Business Standard

T N Ninan: Who next?

If Mr Gandhi opts out, and if Manmohan Singh is considered too old to continue, it is increasingly obvious that the Congress candidate will have to be Chidambaram

Related News

Weekends can sometimes be devoted to idle speculation, so it should be permissible to look forward to 2014 and speculate on who could be prime minister after the Lok Sabha elections. If the is in a position to lead a coalition (and this is a huge ‘if’), its preference as leader is certain to be Rahul Gandhi. But Mr Gandhi has shown a sustained reluctance to accept ministerial office. He has declared in the past that being prime minister is no big deal for members of his family, and he may be unwilling to accept the top job in a messy coalition — which, from this admittedly considerable distance of time, is what seems the most plausible electoral outcome. If Mr Gandhi opts out, and if is considered too old to continue, it is increasingly obvious that the Congress candidate will have to be P Chidambaram.

For a start, no one else in the Congress has his record in the government. He was successful as home minister — with a much better performance rating than and L K Advani, his immediate predecessors from 1998 to 2008. Now, as finance minister, he is showing a combination of energy level and focus that was missing in his predecessor. Since 2004, Chidambaram has also been the only minister to have come consistently prepared for ministerial meetings. Most important, he seems to have the ear of Sonia Gandhi, and played a role in the Congress leadership’s belated recognition (and public endorsement) of the vital importance of economic reform and fiscal rectitude. A look at the others sitting up on Raisina Hill (A K Antony, Sushilkumar Shinde and Salman Khurshid) should rule them out as options; ditto with the other leading lights of the government: Kamal Nath, Anand Sharma, and Veerappa Moily. Among the party office-bearers, is seen as too much of a maverick.

But this is not being written just to sing Mr Chidambaram’s praises. If he is to win acceptability for the top job, he needs to demonstrate that he can establish working relations with people of different political persuasions — remember that he had run-ins with state governments when he was home minister. He has a history of being prickly when faced with criticism, and not very tolerant of dissent, as he demonstrated recently by being peevish when the Reserve Bank did not do what he wanted, on interest rates. He also tends to micro-manage. But he is supremely intelligent, and should be able to recognise that anyone who hopes to lead a country like India needs to develop shock absorbers as a part of his personal armour, and to be wise rather than clever. In India’s age of scandal, he will also need to steer clear of controversy (his son has already been involved in one or two), and of course win the court battle over his 2009 election.

Most importantly, he will have to show results over the next 18 months, when there are severe limitations on what he can do. He has only one Budget to reverse fiscal trends, and with the best will in the world, there isn’t time to deliver the Goods and Services Tax in time for that. Many of the solutions that the government is tom-tomming are unlikely to materialise (such as foreign investment in airlines and higher foreign investment in insurance), and foreign investment in multi-brand retail is unlikely to have any material bearing on any product market before 2014. Earlier government initiatives have run aground too, like the special economic zones. Quite simply, reform is complicated. To underline his claim to the top job, Mr Chidambaram will have to lead the reform charge, bring down the deficit, reduce inflation, revive investment, and show better GDP (Gross Domestic Product) growth. It is a test worthy of a future prime minister; the present one passed precisely such a test.

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|

Read More

Jamal Mecklai: To ECB or not to ECB

Exports have been on the ropes for over a year now. In average, they have been lower by nearly a billion dollars in each of the last 12 months. While ...

Advertisements

Most Popular Columns

Rahul Jacob

Rahul Jacob: How Mr Modi has outplayed the media
Rahul Jacob

From a ruling party's perspective, the BJP is in a sweet spot; editorial independence and analytical coverage of governance is rapidly declining

Abheek Barua

Abheek Barua: The right questions
Abheek Barua

A response to the 28 economists defending the employment guarantee scheme

Sreenivasan Jain

Sreenivasan Jain: Is Swachh Bharat repeating mistakes of the past?
Sreenivasan Jain

India's proposed toilet revolution is all set to repeat mistakes of the past

Advertisement

Columnists

T N Ninan

T N Ninan: The audacity of hope?
T N Ninan

First, the country has only 2.6 Gw of solar capacity installed as of now, and the plan has been to take it up to 20 Gw by 2020 (revised later to ...

T C A Srinivasa-Raghavan

T C A Srinivasa-Raghavan: The two phases of Nehru
T C A Srinivasa-Raghavan

Historians ought to examine the pre-1947 Nehru independently of the post-1947 one

Sunanda K Datta-Ray

Sunanda K Datta-Ray: Black money and black holes
Sunanda K Datta-Ray

Instead of chasing chimeras or politically motivated witch-hunts, we need to focus on the phenomenon of black money. The point is not how it is ...

Back to Top