Will send 44 judges' names within two-three days: Govt to Supreme Court

The Centre on Friday told the Supreme Court that the government would adhere to the timeline for processing names recommended by the Collegium for appointment as judges in constitutional courts and 44 names are likely to be processed within two-three days.

Attorney General R Venkataramani told the top court that out of the 104 recommendations made by the Collegium of high courts, which are pending with the government, 44 are likely to be processed and sent to the Supreme Court by this weekend. A Bench of Justices S K Kaul and A S Oka also asked Venkat­ara­mani about the five names recommended by the collegium for elevation as judges of the SC.

“Would your lordships defer this for a little while? I have some inputs given to me but I may have some difference of opinion on that,” the Attorney General told the Bench. The Bench observed, “In so far as the pending five recommendations for elevation to this court are concerned, the Attorney General requests for a deferment as he says he is looking into the matter.” At the outset, Venkataramani told the Bench that timeline laid down by the apex court should not be deviated from and all efforts are being made to conform to those timelines.

“Attorney General submits that he has instructions that the government will adhere to the timelines as provided in the judgement. It is towards that objective that he submits that out of the 104 recommendations made by the Collegium of high courts pending with the government, 44 are likely to be processed and sent to the SC by the weekend,” the Bench noted. 

The SC has posted the matter for further hearing on February 3. The apex court Collegium, headed by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud, had last month recommended five judges, including Justices Pankaj Mithal and Sanjay Karol, the chief justices of high courts of Rajasthan and Patna, for elevation as judges of the apex court.

“The Supreme Court Collegium, in its meeting held on December 13, 2022, has resolved to recommend elevation of the following chief justices/judges of the high courts, as judges in the Supreme Court: 1. Justice Pankaj Mithal, Chief Justice, Rajasthan High Court 2. Justice Sanjay Karol, Chief Justice, Patna High Court, 3. Justice P V Sanjay Kumar, Chief Justice, Manipur High Court, 4. Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Judge, Patna High Court and 5. Justice Manoj Misra, Judge, Allahabad High Court," said a statement uploaded on the apex court's website last month.

While hearing the matter last month, the top court had said the collegium system of appointment of judges is the law of the land and comments against it are "not well taken".

It had observed that any law declared by it is "binding" on all stakeholders and the collegium system must be followed.

The collegium system has become a major flashpoint between the Supreme Court and the central government, with the mechanism of judges appointing judges drawing criticism from different quarters.

The plea in the apex court has alleged "wilful disobedience" of time frame laid down to facilitate timely appointment in the apex court's April 20, 2021 order.

In its April 2021 order, the apex court had said the Centre should appoint judges within three-four weeks if the Collegium reiterates its recommendations unanimously.

Coming out with timelines to facilitate the process, it had said the Centre should proceed to make appointment immediately after the apex court Collegium recommends the names and if the government has any reservations on the "suitability or in public interest", it may send it back to the Collegium with the specific reasons for reservation recorded.
 

Govt sending back names a matter of concern: SC
 

The Supreme Court said on Friday it was a “matter of concern" that the Centre is sending back the names reite­rated by the Collegium for judgeship in constit­utional courts despite there being nothing in the present scenario to prevent the appointment post reiteration. The Bench observed that nothing prevents the legislature from bringing in a better system for appointment of judges to constit­utional courts but till the time the law holds it must be implemented. PTI