The Supreme Court (SC) judgment asking for Singur land to be returned to the original owners could likely open several cases of land acquisition carried out before 2009. But, the judgment will have no impact on land being acquired for Smart City projects, claim experts."The judgment again tosses in the air the concept of public interest", said Suhaan Mukherjee, partner at PLR Chambers, which specialises in public policy. The two judges have differed on whether the land acquired for the Tata Nano project in Singur was in public interest.On Wednesday, a two-judge bench ruled as invalid the acquisition of land in Singur by the West Bengal government for a Tata Motors' project made in 2006. The judges have asked the state to return the 997 acres of land to the farmers, since the acquisition made under the Land Acquisition Act of 1894 was "perverse and illegal" by the then state government. The Singur land acquisition has been a watershed for land disputes in India. All political parties
The top court told the present West Bengal Government to hand the land back to farmers in the next 12 weeks
Says law was flouted by the Left Front government in West Bengal in 2006
Implementing the SC order is likely to be a minefield for the Trinamool Congress-led government
For the people at Beraberi, the SC verdict marks the end of a decade-long rebellion for land rights
The company's share gained 1.7% to Rs 537 on BSE and was the fourth highest gainer among Sensex stocks
Those who had used brute force to acquire land should tender an apology to the masses and hang their head in shame, said Partha Chatterjee
Land was back then acquired by following the Land Acquisition Act of 1894, said CPI(M) state secretary Surya Kant Mishra
The apex court has agreed that land should be restored in 12 weeks to the owners and cultivators
The West Bengal govt has also been directed to take possession of the land and return it to the landowners in 12 weeks
The Supreme Court is to rule on the Singur case today, five years after the Bengal government filed an appeal against a Calcutta HC order striking down the Singur Land Act
The same hot-bed of land rights movement against Tata Nano factory that helped TMC overthrow CPI(M)'s over three-decade rule ,can now come back to bite the ruling govt
It might be hard to predict who will win but the nation awaits the verdict from Singur nonetheless as a commentary on current West Bengal politics
Singur was on the boil between 2006 and 2008 after the then Left Front government acquired 997.11 acres of land for setting up the small car factory