New Document top_band
 
Business Standard

Vinayak Chatterjee: The enemy within

It is ridiculous to make the task of clearing sovereign obstacles the private sector's core competence

Related News

Ask any infrastructure developer and he will tell you that the biggest risk factor is the government itself. The “sovereign” does not inspire confidence when, paradoxically, in financial markets, sovereign debt and sovereign guarantees are supposedly the safest you can get. Infrastructure developers will also tell you that the situation is akin to being invited to dinner as a valued guest; and as soon as you arrive at your host’s gate, you get roughed up, beaten and sometimes even killed by the guards on duty. The , lest we forget, is “invited” to “bid” for public utilities by the sovereign. Private capital is “welcomed”. Half of the nation’s trillion-dollar infra development is to be done by valued and esteemed private sector “invitees”.

So, Kafkaesquely, while one arm of the sovereign invites and welcomes, 65 other arms – security men who guard the host’s gates – rough up the invitee. (Click here for table)

The enemy is within!

Why private enterprises should be beaten and bruised in the process of is the biggest riddle of our times. Well, the time has come to force the sovereign to clear obstacles it has itself placed on the path to speedy implementation. The private sector, with one voice, should say clearing sovereign obstacles is not its core competence. And that the sovereign cannot abdicate its responsibility of clearing the minefield.

Here are three ways to bite the bullet.

One, infrastructure ministry: This column had set out 10 “good” reasons to have one (“From policy paralysis to action station,” April 16). One of the principal reasons was to have a nodal body for securing all “sovereign permissions” in a purposive, time-bound and facilitative manner. The column even suggested that the current statistics and programme implementation ministry could well be re-fashioned into a new-age infra ministry, and statistics could be handed over to the .

Two, sovereign-incubated special purpose vehicle (SPV): Over and above the infra ministry, one of the finest moves possible is to have sponsoring sarkari authorities first set up 100 per cent sarkari-owned SPVs to implement a project. In its sarkari avatar, this SPV should secure all permissions and clearances. Then, it should bid out the SPV to the highest bidder. In mid-May, the Prime Minister’s Office woke up to the immense practical possibilities of this move when it circulated a note suggesting this to all economic ministries. This should be done right away.

Three, penalties on sponsoring authorities: In future, let all infra public-private-partnership (PPP) bids carry a special annexure listing 100 per cent of the permissions required, clearly delineating the responsibilities of the sovereign sponsoring authority. The bid legalese must impose severe penalties for delays on the sponsoring authority if it fails to keep its side of the bargain and does not act and behave as a responsible PPP partner. Get babudom and its political leadership to be publicly and monetarily accountable. Otherwise, let them not merely bid out as bemused observers.

The prime ministerial announcement of June 1, 2012, of “an investment-tracking mechanism to expedite the implementation of big ticket projects” did not lead to any surge of adrenalin. In fact, it was seen to be nothing more than navel-gazing and a knee-jerk PR effort immediately after the announcement of disastrous GDP numbers. The infra meeting of the PM on June 6 saw the delivery of homilies and platitudes and a laundry-list of new projects, producing nothing more than a yawn.

It’s time to get real. Gentlemen, let’s go for real solutions.


 

The author is chairman of Feedback Infrastructure. These views are personal. vinayak.chatterjee@feedbackinfra.com  

Read more on:   
|
|
|
|

Read More

Kishore Singh: Venice the menace

The Brazilian honeymooner was my age by any reckoning, his glamorous bride a little younger, and like us they’d reserved berths in the overnighter ...

Most Popular Columnists

A K Bhattacharya

A K Bhattacharya: Two months and two signals
A K Bhattacharya

The political climate in this country has perhaps convinced the BJP that only incremental reforms administered in small doses can work

Vanita Kohli-Khandekar

Vanita Kohli-Khandekar: Welcoming FDI in news
Vanita Kohli-Khandekar

Allowing foreign investment will push media firms to clean up their act and put in place systems that will allow good journalism to flourish

Pranay Kotasthane

Pranay Kotasthane: The lure of legalising bilateral disputes
Pranay Kotasthane

The Permanent Court of Arbitration verdict on the India-Bangladesh maritime dispute, which largely upholds the Bangladeshi claim, has important lessons for India's Saarc policy

Advertisement

Columnists

Kenneth Rogoff

Kenneth Rogoff: Europe's debt wish
Kenneth Rogoff

Structural reforms and fiscal austerity fall far short of being a complete solution to Europe's debt problems

Devangshu Datta

Devangshu Datta: The US biologist who changed India
Devangshu Datta

The Green Revolution owes a debt to Norman Borlaug, whose birth centenary falls this year

Hussain Yasa

Hussain Yasa: Is the Afghan electoral deadlock broken?
Hussain Yasa

The deal to audit votes cast in the third presidential polls marks a small but uncertain step towards a durable political transition

Back to Top