A big rap on the knuckles for Sebi

The SC on Friday came down heavily on Sebi in the matter against the Sahara group companies

The on Friday came down heavily on the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) in the matter against the Sahara group companies. The court has shown frustration at the manner in which the regulator has been dragging its feet after getting one of the most path-breaking and crystal-clear orders for action. It even accused the parties of “mutually agreeing to violate the order”. This is serious.

On August 31, the court had given a full 10 days for and Corp to file details of all the investors and the outstanding sum. Till August 2011, these firms had collected Rs 24,029 crore from some 30 million investors.

Could the regulator not have taken the initiative and clearly worked out what it wanted the group to do in those 10 days and what are the legal consequences it would face if the compliance was not satisfactory?

Somehow, the regulator which had shown its warface in the legal battle for the past two years is looking lost. So lost, that the court had to tell that it cannot expect some kind of handholding.

“If they do not comply with it, take action as per law. It is the duty of Sebi to comply with the judgment also. We are not here to hold the hands of Sebi and tell what it should do,” the bench said on Friday.

Fifty days have passed and there has been no concrete action, as the court observed. In fact, the regulator has ceded the initiative to the violator and allowed it to spin stories involving non-living objects such as trucks, Xerox machines and piles of paper, which the media has duly published, without analysing whether such cock-and-bull stories hold water in this iPhone age.

Sahara’s media hyperbole seems to have cramped the regulator, already on the backfoot lacking a clear strategy on how to go about this massive operation of impounding assets and freezing bank accounts. It also seems to be sitting on proof of the Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures’ money being transferred to new plans such as Sahara Q Shop. Reports by Mint, Reuters and MoneyLife talk about agents asking people, and in cases threatening, to transfer existing deposits to such newer plans.

Precious little has been done to stop this. Further, freezing of bank accounts may be of little use as over a year ago, Business Standard had reported that the companies were using bank accounts of Sahara India Parivar, the partnership firm. Attaching properties could be another headache. For example, in Amby Valley, one of the marquee properties of the group, several other entities also have ownership - only a part of the equity was held by the above two entities. Probably, the regulator doesn’t want to get into further messy legal battles. It doesn’t want to lose the significant ground it has gained already. But, the best way to defend that ground is to attack. At least, that is what the highest court of the land has just told the mandarins of Bandra Kurla, with a big rap on the knuckles.

image
Business Standard
177 22
Business Standard

A big rap on the knuckles for Sebi

The SC on Friday came down heavily on Sebi in the matter against the Sahara group companies

N Sundaresha Subramanian  |  New Delhi 



The on Friday came down heavily on the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) in the matter against the Sahara group companies. The court has shown frustration at the manner in which the regulator has been dragging its feet after getting one of the most path-breaking and crystal-clear orders for action. It even accused the parties of “mutually agreeing to violate the order”. This is serious.

On August 31, the court had given a full 10 days for and Corp to file details of all the investors and the outstanding sum. Till August 2011, these firms had collected Rs 24,029 crore from some 30 million investors.

Could the regulator not have taken the initiative and clearly worked out what it wanted the group to do in those 10 days and what are the legal consequences it would face if the compliance was not satisfactory?

Somehow, the regulator which had shown its warface in the legal battle for the past two years is looking lost. So lost, that the court had to tell that it cannot expect some kind of handholding.

“If they do not comply with it, take action as per law. It is the duty of Sebi to comply with the judgment also. We are not here to hold the hands of Sebi and tell what it should do,” the bench said on Friday.

Fifty days have passed and there has been no concrete action, as the court observed. In fact, the regulator has ceded the initiative to the violator and allowed it to spin stories involving non-living objects such as trucks, Xerox machines and piles of paper, which the media has duly published, without analysing whether such cock-and-bull stories hold water in this iPhone age.

Sahara’s media hyperbole seems to have cramped the regulator, already on the backfoot lacking a clear strategy on how to go about this massive operation of impounding assets and freezing bank accounts. It also seems to be sitting on proof of the Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures’ money being transferred to new plans such as Sahara Q Shop. Reports by Mint, Reuters and MoneyLife talk about agents asking people, and in cases threatening, to transfer existing deposits to such newer plans.

Precious little has been done to stop this. Further, freezing of bank accounts may be of little use as over a year ago, Business Standard had reported that the companies were using bank accounts of Sahara India Parivar, the partnership firm. Attaching properties could be another headache. For example, in Amby Valley, one of the marquee properties of the group, several other entities also have ownership - only a part of the equity was held by the above two entities. Probably, the regulator doesn’t want to get into further messy legal battles. It doesn’t want to lose the significant ground it has gained already. But, the best way to defend that ground is to attack. At least, that is what the highest court of the land has just told the mandarins of Bandra Kurla, with a big rap on the knuckles.

RECOMMENDED FOR YOU

A big rap on the knuckles for Sebi

The SC on Friday came down heavily on Sebi in the matter against the Sahara group companies

The Supreme Court on Friday came down heavily on the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) in the matter against the Sahara group companies. The court has shown frustration at the manner in which the regulator has been dragging its feet after getting one of the most path-breaking and crystal-clear orders for action. It even accused the parties of “mutually agreeing to violate the order”. This is serious.

The on Friday came down heavily on the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) in the matter against the Sahara group companies. The court has shown frustration at the manner in which the regulator has been dragging its feet after getting one of the most path-breaking and crystal-clear orders for action. It even accused the parties of “mutually agreeing to violate the order”. This is serious.

On August 31, the court had given a full 10 days for and Corp to file details of all the investors and the outstanding sum. Till August 2011, these firms had collected Rs 24,029 crore from some 30 million investors.

Could the regulator not have taken the initiative and clearly worked out what it wanted the group to do in those 10 days and what are the legal consequences it would face if the compliance was not satisfactory?

Somehow, the regulator which had shown its warface in the legal battle for the past two years is looking lost. So lost, that the court had to tell that it cannot expect some kind of handholding.

“If they do not comply with it, take action as per law. It is the duty of Sebi to comply with the judgment also. We are not here to hold the hands of Sebi and tell what it should do,” the bench said on Friday.

Fifty days have passed and there has been no concrete action, as the court observed. In fact, the regulator has ceded the initiative to the violator and allowed it to spin stories involving non-living objects such as trucks, Xerox machines and piles of paper, which the media has duly published, without analysing whether such cock-and-bull stories hold water in this iPhone age.

Sahara’s media hyperbole seems to have cramped the regulator, already on the backfoot lacking a clear strategy on how to go about this massive operation of impounding assets and freezing bank accounts. It also seems to be sitting on proof of the Optionally Fully Convertible Debentures’ money being transferred to new plans such as Sahara Q Shop. Reports by Mint, Reuters and MoneyLife talk about agents asking people, and in cases threatening, to transfer existing deposits to such newer plans.

Precious little has been done to stop this. Further, freezing of bank accounts may be of little use as over a year ago, Business Standard had reported that the companies were using bank accounts of Sahara India Parivar, the partnership firm. Attaching properties could be another headache. For example, in Amby Valley, one of the marquee properties of the group, several other entities also have ownership - only a part of the equity was held by the above two entities. Probably, the regulator doesn’t want to get into further messy legal battles. It doesn’t want to lose the significant ground it has gained already. But, the best way to defend that ground is to attack. At least, that is what the highest court of the land has just told the mandarins of Bandra Kurla, with a big rap on the knuckles.

image
Business Standard
177 22

LIVE MARKET

BSE

  ( %)

NSE

  ( %)

More News

  • Bargain hunters keep gold steady, eye US jobs data Bargain hunters keep gold steady, eye US jobs data
  • TD Power Systems surges on winning order from multi-national company TD Power Systems surges on order win from major MNC

STOCK WATCH

Company Price() Chg(%)
Dr Lal Pathlabs 1003.00 8.73
G M D C 98.30 8.44
Jubilant Life 546.80 7.65
Hatsun AgroProd. 350.00 5.71
Sundram Fasten. 294.25 5.66
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
G M D C 98.35 8.43
Jubilant Life 546.60 7.36
Sundram Fasten. 294.45 5.80
India Cements 151.50 5.76
Radico Khaitan 101.50 5.13
> More on NSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Welspun India 46.35 -4.92
R C F 47.30 -4.83
Den Networks 81.00 -3.74
Trident 56.00 -3.45
Bharti Airtel 331.25 -3.07
> More on BSE Gainers
Company Price() Chg(%)
Welspun India 46.05 -4.95
R C F 47.30 -4.92
Den Networks 80.70 -3.99
Trident 55.95 -3.62
Bharti Airtel 330.85 -3.43
> More on NSE Gainers
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Derivatives

Index
Instrument Type
Expiry Date
Option Type
Strike Price

Upgrade To Premium Services

Welcome User

Business Standard is happy to inform you of the launch of "Business Standard Premium Services"

As a premium subscriber you get an across device unfettered access to a range of services which include:

  • Access Exclusive content - articles, features & opinion pieces
  • Weekly Industry/Genre specific newsletters - Choose multiple industries/genres
  • Access to 17 plus years of content archives
  • Set Stock price alerts for your portfolio and watch list and get them delivered to your e-mail box
  • End of day news alerts on 5 companies (via email)
  • NEW: Get seamless access to WSJ.com at a great price. No additional sign-up required.
 

Premium Services

In Partnership with

 

Dear Guest,

 

Welcome to the premium services of Business Standard brought to you courtesy FIS.
Kindly visit the Manage my subscription page to discover the benefits of this programme.

Enjoy Reading!
Team Business Standard