“We do not have any opinion on Junior Murthy’s ability, but making him a vice president surely diminishes the halo around Infosys’s corporate governance standards,” HDFC Securities said in a note on Monday.
“If Junior Murthy is eventually elevated to a decision-making position like chief information officer, chief executive officer or managing director, without spending significant time at middle management levels and without proving his mettle, that would be not taken kindly by investors,” it added. The brokerage firm went on to say that such decisions by Infosys, if they happen, might lead to a de-rating of the company.
|SINCE NARAYANA MURTHY’S RETURN|
June 1, 2013 : Infosys recalls Narayana Murthy as executive chairman for five years. Rohan Murty made executive assistant to the chairman on Murthy's request. NRN says Rohan never to take up any leadership roles in Infosys
July 11, 2013 : T Basab Pradhan, head of global sales and marketing, quits Infosys. Industry experts say this may be a part of the organisation overhaul initiated by Narayana Murthy
July 12, 2013 : Infosys sticks to FY14 revenue guidance and delivers 3.7% net profit growth for Apr-Jun. Stock rises 11 per cent. CEO & MD Shibulal says “Murthy's presence is a huge difference for us”
August 3, 2013 : Shareholders approve Narayana Murthy’s appointment as executive chairman at Infosys
August 20, 2013 : Infosys adds three members to its executive council, a high-level decision making body
August 24, 2013 : Vice-president & head (financial services) in Americas, Sudhir Chaturvedi, steps
August 25, 2013 : Reports of Rohan Murty's appointment as a vice president emerge. Infosys says his appointment not yet cleared by corporate affairs ministry and his designation not yet final
Rohan joined Infosys in June, when Narayana Murthy returned to the Bangalore-based company as the executive chairman. At the time of his joining, Narayana Murthy had stated that Rohan would only work as an executive assistant in the chairman's office, and would not have any leadership role in the company. “The only role Rohan has, is to make me more effective,” Murthy had said in June at a press conference to announce his appointment as the executive chairman.
However, last week, some media reports stated that Rohan has been designated as a vice president, which is a relatively senior position in the company. Infosys did not deny the reports, but came out with an official statement, saying: “Mr Rohan Murty’s appointment at Infosys is yet to be approved by the corporate affairs ministry. His designation would be confirmed once the process of appointment has been completed.”
“If reports that Rohan Murty has been designated vice-president are to be believed, it looks like Infosys would soon designate him the chief executive officer of the company,” Shriram Subramanian, founder and managing director of corporate governance research firm, InGovern Research Services Pvt. Ltd, said.
“Rohan Murty joined in June, and at that time, Narayana Murthy himself went on record to say that Rohan Murty doesn't aspire for senior leadership position. But now, if the position has changed, what can prevent Rohan Murty from becoming managing director of Infosys before Diwali?” he added.
Most analysts share such concerns and believe that Infosys might be taking “desperate measures due to desperate times”.
“The biggest concern for investors is that a senior position for the inexperienced Rohan Murty might raise eyebrows within the company's top leadership,” an analyst with a US-based brokerage said. “This would be the third time that N R Narayana Murthy bends the rules that he himself had instated,” the analyst added.
Infosys under Narayana Murthy had earlier formulated a policy as a part of which the family members of the co-founders were not allowed to join the company even through the normal route. To a question if with the entry of Rohan Murty into the company, the family members of the other co-founders would also be allowed to join the company, Murthy had said it would be the prerogative of the board to take any such decision.
“If the company sees it necessary to invite anybody who has retired -- not just the co-founders -- he or she has the right to say that these are the terms under which they would be effective and add value to the company,” Murthy has said in June this year.
Calling it a “very big breech of corporate governance,” a senior industry source close to Infosys, said, “You must understand that by doing that, Murthy is trying to push his son.”
Infosys did not reply to a query of whether the appointment of Rohan would be a breach of the corporate governance practice in the company.