 "Protein shakes for breakfast: Healthy choice or nutrition gap in making?")
In the rush of morning routines, a quick protein shake often feels like the perfect breakfast fix; fast, filling, and packed with nutrients. But is this convenient drink really a smart choice? Experts weigh in on whether this breakfast-in-a-blender can truly replace a wholesome morning meal.
Protein shakes for breakfast - smart or not?
Protein shakes have gained popularity among fitness enthusiasts, professionals, and those short on time. They are rich in amino acids, which support muscle repair and satiety.
However, Rutu Dhodapkar, Head of Dietetics Department at P D Hinduja Hospital & Medical Research Centre, Khar, points out that a shake alone doesn’t make for a balanced breakfast. “A protein shake is high in protein but lacks fibre and complex carbohydrates that stabilise energy levels and support gut health,” she says.
For sedentary individuals, relying solely on protein shakes can do more harm than good. “Replacing breakfast with a protein shake is not recommended as excess protein can put load on kidneys, if hydration is not proper,” warns Dhodapkar.
Dr Bhanu Mishra, Consultant-Nephrologist at Fortis Hospital, Delhi, echoes this concern. “A pure protein shake alone is not a good breakfast. Most lack dietary fibre, healthy fats, vitamins, and minerals supplied by whole foods,” he explains.
Without these essential nutrients, one may experience issues with digestion, energy fluctuations, or long-term imbalances in metabolic health.
Making your shake more balanced
Both experts agree that protein shakes can serve as a convenient breakfast substitute if made right. They can be a bliss for athletes, those recovering from illness, or people constantly on the go.
To make it more complete, Dhodapkar suggests blending protein with whole grains, fruits, nuts, and seeds, or pairing it with a high-fibre Indian breakfast such as ragi chilla with vegetables, oats, or thalipeeth. Adding fibrous fruits like guava, papaya, or pear can also help boost gut health and keep you fuller for longer. These additions slow down digestion, support the gut microbiome, and help balance blood sugar levels.
Dr Mishra adds that blending fruits, seeds, or oats improves the nutrient profile, turning it into a mini meal rather than a quick fix.
Caution with commercial powders
Both experts urge consumers to check labels before buying ready-to-drink protein shakes or commercial protein powders.
“Watch for added sugars, preservatives, and artificial sweeteners,” says Dr Mishra. “Choose brands that are FSSAI-certified, use cleaner ingredients, and have transparent labelling.”
Dhodapkar adds, “Instead of sugar, jaggery or dates-based options can be a better choice.”
Fitting protein shakes into Indian breakfast habits
In Indian households, breakfasts are often heavy on carbohydrates — think parathas, idlis, or poha. A protein shake, therefore, can help balance the plate, but moderation is key.
“Protein shakes in India should supplement, not replace, traditional meals,” notes Dr Mishra. “They’re useful for busy professionals or vegetarians, but shouldn’t become a daily habit”
Dhodapkar agrees, recommending that shakes be part of a diverse diet, not the only source of nutrition in the morning.
More from this series:
- From muscles to immunity: Why protein is important for your health
- Are you getting the right amount of protein for your body's needs?
- Protein overload: Why eating more isn't always better for your body
- What two boiled eggs a day can do for your strength, focus, and health
- Getting enough protein as a vegetarian is easier than you think: Here's how
- Protein on a budget: Everyday foods that outperform protein bars
- High-protein diet isn't always better: Here's when it turns risky
- Should you try protein coffee? Experts decode the popular health trend
For more health updates, follow #HealthwithBS
This report is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical advice.