Treatment of arrested diplomat was typical in US

Image
AP New York
Last Updated : Dec 22 2013 | 12:15 AM IST
It has sparked protests outside the American embassy in New Delhi. Burnings of President Barack Obama's photo. And angry speeches by Indian officials.
But the arrest - and, yes, even the strip search - of an Indian diplomat accused of visa fraud also revealed a simple and longstanding reality of the US justice system: Everyone charged with a crime here is supposed to be treated the same, whether wealthy or poor, prominent or ordinary, citizen or foreigner.
"There is a remarkable and almost charming egalitarianism in it," said New York City defense attorney Ron Kuby.
"Everybody is treated in exactly the same disrespectful, casually brutal and arrogant fashion."
The United States is the only place where "the rich as well as the poor get to sleep on cold floors and urinate in overflowing toilets - together."
Indian officials have been angry over the way federal marshals handled Devyani Khobragade, the country's deputy consul general in New York, calling the treatment degrading and inhumane. Yet most Americans would find the procedures fairly typical for a criminal case - though certainly not pleasant.
Khobragade, who was arrested last week outside her daughter's school, complained that she was strip-searched and held in a cell "with drug addicts" until her appearance before a judge.
She posted USD 250,000 bail and was released. And she insists she is not guilty of charges she submitted false documents to obtain a visa for an Indian woman who worked as her housekeeper in Manhattan.
The case stirred widespread outrage in India, where the idea of an educated, middle-class woman being strip-searched is almost unheard of, except in the most extraordinary crimes. The fear of public humiliation resonates strongly there, and heavy-handed treatment by the police is normally reserved for the poor.
US Attorney Preet Bharara, who brought the charges, was born in India and raised here. He said the diplomat was "fully searched" by a female deputy, which is "standard practice for every defendant ... In order to make sure that no prisoner keeps anything on his person that could harm anyone, including himself."
Khobragade's lawyer said "similarly situated individuals of her stature are routinely provided an opportunity to report to the authorities to address charges at their convenience, instead of being swept off the street like a common criminal."
In India, the wealthy fearing arrest often approach courts for anticipatory bail, a means of avoiding arrest. The poor cannot afford that luxury because they are not in a position to hire prominent attorneys and pay legal costs.
Influential politicians sometimes feign illness after an arrest to get shifted to hospitals rather than prisons. But in the US, defendants of all types are routinely searched, photographed and fingerprinted before going to court.
*Subscribe to Business Standard digital and get complimentary access to The New York Times

Smart Quarterly

₹900

3 Months

₹300/Month

SAVE 25%

Smart Essential

₹2,700

1 Year

₹225/Month

SAVE 46%
*Complimentary New York Times access for the 2nd year will be given after 12 months

Super Saver

₹3,900

2 Years

₹162/Month

Subscribe

Renews automatically, cancel anytime

Here’s what’s included in our digital subscription plans

Exclusive premium stories online

  • Over 30 premium stories daily, handpicked by our editors

Complimentary Access to The New York Times

  • News, Games, Cooking, Audio, Wirecutter & The Athletic

Business Standard Epaper

  • Digital replica of our daily newspaper — with options to read, save, and share

Curated Newsletters

  • Insights on markets, finance, politics, tech, and more delivered to your inbox

Market Analysis & Investment Insights

  • In-depth market analysis & insights with access to The Smart Investor

Archives

  • Repository of articles and publications dating back to 1997

Ad-free Reading

  • Uninterrupted reading experience with no advertisements

Seamless Access Across All Devices

  • Access Business Standard across devices — mobile, tablet, or PC, via web or app

More From This Section

First Published: Dec 22 2013 | 12:15 AM IST

Next Story