The company’s Q2 gross merchandise value (GMV) and net sales value (NSV) grew 30 per cent and 31 per cent, respectively, beating estimates. This was the third consecutive quarter in which consolidated NSV growth was 30 per cent or higher.
Within segments, GMV in BPC grew 25 per cent, while NSV growth came in at 28 per cent. This was driven by a 30 per cent increase in monthly average unique visitors to 54.1 million and a 26.3 per cent rise in annual unique transacting customers to 22.1 million. Average order value rose 4.9 per cent, driven by premiumisation. The segment’s operating profit margin came in at 10.5 per cent, ahead of expectations.
The fashion vertical’s NSV grew 47 per cent year-on-year (Y-o-Y), but the growth was lower than brokerage estimates. The vertical reported a contribution margin of 11.3 per cent, while its operating profit margin stood at 0.2 per cent. Both metrics were below Street estimates.
Given the shift in festival timing, analysts led by Manish Adukia of Goldman Sachs Research expect NSV growth to accelerate in the third quarter (October-December/Q3). Management comments also point to multiple growth drivers across both beauty and fashion, with no material demand headwinds in the near term. The brokerage has a ‘neutral’ rating on the stock with a target price of ₹300. According to the analysts, Nykaa trades at twice the valuation of its peer group. They believe sustained robust growth and a directional improvement in margins should help the company sustain its premium multiples, though the scope for positive earnings surprises is limited.
The physical retail business posted growth in the early 20s, with like-for-like growth at its highest level in six quarters. NSV for House of Nykaa (own brands) rose 39 per cent Y-o-Y, while the company’s 82 per cent stake in Simply Nam has extended its makeup range into the ₹1,250-2,000 price band.
Motilal Oswal Research believes Nykaa should continue to deliver healthy growth in beauty, supported by premiumisation, customer additions and festive demand, while fashion is showing improving growth and sustained breakeven. Given the largely in-line performance this quarter, the brokerage has kept its estimates unchanged. It has retained its ‘neutral’ rating on the stock with a target price of ₹370. However, valuations remain a key deterrent, and brokerages are awaiting a better risk-reward profile before turning constructive.
On the profitability front, gross margin rose 106 basis points (bps) Y-o-Y to 46 per cent, driven by a higher contribution from House of Nykaa and marketing income. Marketing costs fell 48 bps to 15.2 per cent of revenue, while employee and other costs declined 86 bps to 11.9 per cent. This offset a 44 bps rise in fulfilment costs to 10.1 per cent, owing to investments in faster deliveries.
Elara Securities has retained its ‘buy’ rating with an unchanged target price of ₹475, as the company continues to ride the premiumisation trend and growth in online BPC penetration. Nykaa Now is performing above expectations, limiting the risk of a loss in BPC market share to quick commerce players. Adjusting for fashion, core BPC trades at 68x its 2028-29 earnings. Analysts led by Karan Taurani believe the premium valuation will persist as long as the company maintains execution and growth. While estimates remain unchanged, slower BPC growth and lower-than-expected margin gains are key risks. According to Bloomberg, 15 of the 25 analysts polled post Q2 results are bullish on Nykaa, while five each are either bearish or neutral. Their average one-year target price is ₹368.32. The stock, which has gained over 11 per cent in the past fortnight, slipped 1.44 per cent on Thursday to close at ₹350 on the BSE.