BS EDIT: SC stands firm: Bulldozer justice violates the Constitution

By Business StandardPublished On Apr 4, 2025

The court’s rebuke

The Supreme Court ruled the 2021 Prayagraj demolitions “inhumane and illegal,” awarding Rs 10 lakh each to six affected citizens

It reaffirmed that state action must respect constitutional rights

Right to shelter, not just a roof

Invoking Article 21, the court recognised shelter as a fundamental right—beyond bricks and mortar, it guarantees privacy, safety, and dignity

Evictions without due process breach this right

What went wrong in Prayagraj

Authorities issued a notice in December 2020, but demolished homes months later—without ensuring recipients had a fair chance to respond

The court called this “a shocking disregard” of law

Building on the November 2024 order

The April ruling strengthens the earlier directive: No demolitions without 15-day notice, proof of communication, a fair hearing, and videographic documentation of the process

Holding officials accountable

The apex court invoked Article 142 to impose penalties and fix personal liability on errant public officials—including the threat of contempt and prosecution for violations

The road ahead

The Supreme Court’s warnings may check misuse of power. But true justice depends on lower courts ensuring citizens’ rights are upheld—before bulldozers roll in