Vantara gets clean chit in SIT report: 'In strict compliance with laws'

SIT headed by ex-Supreme Court judge Justice J Chelameswar finds facility in regulatory compliance; states allegations of mistreatment of animals, including elephants, are unsubstantiated

A Special Investigation Team (SIT) headed by former Supreme Court judge Justice J Chelameswar has given a clean chit to Vantara, the Greens Zoological Rescue and Rehabilitation Centre run by the Reliance Foundation in Jamnagar, Gujarat, according to Bar and Bench.

 

The matter came up before a bench comprising Justices Pankaj Mithal and PB Varale on Monday.

Vantara in regulatory compliance: SC

The SIT submitted its report in a sealed cover to the Supreme Court, which expressed satisfaction with the compliance and regulatory measures at the facility. "We have gone through the summary of the report. It notes erudite in regulatory compliance. It notes that stakeholders also presented views. Authorities have expressed satisfaction with the regulatory compliance," said Justice Mithal. 

 

The court had constituted the SIT to conduct an independent factual appraisal of allegations concerning animal welfare and operational practices at Vantara.

 

During the proceedings, Justice Mithal noted that the acquisition and care of animals at the centre were carried out in compliance with regulatory norms, and that the SIT’s recommendations would guide the authorities.

Allegations regarding elephants 'unfounded'

The bench also addressed claims regarding the treatment of elephants at Vantara, stating that allegations of mistreatment were unsubstantiated and that acquisitions had been made according to law. "If the acquisition is according to the law, then what is the problem? If all provisions are followed, you cannot pass some general statements like this," the bench noted.

 

Justice Mithal emphasised that certain cultural and conservation practices are a matter of national pride and should not be disrupted without evidence. "There are some things which are the pride of our country. We cannot raise these issues and create hue and cry. Let some good things happen in the country, we should be happy about it," he said.

 

The top court concluded the proceeding, saying it will pass orders based on the SIT report in chambers, ensuring that authorities implement its recommendations without entertaining unnecessary allegations.