Tata Sons listing critical, will dismantle culture of secrecy: Jimmy N Tata
Backs Chandrasekaran's third term; says Noel's plan to restructure holding co a damaging step
)
Jimmy, who owns around a 0.81 per cent stake in Tata Sons, has backed a stock exchange listing of Tata Sons, which is at the centre of the biggest corporate battle of the time. (Image Credit: Bloomberg)
Listen to This Article
Jimmy N Tata, the oldest trustee of Tata Trusts and younger brother of former chairman Ratan Tata, has for the first time spoken out on the dispute within the group. The 86-year-old Jimmy, who lives in a modest apartment in Pune and is often described as a recluse, has expressed concern over “unnatural, dictatorial veto powers” granted to the chairman of Tata Trusts, which is the largest shareholder in Tata Sons with a 66 per cent stake.
Jimmy, who owns around 0.81 per cent stake in Tata Sons, has backed the proposed stock exchange listing of Tata Sons — which is at the centre of the biggest corporate battle of the time. “Listing would dismantle the pervasive culture of secrecy, impose statutory accountability, and necessitate rewriting the onerous Articles of Association (AoA) to restore the pre-1989 separation between business operations and welfare trusts,” he’s learnt to have said in a signed statement, following a conversation with Tata Trusts vice-chairman Vijay Singh recently. In the statement, seen by Business Standard, Jimmy has termed the listing of Tata Sons a critical step.
Noel Tata, chairman of Tata Trusts and nominee director on the Tata Sons board, had at a media event on Saturday reiterated his opposition to listing Tata Sons. “Listing will change the Tata way, putting profit ahead of philanthropy,” Noel, who has a 1 per cent shareholding in Tata Sons, had said.
Looking at the recent developments at the group, Jimmy is learnt to have stated that the listing of Tata Sons, as mandated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), is “all the more critical”. Pointing out that Tata Sons previously “benefited immensely when Tata Consultancy Services was taken public under Ratan Tata”, Jimmy said that “any proposal or move by Noel Tata to break up Tata Sons into smaller entities to evade the RBI’s threshold requirements for listing is deeply damaging and contrary to public and shareholder interests, undertaken solely to preserve secrecy, avoid scrutiny, and maintain unchecked personal power.”
The RBI, he said, should enforce strict timelines for listing without delay and ensure that breaking up the group is not permitted. Also, he sought the intervention of the government and the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner “to protect the original objects of the trusts for the people of India”.
Also Read
On the other dispute around reappointment of N Chandrasekaran for a third term as executive chairman of Tata Sons, Jimmy has been quoted as saying: “JRD Tata valued and nurtured his key operating star performers (including Sumant Moolgaonkar, Darbari Seth, Xerxes Desai, and Rusi Modi), whereas the present leadership fails to support its proven star performer.” He said, “Noel sought to block him arbitrarily by invoking the onerous veto provisions in the amended Articles of Association, without providing any justification or accountability”, despite the “overwhelming support” of the Tata Sons board and “unanimous resolution” passed by Tata Trusts for Chandrasekaran’s third term. Jimmy mentioned “bumper dividend payouts” from Tata companies to shareholders, including Tata Sons, in his support for Chandrasekaran.
At the Tata Sons board meeting on September 17, Noel had voted against Chandrasekaran’s third term and opposed the listing proposal. Subsequently, Noel proposed that Tata Sons can be restructured so that it can remain a privately-held entity.
Responding to queries linked to the current situation in Tata Trusts and other widely reported developments in the group, Jimmy said, “A central driver of this issue is the drastic alteration of the Articles of Association around 2013-2014. Historically, under the pre-1989 framework, the Articles strictly separated the welfare trusts from the commercial business operations of Tata Sons, ensuring the Trusts had no operational management role.” He added that the subsequent amendments “fundamentally overturned this balance by granting the Tata Trusts chairman unnatural, dictatorial veto powers and the right to place directors, thereby subverting the collective authority of the rest of the board”.
A trustee at Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT) — a key shareholder trust — since 1989, Jimmy raised the issue of family members occupying the boards of Tata Trusts. “What has transpired in recent time is that the trusts are being filled with family members of the present Tata Trusts chairman, thereby securing a degree of control over Tata Sons that was never the settlors’ intention,” he said. Jimmy argued that it is “entirely inappropriate for more than one family member to serve on a given trust; doing so effectively confers ownership rights over the trusts’ significant shareholding in Tata Sons at no consideration whatsoever”. According to Jimmy, such an arrangement is “untenable and amounts to a back-door takeover of Tata Sons”.
He stressed that trustees are supposed to be custodians of public trusts that can never be dissolved, unlike private family trusts, while talking about “independent luminaries”, such as Nani Palkhivala, Gautam Sarabhai, Homi Sethna, and Homi Bhabha being trustees earlier.
SRTT, which was frozen by the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner earlier this year over perpetual trustee rules, allows only one-fourth of the total board strength as perpetual or lifetime trustees under the amended law. Currently, SRTT has three perpetual trustees — Noel Tata, who’s half brother of Ratan Tata and Jimmy Tata; Jehangir HC Jehangir, industrialist and philanthropist; and Jimmy N Tata. The term of the fourth trustee on SRTT, Venu Srinivasan, is until December 2026, if not renewed further. On a board of four trustees, only one can be a perpetual member. While Jimmy is not on the other key shareholding trust — Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) — he’s a trustee on some other smaller charitable trusts also.
Criticising the lack of uniformity in decisions, including renewal of tenures at Tata Trusts, Jimmy said that introducing a time limit on the tenure of certain trustees while exempting others “has compromised trustee independence and concentrated authority, enabling the marginalisation or removal of trustees who dissent”. Citing the example of Venu Srinivasan, Jimmy said he was targeted because he “opposed the induction of Noel’s son into SRTT”. Neville Tata, Noel Tata’s son, is a trustee on SDTT, but not on SRTT. Neville and his sisters Leah and Maya are on some other trust boards as well.
Jimmy, who mostly stays away from public outings — including Tata Trusts meetings — was at the funeral of his elder brother Ratan Tata on October 10, 2024, in Mumbai.
More From This Section
Don't miss the most important news and views of the day. Get them on our Telegram channel
First Published: Nov 16 2026 | 8:24 AM IST
