high as 45-50 per cent on loans ranging up to Rs 50,000. At present, banks and non-bank finance companies (NBFCs) have an exposure of almost Rs 45,000 crore in the subprime market. Leading private sector banks such as ICICI Bank and HDFC Bank have already exited this business while Citigroup has tightened its lending procedures. The bank has made face-to-face interactions with customers mandatory.

SECTORAL DEPLOYMENT OF GROSS BANK CREDIT
(Amount in Rs crore)
Sector
Outstanding as on
Variation
March 18,
2005
March 31,
2006
March 30,
2007
2005-06
2006-07
Personal Loans
2,56,348
3,60,081
4,55,503
1,03,733
95,422
Consumer Durables
8,976
7,101
9,151
-1,875
2,050
Housing
1,33,908
1,85,181
2,30,689
51,273
45,508
Advances against Fixed Deposits
(including FCNR (B), NRNR Deposits, etc.)
29,774
34,283
40,455
4,509
6,172
Advances to individuals
against share, bonds, etc.
4,101
5,226
4,511
1,125
-715
Credit Card Outstandings
6,432
9,086
13,316
2,654
4,230
Education
5,680
9,962
15,020
4,282
5,058
Other Personal Loans
67,477
1,09,242
1,42,361
41,765
33,119

More data with organisations like the Cibil (Credit information bureau of India) will be a great help for the banks in identifying tainted customers. The available data already reflects that in the last couple of years there have been indications of overleveraging of borrowers, especially in the small ticket sized loans. This could mean some more pain for banks.

Previous page

Business Standard December 2007