Maha circular on sedition shows law must be repealed: Amnesty

A circular issued by the Maharashtra Government on when the state police can invoke India's sedition law is "overly broad" and demonstrates why it must be "urgently repealed", Amnesty International said today.
Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code defines sedition as any act or attempt "to bring hatred or contempt, or excite disaffection towards the government".
The offence is punishable with life imprisonment.
The circular, written in Marathi, is based on English guidelines submitted to the Bombay High Court by the state government about how the law must be applied, Amnesty International said in its statement.
"It suggests that speaking against a government representative would amount to sedition. It also dilutes a requirement in the guidelines that the speech in question would constitute incitement to violence or a threat to public order. This circular makes an already bad law even more likely to be abused," said Abhirr VP, Campaigner at Amnesty International India.

"It is vague and overly broad, and can be used by the Maharashtra police to arrest people for legitimate political criticism," he said.

The Maharashtra government had drafted the guidelines in a case arising out of the arrest of cartoonist Aseem Trivedi in 2011 for drawing cartoons that had allegedly insulted national symbols.
Speaking to Amnesty International India, Aseem Trivedi said, "This circular must be challenged in court immediately. Governments in India have always misinterpreted laws and guidelines to curb the freedom of expression".
"The sedition law in India is frequently used against activists and human rights defenders. It is a reminder of how colonial era laws continue to threaten the right to freedom of expression, which is recognised by the Constitution of India and international law," Abhirr VP said.

"There is no good way to apply the sedition law. The Narendra Modi government, which promised to repeal obsolete laws, must add this law to the top of its list," he said.