The discussion in the meeting of state finance ministers on the empowered committee for the goods and services tax (GST) saw heated debate on the use of the words "may" and "shall". West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra said as much when he said the fine print of GST should be written with no ambiguity. Elaborating on how ambiguous use of words could lead to misinterpretation, he said, "Today the key point is safeguarding states' interest. The language of the constitutional amendment has to be 100 per cent clear. For example, in government files, we often see the use of the word 'may'. In some legal terminology it may mean 'shall'. If it means shall, why not call it 'shall'. I hope, at the end of the day, the language of the constitutional amendment comes out as 'shall'." What people don't know is, things reached such a pass that a dictionary had to be procured to analyse accurately the difference between "may" and "shall".
PM to speak on new tax regime in Lok Sabha on Monday
The BJP members in the Rajya Sabha were under strict instructions to not get provoked by Opposition members during the discussion
PM to speak on GST on Monday in LS; In RS, govt scores moral victory on issue of money Bill
Logistics firms have warehouses in all states but after the GST comes into play they can set up fewer and better located facilities
BJP has asked its members to be present in the House on Monday to ensure its smooth passage
Centre would take steps for enactment of CGST and IGST Act, the states would enact SGST Act
Jaitley's team sees limited impact on inflation, says software will be ready in three-four months
Hopes to continue to isolate Congress in Rajya Sabha
Maruti Suzuki, Tata Motors and Hyundai stand to gain the maximum, given their large portfolio of products in the sub-4 meter segment
Cost escalation, abolition of tax holidays loom
Implementation of the GST in the near term could bring some upturn in inflation, said Morgan Stanley in a report
Sector experts believe the proposed GST would streamline the domestic supply chain and have a beneficial effect for home buyers
Analysts are assuming that if the effective GST rate is at 18%, then telecom subscribers will have to shell out a little more as the current service tax rate is 15%
Interview with Economic affairs secretary
The issues of concern include GST being levied on stock transfers from sellers to warehouses and taxes on discounts as well as freebies offered by e-commerce companies
If the taxation structure for essential medicines changes within the GST regime, prices of drugs could increase significantly
Consumer goods makers, including consumer staples and durables, say the taxation rate will be critical to determine how effective GST is
Post GST, warehousing costs and inventory levels will come down by half
Though the road ahead for GST is pretty long, Wednesday's landmark legislation is good news for world economy