USCIS says no citizenship for immigrants without good moral character

USCIS has warned that green card holders with poor moral character will not be considered for US citizenship, citing the need for applicants to meet high ethical and community standards

Want to apply for US citizenship? United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) on Wednesday warned, “Applicants for naturalisation without ‘good moral character’ need not apply.”

  USCIS mentioned a case of an immigrant who entered the country with an active warrant for larceny – Grand Theft Auto – prompting authorities to be notified.

 

“Becoming a #NewUSCitizen is a great privilege – an honour granted to those who embrace values, responsibilities, and freedoms that define our nation, not a guaranteed right owed to all,” said USCIS in a post on X (formerly Twitter).

 

Ketan Mukhija, senior partner at Burgeon Law, explained to Business Standard, “In the context of US naturalisation law, ‘good moral character’ is a legal standard requiring applicants to demonstrate, during the statutory period (typically the five years preceding the application), that their behaviour aligns with the ethical and moral standards expected of the average member of the community. This goes beyond simply avoiding criminal convictions; it involves showing honesty, responsibility, and respect for the law, such as fulfilling tax and family obligations, avoiding fraud or deceit, and upholding civic duties.”

 

What is naturalisation?

 

Naturalisation is the process by which a Green Card holder becomes a US citizen. It usually takes between three and five years, depending on the individual’s circumstances. Applicants must meet residency requirements, show good moral character, pass English language and civics tests, and take an oath of allegiance.

 

The application costs $760, though military applicants are exempt. USCIS offers a $50 discount for online applications. Average processing time is around 4.9 months but can vary.

 

What does good moral character involve?

 

According to USCIS, good moral character is determined on a case-by-case basis. Officials look at:

 

* Criminal history, including arrests and convictions

* Compliance with tax laws and financial responsibilities

* Honesty in immigration applications and interviews

* Community behaviour over time

 

Common reasons for failing to meet this requirement

 

* Criminal convictions and aggravated felonies such as drug trafficking, rape, sexual abuse of a minor, or fraud over $10,000

* Unpaid federal or state taxes

* Failure to pay child support

* Lying to USCIS or committing immigration fraud

* Habitual drunkenness, multiple DUI offences or substance abuse

* Involvement in illegal gambling or prostitution

 

For example, those with multiple DUI arrests may be asked to show proof of alcohol counselling or drug treatment programmes.

 

Permanent bars to good moral character

 

Some offences permanently bar an applicant from naturalisation, according to USCIS:

 

< Murder

< Aggravated felonies (after November 29, 1990) including crimes of violence or theft with prison terms of one year or more

< Genocide, torture or particularly severe violations of religious freedom

 

Aggravated felonies include:

 

Murder, rape or sexual abuse of a minor

Drug trafficking or illicit firearms trafficking

Money laundering over $10,000

Fraud or deceit with losses over $10,000

Alien smuggling

Document fraud or misuse of visas

 

The US Immigration and Nationality Act defines each of these offences in detail.

 

What is the naturalisation process?

 

Application for naturalisation (Form N-400): This can be filed online or on paper. Military applicants and those seeking fee waivers must use paper applications.

Biometrics appointment: Usually within a month of submitting the application. Applicants’ fingerprints are taken for background checks.

Citizenship interview and exam: Around 14 months after applying, USCIS conducts an interview and tests applicants’ English skills and US civics knowledge.

Oath of allegiance: After approval, applicants attend a ceremony, hand in their Green Card, and receive a Certificate of Naturalisation.

 

Benefits of becoming a US citizen

 

Becoming a US citizen brings several benefits. It grants the right to vote in federal elections and eligibility to run for public office, offering a chance to actively participate in the country’s governance. It means freedom from repeated immigration paperwork and the chance to take up jobs that require citizenship, such as certain government roles. US citizens can also access government benefits like Social Security and Medicare, and they are protected from deportation, no matter the circumstances. Citizenship allows them to sponsor family members for immigration, provides automatic citizenship for their children, and grants a US passport, making international travel easier with visa-free access to many countries.

 

For many Indians becoming a US citizen is a still a dream. Over a million Indians are currently waiting for Green Cards, with some facing decades-long waits due to annual caps and per-country limits. The Department of Homeland Security said in 2022 that there were 12.9 million Green Card holders living in the US, with 9.2 million eligible for citizenship.