Though Roy Hodgson's side lost Saturday's match in 2-1, the newspapers found England's attacking verve in Manaus a refreshing change and a source of optimism.
"For England, this was a strange kind of World Cup defeat," wrote Martin Samuel of the Daily Mail.
"This time there will be few recriminations, no grand inquest, little soul-searching, no official or lay examination of what is rotten in our game.
"England played well, but lost. Went for it, but lost. Had many of the best chances, but lost. That happens in football and we'll live with it."
"One senses that, deep down, Hodgson knows it, too," he wrote.
The Sunday Times said England had lost a "battle of age and culture".
"Italy were a dish too hot and a gang too cool for England," wrote Jonathan Northcroft.
"England were beaten but should stay emboldened, for Hodgson's decision to start with youngsters such as Raheem Sterling and bring Ross Barkley off the bench pushed Italy all the way.
"This was the most thrilling, high-quality and engrossing encounter England have played at a World Cup since their exit to Argentina at the 1998 finals in France.