You are here: Home » Beyond Business » Features
Business Standard

Chicken dose and don'ts

With reports that poultry is causing antibiotic resistance in humans, how wise is it to eat chicken? The author questions experts and poultry farmers on the issue

Rajat Ghai 

chicken

Until recently, you relished your - wings, breasts, legs and all. That is, before environmentalist and her Delhi-based think-tank, (CSE), claimed that resistance to in humans in India was growing because of indiscriminate use of these drugs by farmers.

CSE made the claim on the basis of a study of 70 samples in and around Delhi. It tested three tissues - muscle, liver and kidney - for the presence of six used widely in poultry: oxytetracycline, chlortetracycline and doxycycline (class tetracyclines); enrofloxacin and ciprofloxacin (class fluoroquinolones) and neomycin (an aminoglycoside). The study found that 40 per cent of the samples contained residues of While 22.9 per cent contained residues of one antibiotic, the remaining 17.1 per cent samples showed residues of more than one antibiotic.


So, should you be concerned? "It would be scare-mongering if the issue were not important. But this concerns our food and health. We should be very serious about getting policy reform undertaken," says Narain.

The industry, however, disagrees vehemently. "Yes, antibiotic resistance is a very serious issue. But you cannot isolate an industry that employs one lakh crore people just because you have found a negligible quantity of in the samples," says Ashok Kumar Sharma, coordinator of the Federation of India, Gurgaon. Several people engaged in the industry argue that farming in this day and age without the use of drugs is impossible. "Given the environment we live in, unless you medically fortify farm animals, you cannot keep them free of disease," says Sonu, a wholesaler from Gokulpuri in Delhi who sells at the Ghazipur mandi in Delhi's trans-Yamuna zone. "Even the vegetables in our diet are full of pesticides. So, should we stop eating them?" he asks.

Narain's report, however, accuses farmers of using to boost muscle growth and not just to prevent diseases. The drugs used cause an inflammation of the gut mucosa, resulting in faster growth. "We use drugs that are certified for use, such as vaccines, and only for therapeutic purposes," says Pradeep Kumar, a farm owner from Panipat in Haryana. "To the best of my knowledge, there are no that can increase the body size of the bird quickly."

Kedarnath Yadav, a chemist who sells veterinary drugs at Bhagirath Palace near Old Delhi's Chandni Chowk, says, "We sell vitamins such as B1, B2, B6, AD3 and such as Neomycin. None of these is harmful for human beings. Besides, we sell only to farmers who have a prescription from a veterinarian."

Animal activists, however, blame the government for the problem. "farms are supported by loans, subsidies and grants from banks behind which is the government. The aim is to grow birds in the fastest possible manner, so that they reach a certain body weight in a matter of days," says Kartick Satyanarayan, cofounder of Wildlife SOS. "And this has to be done with a target of a minimal mortality rate. This cannot be achieved naturally. Thus, artificial, unethical and inhumane methods are used. The government has to stops advocating the pumping of drug into livestock."

Vijay Teng of the Indian Federation of Animal Health Companies, which represents animal health companies, maintains that "regulatory guidelines" on the use of in are in place. "That is absolutely not factual," counters Narain. "There is a Bureau of Indian Standards guideline for farming, but it is not mandatory. The Drugs Controller of India and the agriculture ministry have sent advisories to owners that they should not use " Antibiotics, she says, should only be prescribed for therapeutic purposes and not to encourage growth or prevent disease. "However, we have seen that across the world it is very difficult to distinguish between meant for different purposes."

Her solution to the current situation: "Do not eat till the government sets mandatory standards. Your renunciation would affect sales and consequently, put pressure on the government. Or, just harass the life out of your supplier to make sure that there is minimal antibiotic content in your "

ALSO WATCH OUT FOR
is also contaminated with growth hormones and an anti-microbial called These are used to increase size. is believed to be the source of arsenic contamination in

First Published: Sat, August 09 2014. 00:15 IST
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU