US won't agree to 2022 patent waivers for Covid tests, treatments

The US won't agree to waive intellectual-property protections for Covid-19 treatments and tests this year -- aligning with developed-nation peers and damaging prospects for a WTO accord

The US won’t agree to waive intellectual-property protections for Covid-19 treatments and tests this year -- aligning with developed-nation peers and damaging prospects for a World Trade Organization accord aimed at boosting global access to life-saving medicines. 
 

An official from the Biden administration told Bloomberg News on Monday that it needs more information, and plans to ask the US International Trade Commission to launch an investigation into the matter. The official declined to be identified because the information was private. 

Such investigations can take nine months to a year to complete -- which means delays for a deal that aims to water down patent rights for antiviral medications like Pfizer Inc.’s Paxlovid, Merck & Co.’s Molnupiravir, Gilead Sciences Inc.’s Remdesivir and Eli Lilly & Co.’s Baricitinib. 

The US plans to discuss its views during an informal meeting at the WTO’s headquarters on Tuesday. 

Looming Deadline
 

The debate over waiving IP rights for Covid-19 therapeutics and diagnostics has simmered since this summer, when WTO members approved a five-year decision that authorized the use of vaccine patent secrets without the right-holder’s consent. 

Developing nations such as India, South Africa and Indonesia are pushing to extend the waiver to cover the production and supply of Covid-19 diagnostics and therapeutics. WTO negotiators left the door open to amend the existing waiver by Dec. 17 -- a deadline that will now be missed. 

The WTO operates on the basis of consensus, which means any agreement must have the support of each of the organization’s 164 members. 

The US surprised negotiators a year and a half ago, when it backed an agreement to water down key provisions of the WTO agreement on trade-related aspects of intellectual-property rights for vaccines, known by the acronym Trips. Since then, the US consistently opposed any effort to expand the waiver’s coverage to tests and treatments and spent the past five months consulting with domestic stakeholders about whether it should change course. 

The global market for Covid-19 treatments was worth $10.2 billion in 2021 and is expected to reach $25.6 billion by 2030, according to a report published by InsightAce Analytic. 

Pharma, Hill Backlash
 

Almost three dozen nations oppose a waiver extension -- including the European Union’s 27 members, the UK, Singapore, Switzerland, Japan and South Korea. These governments say they have not seen any concrete evidence that IP rules are hindering the global rollout of Covid-19 treatments and tests. 

The pharmaceutical industry also opposes an extension, and argues that a waiver is unnecessary because the current supply of Covid-19 therapeutics exceeds global demand. 

The International Federation of Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Associations argues that any effort to waive IP rights for Covid-19 treatments would eliminate the incentives that companies have to invest in life-saving drugs in the future. 

Separately, US lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have warned the White House that an IP waiver for tests and treatments “will have devastating, long-reaching effects on access to treatments beyond those used for Covid-19.”