Prevent stubble burning: HC to UP, Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana

Observing that the national capital every year grapples with the menace of haze due to stubble burning affecting people's health, Delhi High Court directed the neighbouring states to "strike while the iron is hot" to prevent this practice.
A bench of justices Badar Durrez Ahmed and Ashutosh Kumar said it had taken a serious view of the matter as Delhi and its people have been grappling with the problem every year, despite orders of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) to stop the practice of burning of crop and agriculture residue.
The bench made it clear it will hold the Chief Secretaries of Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh responsible if the orders of NGT and the court were not implemented.

"Every year we grapple with the menace of haze due to stubble burning. It (burning of crop residue) may have already started as you can see haze in the early morning. It will hit us and the situation will get worse. It will even become difficult to breathe.
"We are taking a serious view on it this year. NGT has been asking them (states) to take action, but nobody is doing anything. If you do not hit now while the iron is hot, the situation in Delhi will become worse," the court said.
Noting that "stubble burning is not permissible under the law", it said the "difficulty lies in implementation" as "despite orders of NGT and this court, this practice has gone unabated and year after year and Delhi has been engulfed in haze, constituents of which are aerosols from stubble burning and dust".

The bench said the effects of pollution were felt by every citizen, particularly the elderly and children in the national capital who experience difficulty in breathing.

The court also said pollution manifested itself in long term effect like "reduction in longevity", particularly so for PM 2.5, a fine particulate matter which can be absorbed in the blood stream.
"It is for this reason that preventive measures need to be taken and we should strike when the iron is hot," it said.
Expressing hope that the law and court orders would be followed in letter and spirit, the bench directed the four states to file status reports with regard to action taken by them to ensure stubble burning practice is eliminated.

The court was hearing a PIL initiated by it on the issue
of air pollution in the national capital and had asked the governments of Uttar Pradesh, Haryana and Punjab about their action plan to stop the practice of stubble burning.
This activity is undertaken by farmers to clear the fields before sowing the next crop after Diwali.
Punjab government, represented by advocate Naginder Benipal, said that immediate action was required by Haryana as it was much closer to Delhi.
Haryana government said it has already started taking action in compliance with the orders of NGT.
Rajasthan government said its Chief Secretary has held meetings on how to deal with the issue and said the pollution control board of the state should also be made a party.

Delhi Pollution Control Commission (DPCC), represented by advocate Sanjeev Ralli, said that directions were given by NGT to these states last year itself to stop stubble burning, so let them also show what they have done so far.
The bench thereafter said that any action taken by the states can be seen from the air quality data collected by the 20 monitoring stations in Delhi run by DPCC, Central Pollution Control Board and Ministry of Earth Sciences.
It directed all the three agencies "to ensure that data is recorded for entire month of October and November 2016 and a comparative chart be placed before us comparing current year data with previous year and also comparing with August and September months of 2016".