BS EDIT: Election Commission has not addressed key weaknesses in SIR

By Business StandardPublished On Sep 30, 2026

Unanswered concerns

Recent revelations have raised questions about the Election Commission’s handling of the Special Intensive Revision

Its responses have not fully addressed concerns raised internally by commissioners

Changes announced

The ECI has announced measures including meeting agendas and minutes, tighter IT scrutiny, approval for officers’ foreign trips and a review of the ECINet platform

The Form 6 issue

The online Form 6 requires new voters to map themselves to a parent or family member on the electoral roll. This creates difficulties for applicants without such records

Legal questions

Legal experts have questioned the ECI’s claim that the Supreme Court approved the parent-mapping requirement

The editorial notes that there is no specific adjudication on this point

West Bengal concerns

In West Bengal, a large number of voters were excluded from the roll and appeals were filed

Dissenting commissioners questioned whether they were adequately informed about these appeals

Restoring public trust

Administrative changes alone may not resolve deeper concerns about the ECI’s functioning

Greater transparency, veracity and impartiality remain essential to public confidence in the electoral process