BS EDIT: Retro tax on miners a regressive step

By Business Standard Editorial CommentPublished On Aug 19, 2024

Taxing miners retrospectively

The Supreme Court ruling allows states to tax mineral rights retroactively from April 1, 2005, imposing a heavy financial burden on mining companies

Massive financial impact

Mining companies, both private and public, could face liabilities of Rs 1-2 trillion. Public-sector miners alone might incur costs of Rs 70,000 crore

Partial relief offered

The court’s ruling includes provisions like no interest or penalties and allows staggered payments over 12 years, providing some relief to the affected parties

Contentious history of retro tax

Retrospective taxation has stifled foreign investment in the past. The infamous 2012 Vodafone case led to significant backlash, eventually resulting in the law being scrapped

States to benefit from the ruling

Mineral-rich states like Jharkhand, Odisha, Rajasthan, and Chhattisgarh stand to gain from this ruling, with Jharkhand already passing a Bill to impose a cess on minerals

Potential economic fallout

The cascading effects could include higher electricity prices due to increased costs of coal. States must exercise discretion to mitigate the inflationary impact of this ruling