You are here: Home » Companies » News
Business Standard

CCI dismisses complaints against Google; D K Sikri gives dissent note

In a majority order passed by four members, the CCI concluded that there was no violation of competition norms by Google

Press Trust of India  |  New Delhi 

It was alleged that Google indulged in anti-competitive practices with respect to its advertising platform AdWords

Anti-trust regulator on Thursday rejected allegations of unfair business practices made against with respect to its advertising platform, saying the internet major's actions did not infringe provisions of competition law.

In a majority order passed by four members, the concluded that there was no violation of competition norms by However, (CCI) Chairperson D K Sikri passed a dissent note.

ALSO READ: Google integrates its peer-to-peer payments service with 'Google Pay'

The majority ruling came on complaints filed against LLC, and back in 2014.

The complaints were filed by one Vishal Gupta and (informants). Both entities are into remote technology support business.

It was alleged that Google indulged in anti-competitive practices with respect to its advertising platform AdWords.

ALSO READ: How Google, Facebook are monopolising ideas

For the case, the (CCI) considered 'Market for Online Search Advertising Services in India' as the relevant one. According to the regulator, Google's protect the platform and the end-users, particularly, the vulnerable end-users.

"... there is evidence on record showing that the informants' conduct was likely to endanger end-users of remote tech services. They repeatedly committed multiple violations of the AdWords policies, demonstrating a consistent and persistent pattern of misconduct and user harm (eg. through tactics designed to mislead or exploit users)," the order said. There were multiple violations of AdWords Phone Number Policy by including telephone numbers in ad titles, text, or visible URLs that mislead users into thinking they would place a call by clicking on the ad, when in fact they would be redirected to a website, the said.

Among others, the regulator said there were violations of the relevance clarity, accuracy and user safety policies by using inaccurate ad text.

ALSO READ: Google served notice for constructing road on green belt in Gurugram

About the CCI order, a Google spokesperson said, "we are pleased that, after a thorough analysis, the Commission has confirmed Google's conduct to be fair, pro-consumer, and compliant with competition law".

"We are committed to ensuring that our users have a safe experience when clicking on ads on our platform," the spokesperson said in a statement.

In the statement, Google said the matter pertains to enforcement action taken by its Ads Team in 2013 against the two entities.

The internet major said that legitimate remote tech specialists help consumers fix problems with their computers or devices from a remote location.

However, there are several remote tech that engage in nefarious practices such as credit card fraud, installation of malware, enrolling users in recurring billing subscriptions without their prior knowledge and using false diagnosis information and scare tactics to encourage users to engage in their services, the statement noted.

ALSO READ: Google responds to snooping concerns, says emails not scanned to target ads

"Google has taken action against many such remote tech for breaches of the (and removed their harmful ads from its platform).

"These policies and Google's enforcement are aimed at protecting users, other legitimate advertisers, and the AdWords platform," it added.

Meanwhile, Sikri, in his dissent note, said he was of the opinion that "rather than passing a final order under Section 27 of the (Competition) Act, the present cases ought to have been referred back to the Director General... for further investigation" on the basis of certain aspects. Section 27 pertains to orders passed by the regulator after inquiry into agreements or abuse of dominant position. Director General is the probe arm of the regulator. Earlier too, Google had come under the CCI scanner for alleged unfair business practices.

First Published: Fri, July 13 2018. 01:08 IST