Leading the attack was National Conference leader and former Chief Minister Omar Abullah, who contended that the Mehbooba Mufti government had failed to defend the special status of Jammu and Kashmir before the Supreme Court when NEET was extended to the state.
He questioned the government over its various promises and said no progress was to be seen on revocation of AFSPA or having internal dialogue or restoring the regional balance.
He said the Governor's Address had a "superficial mention" of corruption-free and development-oriented governance.
"This is nothing new and perhaps there has been no government which has not spoken about these issues. The truth is that there is no vision or direction in this government because this government was formed under compulsion," he said.
Omar said the Chief Minister has made many flip flops on various issues and it was likely that doubts will persist about her decision making.
"After the election, you were hoping that a lot will be achieved by aligning with BJP and entered into an Agenda of Alliance but so far no progress is to be seen on revocation of AFSPA, internal dialogue or restoring the regional balance," he told Mehbooba, the leader of PDP.
"Your spokespersons went to media saying that you want assurances on AFSPA and return of power projects to the state. You met the Prime Minister and emerged satisfied enough to form the government. So far there is no clarity what assurances you got from the Prime Minister. We want to know," the former Chief Minister said to Mehbooba.
Omar also recalled that BJP general secretary Ram Madhav had told the media that Mehbooba had not sought any assurances but only blessings of the Prime Minister.
The NC leader raised the issue of Handwara where a girl was allegedly molested last month, saying her security had been compromised by the release of her video and the police also has been villified due to this case.
He said the same happened in NIT issue where the police was replaced by CRPF for security at the controversy-struck institute last month.
"It is the police which protect us and put their lives on the line. You have to protect the police if they are right and take action if anyone is wrong," he said.
"Jammu and Kashmir is the only state where medical education is in the State List, not in the Concurrent List like other states. But you failed in stopping NEET as it was not applicable to our state. It is a direct attack on our special status," he said.
Omar said while he was criticised by PDP for detaining separatists during his tenure, the ruling party now was following the same practice. "Where is the battle of ideas you spoke of," the former Chief Minister asked Mehbooba.
Referring to the return of Kashmiri Pandits and reported establishment of Sainik Colonies in Kashmir, Omar said there is "no clarity" on these. "We are not against these but the government needs to clear its stand. It cannot blame every thing on the previous government," he said.
According to Omar, the Prime Minister "yesterday said as soon as the land is made available the colony for Kashmiri pandits will be set up". He then said, "are you providing the land? We are for return of Kashmiri pandits, Muslim and Sikh migrants but we don't want a Jagti like camp in Kashmir."
He also raised the issue of AIIMS hospital, smart cities, IIT and IIM. "Land has been identified for AIIMS in Jammu but not in Kashmir. Jammu got an IIT and there was not a murmur against it in Kashmir. However, if an IIM or smart city is sanctioned for Srinagar, there will be rucks in Jammu," he said asking where is the promise of bridging the regional gap.
Omar also said there was no development work undertaken by the government when it had an opportunity to improve on that front by spending the Rs 80,000 crore PM's package.
"I am not the opposition leader who will set the state on fire in pursuit of power. In the interest of the state, if you need my support, you will not find me lacking," he said.
Congress MLA Nawang Rigzin Jora said there was nothing in the Governor's Address which his party had boycotted.
Targeting PDP-BJP alliance, he said "the soft separatist Mehbooba Mufti has been tamed by hardline Hindutva organisations. What has come out of it? A Sanghi sarkar."
(Reopen DES31)
"Former Chief Minister Mufti Mohammad Sayeed always used to say that this House is the most empowered institution in the country. However, we feel it is the most disempowered one. There is systematic erosion," National Conference MLC Bashir Veeri said.
"In Agenda of Alliance, you have promised to protect the special status of the state but now you are doing opposite of that by proposing to establish sainik colony, separate settlements for pandits and new industrial policy," he said.
Congress member G N Monga said it was unfortunate that Prime Minister Narendra Modi did not utter a word over Handwara killings last month during his visit to the state.
"Had Modi uttered a single word on the killings (of five civilians), our chests too would have become 56 inches," he said, taking a dig apparently on the Prime Minister's slogan.
Speaking in favour of the motion, BJP's Ramesh Arora appreciated the role of police and security forces in the state.
"No one here has said any word on the recent killings of policemen. I feel there is a calculated effort to demoralise their spirits," he said.
On the issue of Sainik colonies, Arora said the controversy over the issue was a deliberate attempt to vitiate peace in the valley.
Speaking in favour of the motion, BJP's Ramesh Arora appreciated the role of police and security forces in the state.
"No one here has said any word on the recent killings of policemen. I feel there is a calculated effort to demoralise their spirits," he said.
On the issue of Sainik colonies, Arora said the controversy over the issue was a deliberate attempt to vitiate peace in the valley.
"Where has this government done anything to change the law? It is a deliberate attempt to vitiate peace. Why should there be any objection to someone establishing colony for those who have secured our lives here," he said.
