Fortis row: Regulator who said hospitals inflated drug prices transferred

The NPPA conducted its analysis after Gurgaon's Fortis Healthcare charged the family of seven-year-old Adya Singh, a dengue patient, Rs 1.6 million for a 15-day stay and treatment.

On March 1, 2018, Bhupendra Singh, the head of the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA) with a year of his tenure left, was transferred to the National Authority for Chemical Weapons Convention, sparking protests from pro-access activists. They alleged that an “industry and hospital lobby”–mainly large multinational pharmaceutical companies and corporate hospitals–was behind the transfer.

The NPPA is the government agency responsible for setting prices of drugs and ensuring drug availability. Singh had been at its helm since 2016, and under his watch, the prices of cardiac stents were slashed by upto 80% last year.

A week ago, the NPPA published an analysis showing how private hospitals buy medicines and medical devices cheaper in bulk and sell them on to patients much above the maximum retail price, earning margins of up to 1,737%.

The NPPA analysed the bills charged by four “reputed private hospitals” after relatives of deceased patients complained of overcharging. Patients’ families had protested that final bills were three times the initial estimates, the NPPA noted.

It found that the largest component of the bills were drugs, devices and diagnostics (56%), larger than the cost of procedures and room rent (23%), which are the “more visible components”. The prices of medicines and diagnostics were not part of the publicity packages marketed among patients before admission.

The analysis is significant because 58% of households in rural areas and 68% in urban areas choose private hospitals for in-patient care, according to the ‘Health in India’ report from the 71st round of the National Sample Survey.

As many as 15% of poorer households sold assets or took costly loans to pay for hospitalisation, as IndiaSpend reported in July 2017. The average cost of hospitalisation in a private hospital (Rs 20,098) was twice as much as in a public hospital (Rs 9,152).

As many as 52.5 million Indians were pushed into poverty due to healthcare costs in a single year (2011), FactChecker reported in December 2017.

Rs 16 lakh for 15 days of hospitalisation

The NPPA conducted its analysis after Gurgaon’s Fortis Healthcare charged the family of seven-year-old Adya Singh, a dengue patient, Rs 1.6 million ($24,576) for a 15-day stay and treatment. The hospital had allegedly billed the family for 616 syringes and 1,500 non-sterile gloves, as the Economic Times reported on November 25, 2017.

Singh and the other three patients whose bills were investigated had died during treatment. Their families had been charged a total of Rs 6.9 million ($105,984)–an average of more than Rs 1.7 million ($26,112) each. The median per capita income in India was $616 in 2013, a Business Standard report based on a Gallup poll said in December 2013.

Non-essential drugs prescribed for “higher margins”

In all cases, the cost of ‘scheduled’ medicines–essential medicines under price control–was only 4.1% of the total bill, as against ‘non-scheduled formulations’ that constituted 25.6% of the total bill.

 

“It is amply clear that for claiming higher margins, doctors-hospitals preferred prescribing non-scheduled branded medicines instead of scheduled medicines,” the NPPA said. It explained that manufacturers often launch variants of scheduled drugs as “new drugs” or “fixed drug combinations” so as to escape price control, thereby diluting the purpose of creating a National List of Essential Medicines.

The agency found that despite buying medicines in bulk at cheaper prices, hospitals forced pharmaceutical companies to print higher prices to earn “high profit margins” resulting in “huge out of pocket expenditure” for patients.

Diagnostics, device prices also hiked

Hospitals also hiked prices of diagnostic services and devices, which do not fall under the NPPA’s purview. Diagnostic services accounted for 15% of the total bill, but NPPA found that the hospitals charged higher prices for these than other independently-run private centres.

In three of the cases, profit margins for “non-scheduled devices”–syringes, catheters and cannulas–were “exorbitant and clearly a case of unethical profiteering in a failed market system”, the NPPA noted.

 

Hospital Margins In Selling And Purchasing Price
Category	Price At Which Hospitals Purchased (Rs)	Price Printed As MRP (Rs)	Difference (In %)
Scheduled Drugs
Propofol	40.9	187.2	357
Tazira Lyo	100.9	446	342
Non-Scheduled Drugs
Adrenor	14.7	189.9	1192
Dotamin	28.3	287.5	914
Consumables
Three way stop-cap bivalve	5.7	106	1737
Bed-wet wipes	33	350	959
Medical Devices
IV infusion set	5.2	115	1271
Disposable syringe without needle	13.6	200	1208

Source: National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority

 

The benefits accrued to the hospitals and not manufacturers, the NPPA noted.

For example, a three-way stop cock–used in intravenous lines–was priced at Rs 5.77 to the hospital but charged at Rs 106 to patients, a 1,737% increase. Similarly, in scheduled drugs, Verfen–prescribed for pain relief after surgery–was purchased by the hospital at Rs 56.44 but was charged at Rs 220 to patients, an increase of 290%.

“The violation of ceiling price and corresponding MRPs is detected only in very few cases which shall be pursued further by NPPA for recovering the overcharging amounts from defaulters,” the NPPA concluded.

Stent prices capped, but bills still high

The issue of over-charging is not limited to the four cases that the NPPA analysed.

In February 2017, NPPA had capped the prices of coronary stents after including stents in the National List of Essential Medicines, 2015. This reduced stent prices by almost 80% to Rs 7,260 ($111) for regular stents and Rs 29,600 ($454) for advanced drug-eluting stents.

However, the decreased stent prices have not reduced hospital bills, various reports have noted. Hospitals have increased the prices of consumables and procedures, doctors’ charges and laboratory fees to compensate for lower profits. During the month following stent price-capping, the NPPA received more than 40 complaints of overcharging by hospitals, the Indian Express reported on May 16, 2017.

“Despite capping of prices, only 17% of the pharmaceutical market is regulated, the majority is still unregulated,” said Sakhtivel Selvaraj, a health economist working at the Delhi-based non-profit Public Health Foundation of India. Many drug-makers introduce fixed-drug combinations to circumvent the price cap, he said, but some also discontinue manufacture of drugs whose prices are regulated.

From a wider lens, this reflects a demand-supply mismatch. “In current settings, hospitals are fewer in number due to the obstacles created by government bodies to set up new hospitals,” health economist Amir Ullah Khan told IndiaSpend. “As a consequence, existing hospitals have the monopoly of setting the price. Yet there is little or no regulation of private hospitals and the Clinical Establishment Act of 2010 that can regulate hospitals has been approved and put in effect in only a handful of states.”

(Yadavar is a principal correspondent with IndiaSpend.)

Reprinted with permission from IndiaSpend.org, a data-driven, public-interest journalism non-profit organisation. You can read the original article here.