Volkswagen will probably have to show there was some legitimate reason to install software that led to false vehicle emissions tests if it is to avoid US criminal charges, lawyers said on Tuesday.
The German automaker has admitted to US clean air regulators that in some of its diesel cars it used a so-called "defeat device," which was designed to defeat emissions tests. As a result, it is almost certainly exposed to very large civil penalties that could be imposed by the US government, said attorneys with expertise in environmental prosecutions though not involved in the Volkswagen case. The criminal probe, which was confirmed by a source familiar with the matter on Tuesday, is likely to examine not only possible violations of the US Clean Air Act but also of broader statutes against wire fraud, false statements to regulators and other crimes, the lawyers said. Individual employees are also likely to be investigated and could potentially face criminal charges if wrongdoing is discovered, the lawyers added.
A justice department spokesman declined to comment. A Volkswagen spokesman did not respond to requests for comment on what the company's legal strategy would be.
Also Read
Deliberately faking emissions results could be seen by prosecutors as a multi-layered fraud against consumers, regulators and auto dealers, the lawyers said. But there will likely be a debate between the justice department and Volkswagen's legal team over what the company and its employees intended by installing the software.
US prosecutors generally must find evidence of intent to commit a crime - such as incriminating emails or information from cooperating witnesses - before they can charge someone.
The installation of the devices is not necessarily evidence of intentional misconduct, said Bruce Pasfield, a former environmental prosecutor.
