BS EDIT: The wrong cure

By Business StandardPublished On Sep 7, 2026

G20’S TRADE DILEMMA

The G20 agrees that large global imbalances threaten stability. Yet consensus remains elusive, with China rejecting concerns over its persistent trade surpluses and economic model

CHINA’S CLOSED ECONOMY

China’s restricted markets, investment-heavy growth model and targeted subsidies have contributed to persistent imbalances

Reforming domestic demand is essential to restoring balance

THE US HAS A CREDIBILITY PROBLEM

Washington’s case is weakened by its reliance on unilateral tariffs. Targeting trade deficits directly treats the symptom, not the underlying causes of global imbalances

TARIFFS ARE NOT THE CURE

Trade deficits reflect deeper differences in savings, investment and consumption

Tariffs cannot correct these structural factors, particularly when imposed unilaterally and without a broader strategy

THE CASE FOR COOPERATION

China’s trading partners need a coordinated approach to encourage greater domestic consumption and market access

Addressing imbalances requires reform, not a cycle of tariff retaliation

INDIA’S DELICATE POSITION

India faces risks from both China’s closed, state-driven economy and rising US tariff barriers

The G20 must address both through cooperation, rather than allowing economic nationalism to deepen